Charged with illegal brass knuckles: what happens now.

What the charge looks like.

In ban states the count is simple possession of a prohibited weapon: a misdemeanor in New York (criminal possession of a weapon in the fourth degree - up to a year), a wobbler in California (PC 21810 - up to three years as a felony), and equivalents across the prohibition map. Aggravators move it up fast: possession plus intent to use, possession by someone with priors, possession on school grounds, or knuckles produced during any altercation - at which point the file reads aggravated assault and the knuckles become the enhancement.

Where these cases get won.

First, the search. Knuckles are found, not reported - which means a stop, a frisk, or a vehicle search preceded the charge, and each has constitutional requirements the government must satisfy. A frisk that exceeded Terry’s scope, a car search without probable cause or consent, a “inventory” that was really an investigation - suppression of the object is dismissal of the case. Second, the definition: not every hard object worn on a hand meets the statute, and plastic, novelty, and costume items generate triable definitional fights. Third, knowledge: a borrowed car, a shared apartment, a backpack packed by someone else - possession requires knowing the thing was there, and the government has to prove it.

Why the disposition label matters.

A “weapons conviction” - even a misdemeanor - echoes: immigration consequences, professional license questions, future firearm rights analyses, and the aggravating paragraph in any later case. Resolutions that land as disorderly conduct or non-weapon violations cost the same fine and none of the future. That is the negotiation, and it is worth having counsel run it. The consultation is free - bring the police report.

THE AUTHOR

Todd A. Spodek

Managing partner. Second-generation federal defense lawyer - the Netflix defense, the Fox and CNN analyst chair, and two decades of federal courtrooms.

Meet Todd →