Criminal Defense Lawyers

What are common statutory penalties for white collar convictions?

Common Statutory Penalties for White Collar Convictions

White collar crime broadly refers to non-violent crimes committed by businesses or individuals, typically for financial gain. These crimes are usually investigated by federal agencies and prosecuted under federal statutes that carry a range of penalties depending on the severity of the offense. Some of the most common statutory penalties for white collar convictions include fines, restitution, forfeiture, and imprisonment.

Fines

Monetary fines are one of the most common penalties for white collar crimes. Many federal statutes specify fines up to a certain dollar amount for particular offenses. For example, wire fraud under 18 U.S.C. § 1343 can be punished by a fine of up to $1,000,000 for individuals and $5,000,000 for organizations. False statements on tax returns under 26 U.S.C. § 7206 can result in fines up to $100,000 for individuals and $500,000 for corporations.Judges have wide discretion in setting the amount of fines based on factors like the severity of the crime, the amount of loss caused, and the defendant’s ability to pay. Fines can reach into the millions or even billions of dollars for major corporate fraud schemes involving large losses. But fines may be much lower for minor offenses or when defendants have limited resources. Many judges see large fines as a way to punish and deter white collar crime while saving taxpayer expense for imprisonment.

Restitution

Restitution refers to money paid to victims of crimes to compensate them for losses. Many white collar offenses like fraud, embezzlement, and identity theft directly harm victims financially. As a result, restitution is commonly required as part of sentencing for these crimes. Federal statutes generally require restitution for any losses caused by an offense against identifiable victims.Judges determine the full amount of losses caused by the defendant’s criminal conduct and order restitution equal to that amount. For example, if an investment advisor defrauds clients out of $500,000, the court would likely order $500,000 in restitution paid to the victims. Defendants may be ordered to pay restitution immediately or over time under an installment schedule after release from prison.

Forfeiture

Forfeiture involves surrendering property obtained through criminal activity or used to facilitate crimes. Many federal fraud, money laundering, and corruption statutes authorize criminal or civil forfeiture as a penalty. This allows prosecutors to seize assets like real estate, vehicles, bank accounts, and other valuables tied to a defendant’s offenses.Courts may order forfeiture of any proceeds from a crime as well as property used to commit or conceal the offense. For example, a CEO who commits accounting fraud to inflate stock prices could be ordered to forfeit bonuses and stock sale profits gained from the fraud. Someone convicted of investment fraud using client funds may have to forfeit the luxury car and vacation home purchased with the stolen money.

Imprisonment

Incarceration in federal prison is perhaps the most severe penalty for serious white collar crimes. While historically white collar offenders were rarely imprisoned, modern statutes and sentencing guidelines provide significant prison terms for many financial and corporate crimes. Sentences depend on the severity of the offense and the defendant’s criminal history.Some specific white collar offenses carry the following potential prison terms:

• Wire fraud – up to 20 years per count
• Tax evasion – up to 5 years
• Identity theft – 2 to 10 years
• Embezzlement from a financial institution – up to 30 years
• Money laundering – up to 20 years
• Securities fraud – up to 25 years

Under the federal sentencing guidelines, prison sentences are calculated based on the amount of financial loss, number of victims, sophistication of the crime, and other factors. As a result, major fraud schemes often result in decade-long sentences. However, first-time offenders convicted of less serious crimes may receive little or no prison time under the guidelines.Judges have discretion to depart from the guidelines in either direction based on case specifics. But statutory maximum sentences limit how far they can go. So while a judge can be more lenient than the guidelines recommend, they cannot exceed maximum sentences set by Congress in the statutes.

Variations by Crime Type

While the penalties above are common for many white collar crimes, some offenses carry specific punishments worth noting:

• Tax crimes – In addition to fines and imprisonment, tax evasion convictions often result in back taxes owed, interest, and civil fraud penalties assessed by the IRS. Tax crimes also authorize asset forfeiture.
• Healthcare fraud – Convictions can lead to exclusion from federal healthcare programs like Medicare, Medicaid, and Tricare. This penalty can be a death sentence for medical practices.
• Government program fraud – Defendants may be barred from future contracts with or employment by the federal government.
• Securities violations – Individuals convicted of securities fraud often receive bars from working in the securities industry or serving as officers or directors of public companies.
• Anti-trust violations – Corporations can be ordered to break up or divest assets after being convicted of restraint of trade.
• FCPA violations – The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act may require disgorgement of profits from bribery in addition to criminal penalties.

Sentencing Process

Penalties for federal white collar crimes are not determined until after conviction at sentencing. The sentencing process involves the following key steps:

1. The probation department creates a presentence report analyzing the defendant’s conduct and calculating advisory sentencing guidelines.
2. Defense counsel reviews the report and files objections to any erroneous facts or guideline calculations.
3. The prosecution provides victims with the opportunity to submit impact statements to the court.
4. The judge holds a sentencing hearing allowing both parties to argue for their requested sentence.
5. The judge makes final guideline calculations, considers statutory factors, and imposes a sentence within the statutory range but not exceeding the maximum.
6. Fines, restitution, forfeiture, and imprisonment terms are ordered as components of the sentence.
7. Defendants have the right to appeal their sentence if procedural errors are made or the punishment is unreasonable.

Because sentencing is based on the specific offense and defendant, the penalties imposed can vary widely even for similar white collar crimes. The sentencing process is a complex undertaking that requires experienced criminal defense counsel to advocate for the lowest possible punishment under the law.

Conclusion

Statutory penalties for white collar crimes include an array of financial consequences, asset forfeiture, and imprisonment tailored to the severity of the offense. While sentences are imposed on a case-by-case basis, individuals and corporations convicted of these crimes can expect to face substantial punishment. The potential penalties make building an aggressive defense in white collar cases critical from the very beginning.