Vehicle Forfeiture After a Drug Stop.

3. Will criminal charges prevent it? Explain how it is possible to be charged with drug-related crimes and to be charged with the corresponding forfeiture, as well as how it is possible to be cleared of the charges but to still face forfeiture.

4. What are the forfeiture levels? This section will explain the types of forfeiture that may be sought. These are criminal forfeiture, civil forfeiture, and administrative forfeiture.

Article ###

Is a Vehicle Forfeiture Automatic After a Drug Stop?

Drug-related forfeiture is a type of civil forfeiture under which the government targets property alleged to have been involved with controlled-substance activity . Drug law forfeiture laws include provisions for civil forfeiture, criminal forfeiture, and administrative forfeiture. These represent the “three levels of forfeiture” and each have their own rules and are dealt with by federal agents and prosecutors in the appropriate ways.

Can It Be Triggered Without an Arrest?

Yes, civil forfeiture can be triggered without an arrest. In addition to having no connection to an arrest, civil forfeiture does not have to be tied to any criminal charge. It can be initiated as an alternative to pressing criminal charges in some cases, which will be true in most cases involving a drug stop .

Will Criminal Charges Prevent It?

No, not necessarily. For example, if a criminal charge is filed against someone in addition to the forfeiture charge, it could lead to a guilty or not-guilty verdict. However, the criminal case and the forfeiture proceeding are separate matters, although the criminal case may affect the forfeiture proceeding under the applicable law.

When a defendant is found not guilty in a criminal trial, the prosecution can still pursue the property for the related civil charges. The same applies if you were never arrested. However, you should talk to your defense attorney as soon as possible since there are several legal defenses you can use to avoid having your vehicle taken away from you for good.

What are the Forfeiture Levels?

When it comes to drug cases, the three forfeiture levels are:

• Criminal Forfeiture, Criminal forfeiture is the first of the three levels of forfeiture, and it is often the most common one. This type of forfeiture happens at the conclusion of a criminal trial. If found guilty of the charged offense, the court can order the defendant to forfeit property involved in the criminal activity.
• Civil Forfeiture, Civil forfeiture is a legal proceeding in which the government asserts the owners’ property is involved in a crime, and the government takes over the property. Civil forfeiture is not considered a punishment in the same way as criminal forfeiture.
• Administrative Forfeiture, Administrative forfeiture is a type of forfeiture that does not involve the court system. It occurs when the government takes a vehicle that it has determined is involved in a criminal activity, and no one comes forward to challenge the seizure.

Which Notice Deadline Protects a Seized Vehicle Claim?

If your vehicle has been seized after a drug stop and you are located in Tennessee or New York, here are a few key notice deadlines and requirements that may apply:

Tennessee

In Tennessee, the government must follow several procedural steps when attempting to forfeit seized vehicles in drug cases:

• The notice must explain how to contest the forfeiture. If the notice does not explain how to contest the forfeiture and the method for filing a claim for the vehicle, the forfeiture may be procedurally flawed.
• The notice must provide a deadline for filing a claim to get the vehicle back. If you fail to file within the deadline, you may lose your right to seek the vehicle’s return.
• To successfully contest the seizure, your vehicle forfeiture claim must be filed within the required statutory period. This statutory period can vary depending on the circumstances, and it’s essential to ensure your claim is filed on time to preserve your rights.
• Notice of the intent to seize property in Tennessee is usually sent by certified mail. Tennessee law requires the government to send the notice to all “reasonably located” interested persons. This includes not only the vehicle’s registered owner but also the vehicle’s driver.
• After receiving notice that a forfeiture warrant has been issued, a claimant generally must file a written claim requesting a hearing with the applicable agency within 30 days.

New York

If your vehicle has been seized in New York, the notice deadlines are different. When federal authorities seize a vehicle during a drug stop, they are generally required to serve a notice of the seizure to the vehicle’s owner and driver. This notice generally must be sent as soon as practicable and no later than 60 days after the date of seizure, or no later than 90 days when state or local law enforcement seized the property and turned it over to a federal agency for federal forfeiture.

Failure to serve notice within this timeframe can impact the government’s ability to pursue forfeiture. However, this is just one aspect of the forfeiture process, and it is important to consult with a lawyer to determine your next steps. In drug cases, the law enforcement agency must also prove that the vehicle was used to facilitate the commission of a crime. The stronger your claim that you have a legal right to the property, the better your chances of avoiding forfeiture.

The firm's New York office sits at 233 Broadway, a short walk from the federal courthouse in lower Manhattan.

How Does a Tennessee Seizure Move Toward Final Forfeiture?

If you find yourself facing vehicle forfeiture following a drug stop in Tennessee, it is important to be well aware of how the process works. In addition to several other possible statutes, the drug-related forfeiture statute that may come into play is Tenn. Code Ann. § 53-11-451. Generally, forfeiture procedures are outlined at Tenn. Code Ann. §§ 40-33-201 onward.

Some key statutes, including Tenn. Code Ann. § 40-33-203, Tenn. Code Ann. § 40-33-204, and Tenn. Code Ann. § 40-33-207, govern various aspects of the process from service to notice to hearing procedures.

How Does the Administrative Review Process in Tennessee Work?

If your vehicle has been seized in Tennessee, you can read more about the administrative review process in the pages of the Tennessee judicial branch. One part of that administrative review process includes seeking a hearing before an Administrative Law Judge assigned by the Secretary of State’s Administrative Procedures Division. The purpose of this hearing is to determine the validity of the vehicle’s seizure and whether the vehicle needs to be forfeited or returned to the original owner.

According to the U.S. Department of Justice website, the administrative review process begins with the law enforcement officer submitting a forfeiture warrant to a local judge. The forfeiture warrant must explain the evidence the officer has found to support the seizure. If the local judge determines the law enforcement agency has good reason to hold the vehicle for a potential forfeiture, the forfeiture warrant will be approved and the forfeiture process will move forward.

What Is the Timeline for Final Forfeiture?

Because drug-related vehicle forfeiture is a civil rather than criminal matter, the government does not have to prove that the vehicle’s owner or driver committed a crime. Instead, they must prove that the vehicle was used to commit the crime of selling drugs. This means that you can still avoid forfeiture even if you have not received any criminal charges related to the drug stop. The time it will take to achieve final forfeiture varies from case to case. However, you must respond in order to avoid losing your vehicle. Our federal criminal defense attorneys have a good understanding of how to fight for the return of seized vehicles, and we will do everything we can to save your vehicle.

What Defenses Can an Owner Use Against Vehicle Forfeiture?

If your vehicle was seized following a drug stop in Tennessee or any other state, you may have various procedural or constitutional defenses. For example, you can challenge the legality of the initial traffic stop, argue that the stop lasted longer than was necessary, or contest the validity of a canine deployment or search warrant. Our Tennessee vehicle seizure defense attorneys and consultants are intimately familiar with the nuances of these issues, and we can determine whether you have the right arguments to challenge the vehicle’s seizure.

In addition to procedural and constitutional issues, these are some common defenses against vehicle forfeiture in drug cases:

Insufficiency of Evidence

The government bears the burden of proving that your vehicle was used to facilitate the commission of a crime. For example, the government will need to prove that your vehicle was used for transporting or selling illegal drugs. If there is no evidence showing a connection between your vehicle and criminal activity, you will be able to defend against the forfeiture case.

Innocent-Owner Defense

If you own a vehicle but were not involved in the criminal activity in question, you may be able to raise the “innocent-owner defense.” This defense can protect owners who were unaware of the illegal use of their vehicles. It can also protect co-owners who were not involved in the criminal conduct that triggered the forfeiture.

Conduct of Another Driver

While the innocent-owner defense protects those not involved in a crime, the vehicle owner may have other grounds for avoiding forfeiture if another individual’s illegal conduct was responsible for the drug stop and seizure. We can work to help you convince the court that you are not responsible for the driver’s actions, if applicable, and that your vehicle should be returned.

Lack of Knowledge

Many innocent-owner defenses focus on lack of knowledge of a vehicle’s criminal use. If you had no knowledge that your vehicle was used for committing crimes, then this fact alone should be sufficient to avoid forfeiture. With this said, you must be able to convince the court that you are an innocent owner, and we can provide counsel to help you avoid forfeiture.

Proof of Lawful Ownership

Establishing proof of lawful ownership can also be an important defense against vehicle forfeiture in criminal cases. In some circumstances, it can be as simple as proving that you own the vehicle and did not know about its illegal use.

Evidence Suppression

Finally, if the evidence that sparked the forfeiture case was obtained illegally, this too can be used as a defense. Although this is a common defense in criminal cases, it is also a viable defense to civil forfeiture proceedings. If you can get the evidence suppressed, the government will not have the information necessary to prove your vehicle was involved in a crime.

Speak With a Federal Defense Lawyer

If you are dealing with any part of what this article describes, the next step is a conversation with a lawyer who handles these cases. Spodek Law Group is a second generation criminal defense firm practicing since 1976, representing clients nationwide from offices in New York, Brooklyn, Queens and Los Angeles. Call 888 348 8028 to speak with our team.