NATIONALLY RECOGNIZED FEDERAL LAWYERS
What is false statement in immigration documents
|Thanks for visiting Spodek Law Group. We’re a second-generation law firm managed by Todd Spodek, with over 40 years of combined experience handling cases that others say were unwinnable. You’ve probably heard of some of our work – we represented Anna Delvey in her Netflix series case, handled the Ghislaine Maxwell juror misconduct matter, and defended clients in the Alec Baldwin stalking case. If you’re reading this article, you’re probably worried about something you wrote on an immigration form – and you should be. False statements in immigration documents destroy lives, they end cases before they start.
This article explains what counts as a false statement in immigration documents, the criminal and immigration penalties you face, and what limited options exist once the government discovers the lie.
The Two Laws That Destroy Your Immigration Case
Two legal provisions control false statement cases – 18 U.S.C. § 1001 for criminal prosecution and INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(i) for immigration consequences. They work together to destroy your case from both sides.
Under 18 U.S.C. § 1001, it’s a federal crime to knowingly make a false statement to any government agency. That includes USCIS, ICE, the State Department, CBP. The statute doesn’t care if your lie worked. Making the false statement is the crime. Federal prosecutors in 2025 are charging these cases aggressively. Marcelo Soto-Luna got 7 months in federal prison in May 2025 for lying on a DACA application. Anibal Rios-Lavias faces 20 years for fraudulently obtaining citizenship.
The immigration side is worse. INA § 212(a)(6)(C)(i) says that any alien who, by fraud or willfully misrepresenting a material fact, seeks to procure a visa, documentation, admission, or any immigration benefit is inadmissible. The penalty is a lifetime bar from the United States. No statute of limitations applies. USCIS can discover a lie you told 15 years ago and permanently bar you. The agency announced in 2025 that it’s restoring robust screening to catch people who use false information.
What Actually Counts as a False Statement
People think false statements mean dramatic lies – fake identities, forged documents, completely fabricated stories. Most false statement cases involve smaller misrepresentations that applicants convinced themselves didn’t matter.
Saying you never worked without authorization when you did side jobs for cash. Claiming you were never arrested when you had a DUI dismissed years ago. Listing a bachelor’s degree you didn’t quite finish. Saying you’re single when you’re legally married but separated. Omitting a child from another relationship.
These are material misrepresentations, every single one creates inadmissibility, and people make them constantly because they think USCIS won’t check. USCIS checks. They always check. Background investigations pull arrest records, employment histories, tax filings, previous visa applications. When your current application contradicts information in government databases, the agency knows immediately.
The misrepresentation has to be “material” and “willful” for the lifetime bar to apply. Material means the false information might have led the officer to deny your application. Willful means you knew it was false when you wrote it. Courts interpret “material” broadly – almost any false answer on a visa application is material.
Criminal Penalties Are Real and Getting More Common
Federal prosecutors don’t charge every false statement case criminally, but prosecution rates are climbing in 2025. Prosecutors target marriage fraud schemes, U visa fraud where applicants pay corrupt police officers to file false crime reports, false claims to U.S. citizenship, fraudulent naturalization.
The criminal penalties are severe. Up to 5 years in federal prison for false statements under 18 U.S.C. § 1001. Up to 10 years for visa fraud. Up to 20 years for fraudulently obtaining citizenship. Recent 2025 prosecutions show defendants getting multi-year federal sentences, not probation, actual Bureau of Prisons custody.
If you’re convicted of immigration fraud criminally, your immigration case is over. The conviction makes you inadmissible and deportable. No waiver exists for most fraud convictions. Even if you have U.S. citizen children, a U.S. citizen spouse – the criminal conviction ends your case.
The Lifetime Immigration Bar and the Nearly Impossible Waiver
Most people caught making false statements never face criminal charges but still lose everything immigration-wise. USCIS denies the application, issues a Notice to Appear, and the person ends up in immigration court fighting deportation with a fraud finding on their record.
The lifetime bar is permanent unless you qualify for a waiver. Only one waiver exists – the I-601 waiver for fraud and misrepresentation. To get it, you must prove that refusing to admit you would cause extreme hardship to your U.S. citizen or lawful permanent resident spouse or parent. Not hardship to you, not hardship to your children – hardship to your qualifying relative.
Extreme hardship is a high standard. Financial difficulties aren’t enough. Separation isn’t enough by itself. You need medical conditions, psychological harm, country conditions that would devastate your qualifying relative. USCIS denies most I-601 waivers.
False claims to U.S. citizenship are worse – no waiver exists except in extremely limited circumstances. If you checked a box saying you’re a U.S. citizen to get a job or obtain any benefit, you’re permanently inadmissible. The only exception applies if you had a U.S. citizen parent, you lived in the U.S. before age 16, and reasonably believed you were a citizen. Almost nobody qualifies.
When These Cases Get Caught
People think they got away with a false statement because USCIS approved their application. The lie catches up later – at a naturalization interview, during a green card renewal, when CBP pulls you aside at the airport.
Immigration officers at later stages have access to all your prior applications. When you apply for naturalization, the officer reviews every visa application you ever filed, every statement you made at every border crossing. Inconsistencies trigger fraud investigations. Sometimes ex-spouses report marriage fraud, coworkers report employment fraud. USCIS investigates tips aggressively.
What You Should Do If You’re Facing This
If you already submitted an application with false information and it’s pending, file an amendment or correction immediately with an attorney’s help. Explain that you made an error, provide the correct information. This doesn’t guarantee USCIS will overlook the false statement, but it’s better than getting caught in the lie at an interview.
If USCIS already discovered the false statement and issued a denial or Notice to Appear, you need an attorney who handles immigration fraud cases specifically. Most immigration attorneys don’t regularly handle fraud findings, they don’t know how to argue materiality and willfulness, they don’t know how to build I-601 waivers.
Don’t try to fix immigration fraud issues yourself. Officers are trained to detect fraud, they ask questions designed to trap you, and anything you say can be used against you criminally.
At Spodek Law Group, our immigration attorneys have defended clients in fraud cases involving false statements on visa applications, naturalization fraud, marriage fraud allegations. Our managing partner Todd Spodek is a second-generation criminal defense and immigration attorney who has handled hundreds of cases involving federal charges and immigration consequences. We’ve represented clients in high-stakes matters that others said were unwinnable.
If you’re thinking about lying on an immigration form – don’t. The consequences are permanent. If you already made a false statement and you’re facing consequences, contact us for a consultation. We’ll review what happened, explain your options, and fight for the best possible outcome.