ATTORNEY ON CALL · 24/7
212 300 5196
FROM THE DEFENSE DESK / CRIMINAL DEFENSE
12 AUG 2025 · 4 MIN READ · BY TODD A. SPODEK
THE BRIEF · FILED UNDER: FBI · SCAMS
DOCKET NO. 025 · THE DEFENSE DESK

Would an FBI agent text me?

Almost never - and never to demand money, gift cards, or your Social Security number. But real agents do call, email, and knock. Telling the scam from the genuine article is worth getting right, because both are dangerous in different ways.

Todd A. Spodek
Todd A. Spodek
MANAGING PARTNER · 12 AUG 2025 · 4 MIN READ
★★★★★1,100+ FIVE-STAR GOOGLE REVIEWS
SUPER LAWYERS · 2020-25AVVO · “SUPERB”SECOND GENERATION · SINCE 1976
AS SEEN ON NETFLIX · CNN · FOX NEWS · NY POST

The short answer.

The FBI does not initiate investigations by text message. Agents identify themselves in person with credentials, call from official lines, or send letters and grand jury subpoenas through counsel or certified mail. A text claiming to be the FBI - especially one demanding payment, threatening immediate arrest, or containing a link - is a scam with a near-100% certainty. Real federal agencies do not accept gift cards, crypto, or wire transfers to “clear a warrant.” There is no such transaction anywhere in the federal system.

The tells, in both directions.

Scam tells: urgency measured in minutes, payment demands, caller-ID spoofing of real field office numbers, grammar that wobbles, links to “verify your identity.” Genuine tells: two agents at your door with credentials, a business card with a real field office callback, a certified letter, or - the serious one - a grand jury subpoena or target letter with a case number and an AUSA’s name. Verification is simple: hang up, look up the field office number yourself, and ask the switchboard for the agent by name. Never use the number the message gave you.

One more wrinkle: scammers now impersonate agents investigating the scam that just took your money. The “recovery” call is round two of the same fraud.

IF THIS IS YOUR SITUATION
Stop reading. Start defending.

If the contact is real.

A genuine agent reaching out means an investigation exists and your name is in it - as witness, subject, or target. The correct response is identical in all three cases: be polite, take the card, confirm nothing, explain nothing, and say your lawyer will call. Real agents expect this; it does not offend them, and it cannot be used against you. What hurts you is the doorstep interview you gave because refusing felt rude.

Either way, the next call is the same.

Scam: report it to IC3.gov and your bank, and touch nothing in the message. Real: federal defense counsel, same day - we call the agent, learn your status, and take the conversation out of your living room. Both roads run through the same rule: you talking to “the FBI,” real or fake, is the thing that costs you.

Todd A. Spodek
THE AUTHOR
Todd A. Spodek
Managing partner. Second-generation federal defense lawyer - the Netflix defense, the Fox and CNN analyst chair, and two decades of federal courtrooms.
Meet Todd →
LEGAL INFORMATION, NOT LEGAL ADVICE · EVERY CASE TURNS ON ITS FACTS · ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
THE AUTHOR'S RECORD · PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE A SIMILAR OUTCOME
Acquitted.
$26M MONEY LAUNDERING
Dismissed.
RICO · 10-YEAR MINIMUM FACED
Six months.
$12M PONZI · YEARS ASKED
ALL RESULTS →
★★★★★VERIFIED CLIENT · FEDERAL CASE · 2022 · VIA GOOGLE REVIEWS
"By the time our free consultation was over, we left at ease."
1,100+ FIVE-STAR GOOGLE REVIEWS →
RISK FREE · CONFIDENTIAL · 24/7

Reading is good. Calling is better.

Answered within 24 hours, guaranteed. Some stories are better told out loud -

212 300 5196
AFTER YOU REACH OUT
01A person answers - not a service. Day or night. 02Free, confidential consultation - ask us anything, regardless of how long it takes. 03Strategy starts the same day - and you hold the senior partner's cell number.
★★★★★1,100+ FIVE-STAR GOOGLE REVIEWS
READ THEM →
INTAKE · PRIVILEGED & CONFIDENTIAL
24/7
01
02
03
04
05
ANSWERED WITHIN 24 HOURS, GUARANTEED OR CALL 212 300 5196
EVERYTHING YOU SHARE IS PROTECTED BY ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE FROM THE FIRST WORD.