NATIONALLY RECOGNIZED FEDERAL LAWYERS
What are the fines and penalties for Corporate Fraud ?
|Last Updated on: 4th October 2025, 10:52 pm
Corporate Fraud Defense – The Real Costs Nobody Tells You About
I’m Todd Spodek, and I’ve defended executives and companies facing corporate fraud charges that destroyed billion-dollar enterprises overnight. When the DOJ Criminal Division targets your company, they don’t just want fines – they want to make an example that ends careers, triggers personal bankruptcy, and sends executives to federal prison for decades. The Alternative Fines Act permits fines of twice the gross gain or loss under 18 U.S.C. § 3571(d), which means that $10 million fraud becomes a $20 million fine, plus disgorgement, plus monitors, plus shareholder lawsuits. But here’s what kills companies: the parallel proceedings death spiral where SEC civil actions, DOJ criminal prosecutions, and shareholder derivative suits all demand different defenses that contradict each other.
The Parallel Proceedings Trap That Destroys Companies
The government deliberately coordinates parallel civil and criminal investigations to maximize leverage. The SEC files civil charges requiring immediate response under preponderance of evidence standard, forcing you to take positions that DOJ criminal prosecutors then use against you under the higher beyond-reasonable-doubt standard. You can’t plead the Fifth in SEC proceedings without adverse inference instructions that guarantee you lose the civil case. But if you testify, those statements become admissions in the criminal case. Meanwhile, shareholders file derivative suits that demand document production the government then subpoenas.
I’ve watched this destroy companies worth billions. The SEC demands Wells notices within 30 days. DOJ sends target letters demanding proffers within two weeks. State attorneys general pile on with their own investigations. Each proceeding has different standards, different discovery rules, different privilege protections. Your lawyers in one case are making arguments that hurt you in another case. The government counts on this chaos because confused companies make mistakes that become additional charges under 18 U.S.C. § 1001 for false statements or 18 U.S.C. § 1512 for obstruction.
Why Your Compliance Program Will Be Used Against You
Corporate compliance programs are supposed to reduce liability, but prosecutors weaponize them to prove knowledge and intent. That ethics hotline you established becomes evidence you knew about problems. Those training materials about FCPA compliance prove you understood the law you’re accused of violating. The internal audit that found control weaknesses becomes the roadmap prosecutors use to prove willful blindness under the conscious avoidance doctrine.
The DOJ’s own Criminal Division guidance under Deputy Attorney General Monaco’s 2022 memo requires “extraordinary” remediation to earn cooperation credit. Translation: fire your entire C-suite, waive privilege on everything, and spend millions on monitors who report to the government for three years. Companies that invested millions in compliance find those programs used as evidence of scienter – you had controls, they failed, therefore you must have intended the violation. I’ve seen prosecutors argue that sophisticated compliance programs prove companies “should have known” about misconduct, converting negligence into criminal intent.
The Executive Flipping Race Nobody Warns You About
When corporate fraud investigations begin, there’s a race among executives to cooperate first. The government offers 5K1.1 substantial assistance departures to the first executive who flips, reducing sentences from 20 years to probation. But there’s only room for one or two cooperators – everyone else becomes a target. I get calls at 3 AM from CEOs who just learned their CFO has been meeting with prosecutors for months, secretly recording conversations.
The Yates Memo requires companies to identify culpable individuals to earn cooperation credit. Your own company’s lawyers – who you’re paying – are obligated to throw you under the bus to protect the entity. They’ll claim joint representation initially, then conflict out when it matters, leaving you exposed with everything you told them now in prosecutors’ hands. The board forms special committees that hire independent counsel whose job is finding scapegoats. Usually that’s you.
Corporate Monitor Appointments – The Slow Death Sentence
Prosecutors love imposing monitors because it sounds reasonable – independent oversight to ensure compliance. The reality destroys companies from within. Monitors bill $1,000+ per hour, with teams that cost millions annually. They have unlimited access to everything: emails, strategy documents, privileged communications. They report to DOJ, not you, turning your company into a glass house where competitors learn your secrets through FOIA requests.
I’ve seen monitors demand changes that gut profitability in the name of compliance. They second-guess every decision, slow every transaction, and create paralysis. Talented employees flee because nobody wants to work under a microscope. Stock prices crater because markets know monitors mean ongoing problems. The three-year monitorship becomes five years, then seven, because monitors have incentive to find problems that extend their lucrative appointments.
Updated Penalties That Reflect 2025 Reality
The statutory maximums are misleading. Real penalties in major corporate fraud cases include:
Securities fraud (15 U.S.C. § 78ff):
- Criminal: 20 years prison, $5 million individual / $25 million entity
- SEC civil: Greater of $1 million or triple the gain per violation
- Shareholder suits: Often exceed criminal fines
Wire fraud (18 U.S.C. § 1343):
- 20 years per count, prosecutors stack dozens of counts
- $250,000 per count or twice gross gain/loss
- Each email or call is separate count
FCPA violations (15 U.S.C. § 78dd-1):
- Criminal: 5 years prison, $250,000 individual / $2 million entity per violation
- SEC civil: Disgorgement plus prejudgment interest
- DOJ alternative fines often 10x statutory maximum
Recent resolutions show the real exposure: Glencore paid $1.5 billion (2022), Allianz $6 billion (2022), FTX bankruptcy with criminal charges pending exceed $8 billion in losses. These aren’t outliers – they’re the new normal.
Why Most Lawyers Make It Worse
Big law firms have conflicts you don’t see until it’s too late. They represent your company, your banks, your board members – everyone except you personally. When investigations heat up, they protect the institution by sacrificing individuals. They’ll counsel you to cooperate fully, waiving privilege, providing roadmaps for prosecution. They bill $2,000 per hour to prepare you for testimony that becomes your confession.
White collar boutiques often lack resources for parallel proceedings. They might handle the criminal case competently but miss SEC deadlines that default you into civil liability. They don’t understand how Delaware Chancery Court derivative suits interact with federal prosecutions. They negotiate in silos, getting you a decent criminal plea while you lose everything in civil litigation.
The Brutal Timeline of Corporate Destruction
Days 1-30: Subpoenas arrive. Wells notices demand responses. Board forms special committee. Stock drops 20%.
Days 30-90: Lawyers demand retainer replenishment. Insurance carriers deny coverage. Key employees retain counsel. Media coverage intensifies.
Days 90-180: Parallel investigations multiply. Document production costs explode. First executives flip. Board discusses your termination.
Days 180-365: Criminal target letters arrive. Assets frozen by restraining orders. D&O insurance exhausted. Personal bankruptcy looms.
Year 2+: Indictments filed. Trial preparation while defending civil suits. Family assets at risk. Career effectively over regardless of outcome.
I’ll personally manage your defense across all proceedings – criminal, civil, regulatory, and reputational. When prosecutors call at 6 AM with “urgent” requests designed to panic you into mistakes, my phone rings directly to me. Not an answering service, not an associate – me.
What I’ll Do Differently
I don’t represent your company – I represent you. That means no conflicts when the board needs scapegoats. When your company’s lawyers say cooperate, I’ll evaluate whether that helps you or just them. I’ll coordinate defense across parallel proceedings so you’re not making admissions in one forum that hang you in another.
Our digital portal gives you 24/7 access to every document, every filing, every development. While other firms keep you in the dark, billing hourly for phone updates, you’ll see everything in real-time. We’re selective about cases because we only take fights we can win. We don’t need your case – but if you need us, we’re all in.
I’ve handled cases that became Netflix series because I take on the complex, high-profile matters other lawyers avoid. When the government has unlimited resources and 95%+ conviction rates, you need attorneys who know how to find the 5% path to victory.
Call NOW – While You Still Have Options
212-300-5196
Right now, your executives are meeting with their lawyers, deciding whether to cooperate against you. The board is discussing your termination with counsel you’re paying for. Prosecutors are drafting charges based on evidence you don’t even know exists. Every hour you wait limits defense options and strengthens the government’s position.
The government wants you to hire conflicted BigLaw counsel who’ll process you into a guilty plea. They want you confused, scared, and isolated. They know most defendants fold within six months when legal fees exhaust savings and insurance coverage ends.
I’m Todd Spodek. I’ll take your call personally at 3 AM when the FBI raids your home. I’ll stand next to you at arraignment when everyone else abandons you. I’ll fight when other lawyers are calculating their bills.
Your company might survive this. Your career might not. Call 212-300-5196 now – while you still have assets to fund a real defense and options beyond complete capitulation.