Blog
What Role Does Restitution Play in Oregon’s Sentencing Guidelines?
Contents
- 1 What is Restitution and How Does it Work in Oregon?
- 2 What Kinds of Losses Are Covered By Restitution?
- 3 How Much Restitution Can Be Ordered?
- 4 What Happens if the Offender Doesn’t Pay Restitution?
- 5 How Long Does Restitution Last?
- 6 Real-Life Restitution Examples
- 7 Example 1: Embezzlement Case
- 8 Example 2: Assault Case
- 9 Example 3: Burglary Case
- 10 The Limits of Restitution
What is Restitution and How Does it Work in Oregon?
When someone commits a crime in Oregon that results in financial losses for the victim, the court will often order the offender to pay restitution as part of their sentence. Restitution is money paid by the offender to the victim to compensate for economic damages caused by the crime. The basic idea behind restitution is to make the victim “whole” again financially, as much as possible. For example, if someone stole and totaled your car, restitution could cover the cost to replace it. Or if you had high medical bills after an assault, the attacker might be ordered to pay those expenses. Oregon law requires judges to order restitution whenever a victim suffers economic damages from a crime, unless the victim agrees to a lesser amount.10 The specific amount is determined by the court based on evidence of the victim’s losses presented by the district attorney.10 So how does the restitution process actually work in Oregon? Here’s a step-by-step breakdown:
- After a defendant is convicted of a crime, the district attorney’s office investigates the victim’s economic damages and presents this evidence to the court, usually at the time of sentencing.10
- The court reviews the evidence and determines a specific dollar amount for restitution that the offender must pay to the victim. This restitution order becomes part of the offender’s sentence.
- If the offender is put on probation, paying the restitution becomes a condition of their probation. If they don’t pay, they can face penalties like fines or even jail time.
- The payments go through the court, which then sends the money to the victim.13 The court may allow the offender to pay in installments if they can’t afford the full amount all at once.10
- If the offender is in prison, the court can still order them to pay restitution, and the Oregon Department of Corrections can garnish their trust account to make payments.17 However, an incarcerated person’s ability to pay is obviously limited.
One important thing to understand is that restitution is separate from a civil lawsuit. Victims can still sue an offender in civil court for damages, even if restitution is ordered.12 However, any restitution payments received would be subtracted from a civil judgment to avoid double-dipping.
What Kinds of Losses Are Covered By Restitution?
Restitution is meant to compensate victims for “economic damages” – in other words, actual financial losses suffered as a direct result of the crime. This can cover a pretty wide range of expenses, such as:
- Medical bills for injuries
- Mental health counseling costs
- Lost wages from missed work
- Property damage or loss
- Funeral expenses in homicide cases
However, restitution doesn’t cover things like pain and suffering, emotional distress, or punitive damages.12 Those types of non-economic damages can only be pursued in a civil lawsuit. It’s also important to have documentation of all losses to give to the district attorney. Things like medical bills, repair estimates, and proof of missed work are crucial for establishing the restitution amount.10 Let’s look at a hypothetical example to illustrate what kinds of losses might be included in restitution:
Imagine your home was burglarized and the thief stole some expensive jewelry and electronics. You took a day off work to meet with the police and insurance company, and also had to pay to replace your broken window and door locks. In this case, restitution could include:
- The value of the stolen jewelry and electronics
- Your lost wages from the day off work
- The cost of the window repair and new locks
However, it likely would not cover things like:
- The sentimental value of the jewelry
- The emotional trauma of having your home invaded
- Any expensive upgrades to your security system beyond basic repairs
So in a nutshell, restitution focuses on tangible financial losses that can be proven and calculated, not more abstract damages. Those are still real losses, of course, but they fall under the “pain and suffering” category that would be addressed in a civil case rather than criminal restitution.
How Much Restitution Can Be Ordered?
In most cases, Oregon courts must order restitution in the full amount of the victim’s economic damages, even if the offender can’t realistically afford to pay it all.10 The one exception is if the victim agrees to accept a lower amount, which sometimes happens in plea deals. While there’s no set maximum amount for restitution in Oregon, it’s ultimately limited by the actual documented losses suffered by the victim. The court can’t just pick a big scary number to punish the offender – it has to be based on real evidence. However, the reality is that many offenders simply don’t have the assets or income to fully compensate their victims’ losses, especially if they’re facing prison time. In those cases, the restitution amount ordered might be more symbolic than practical. For example, let’s say an identity thief steals $100,000 by taking over someone’s accounts, but they’ve already spent all the money and have no way to repay it. The court would still order restitution for the full $100,000, even though the chances of the victim ever seeing that money are slim. On the other hand, if the economic damages are relatively small and the offender has a decent job, there’s a much better chance of restitution being paid in full. It really depends on the specific circumstances of the case.
What Happens if the Offender Doesn’t Pay Restitution?
Failing to pay court-ordered restitution is treated very seriously in Oregon. If someone has the ability to pay but willfully refuses to do so, they can face harsh consequences, including:10
- Fines and fees tacked onto the restitution amount
- Violation of their probation or parole, which could mean going (back) to jail
- Garnishment of their bank accounts or wages
- Seizure of their property
- Suspension of their driver’s license
Basically, the court has a lot of tools to go after offenders who try to dodge their restitution obligations. And if someone on probation or parole stops paying, they can quickly find themselves back behind bars.However, the key phrase there is “ability to pay.” If an offender genuinely can’t afford their restitution payments, the court may work with them to establish a reduced payment plan.10 Destitute or homeless offenders may have their payments deferred until their financial situation improves. The point of restitution is to help victims recover their losses, not to set offenders up for failure. But those who have the means to pay and choose not to can expect to face serious repercussions.
How Long Does Restitution Last?
In Oregon, restitution orders are enforceable for 50 years from the date of conviction.12 That means the court and the victim have a long time to pursue payment, even if the offender’s sentence has ended. However, once a restitution order expires after 50 years, the victim loses their ability to collect through the criminal court process.12 At that point, any remaining unpaid restitution would become a purely civil matter. While 50 years may sound like a long time, keep in mind that many serious crimes result in very lengthy prison sentences. An offender sentenced to 20 years for a violent crime would still have 30 years left on their restitution order when they’re released. Plus, the court can renew a restitution order for another 50 years if the victim files a request before the original order expires.12 So in practice, restitution can follow an offender for the rest of their life if they don’t pay up.
Real-Life Restitution Examples
To give you a better sense of how restitution works in real criminal cases, let’s look at a few actual examples from Oregon:
Example 1: Embezzlement Case
A bookkeeper embezzled over $150,000 from a small business over the course of three years. She was convicted of aggravated theft and sentenced to two years in prison. The judge ordered her to pay $150,000 in restitution to the business to cover the stolen funds. As a condition of her post-prison supervision, she was required to get a job and pay at least $500 per month toward her restitution.
Example 2: Assault Case
A man was convicted of assault for attacking a stranger outside a bar, causing serious injuries. The victim required surgery and missed several weeks of work during recovery. The court ordered the attacker to pay restitution covering the victim’s medical bills, which totaled $8,000 after insurance. He also had to pay $2,500 in lost wages for the work the victim missed. The restitution was in addition to a three-year prison sentence.
Example 3: Burglary Case
A woman’s home was burglarized and her laptop and jewelry were stolen. The burglar pawned the items for a few hundred dollars before being caught and convicted.At sentencing, the judge ordered the burglar to pay restitution for the full value of the stolen items, which was determined to be $3,000 based on the victim’s documentation. He was also sentenced to 18 months in prison.
As you can see from these examples, restitution is a highly case-specific process that depends on the unique facts of each crime. But the common thread is that offenders are held financially responsible for the damage they cause, even if they’re also facing other punishments.
The Limits of Restitution
While restitution is an important tool for compensating crime victims, it’s important to understand its limitations. No amount of money can undo the trauma of being victimized, and restitution doesn’t cover things like pain and suffering or emotional distress.12 Plus, the sad reality is that many offenders are never able to fully pay off their restitution orders, leaving victims without full compensation. It’s common for restitution to go unpaid if the offender is in prison long-term, impoverished, or simply vanishes off the radar. According to one analysis, only about 15-20% of criminal restitution ordered in Oregon is actually collected.9 Factors like incarceration, indigence, and lack of enforcement all contribute to this low rate. So while restitution can provide crucial support for victims, it’s rarely a complete solution on its own. Those with serious injuries or losses may need to explore other avenues too, like civil lawsuits, victim compensation funds, or insurance claims. At the end of the day, restitution is about holding offenders accountable and providing what relief is possible to victims. It may not make things completely right, but it’s an important piece of the puzzle in the pursuit of justice.