NATIONALLY RECOGNIZED FEDERAL LAWYERS

21 Jan 24

Understanding Federal Trial Subpoenas and Your Rights

| by

Last Updated on: 21st January 2024, 10:45 pm

Understanding Federal Trial Subpoenas and Your Rights

Receiving a subpoena to testify in a federal trial can be an intimidating and confusing experience. As a witness, you have certain rights and responsibilities that are important to understand. This article provides an overview of federal trial subpoenas, outlines your rights as a witness, and offers tips on how to respond.

What is a Federal Trial Subpoena?

A federal trial subpoena is an official legal document issued by a federal court ordering you to appear in court on a specific date to testify in a trial (r/legaladvice). They are most often used in criminal cases brought by federal prosecutors, but can also be used in some civil lawsuits.If you are issued a subpoena, you are legally required to show up at the time and place listed on the subpoena. You can face fines or even arrest if you do not comply. So it’s important to take any subpoena seriously.

Why Might I Receive a Federal Trial Subpoena?

There are a few reasons why you might receive a federal trial subpoena (Avvo):

  • You witnessed a crime or event related to the trial. For example, if you saw an assault take place that led to federal charges.
  • You have information or evidence related to the trial. For instance, documents, communications, photos, or other evidence that is relevant to the case.
  • You are an expert witness. If you have specialized expertise related to the issues in the case, you may be called to offer your expert opinion.

In most cases, you will receive a subpoena because one of the parties in the cases believes you have testimony or evidence that can help prove or disprove something related to the trial.

What Are My Rights as a Witness?

Even if you are legally obligated to comply with a federal trial subpoena, you still have certain rights (LawInfo):Right to Be Paid for Expenses: If appearing in court causes you to incur expenses like travel costs or childcare, you have the right to be repaid by the party that subpoenaed you.Right to Review Case Documents: You have the right to review documents from the case related to your testimony so you can prepare. This includes things like copies of previous testimony, documents you produced, etc.Right to Counsel: As a witness, you can have an attorney represent you. This is rare in most cases, but could make sense if your testimony involves confidential information related to your employment.Fifth Amendment Right Against Self-Incrimination: If answering a question truthfully might implicate you in a crime, you have the Fifth Amendment right to not answer. But you must explicitly assert that right by saying you “plead the Fifth” in response to specific questions.Right to Modify the Subpoena: If complying with the subpoena would cause undue burden or hardship, you can file a motion to “quash” or modify the subpoena. For example, if the date of appearance conflicts with travel plans or medical treatments.So while you are obligated to comply, you also have protections around things like expenses, access to documents, and constitutional rights.

Tips for Responding to a Federal Trial Subpoena

If you’ve received a federal trial subpoena, here are some important tips (FindLaw):

  • Don’t ignore it – You must respond or you could face fines or arrest. Even if you don’t have any information, you must appear and state that under oath.
  • Notify your employer – Your employer cannot punish you for complying with a subpoena. Give them advanced notice that you will be absent from work.
  • Contact the lawyer – The subpoena should list a lawyer’s name and contact information. Reach out with any questions or concerns.
  • Know what documents you have – If you possess any evidence related to the case, provide it to the lawyer in advance.
  • Clear your schedule – You may have to wait several hours before testifying, so keep your schedule clear. Arrange childcare if necessary.
  • Review your prior statements – If you’ve already been interviewed by lawyers or federal agents, review what you said. Your testimony must be consistent.
  • Tell the truth – Always tell the complete truth when testifying in court. Lying under oath is the crime of perjury, which can lead to fines or jail time.

While fielding a federal trial subpoena can be disruptive and unsettling, understanding your rights and responsibilities can help you properly comply. Don’t ignore the subpoena, but do seek guidance if you have questions or face hardship.

What Happens if I Don’t Comply with a Federal Trial Subpoena?

It’s vitally important to comply with any subpoena you receive, as there can be serious consequences for failing to respond (r/legaladvice). Under federal law, if you are properly served with a subpoena and do not appear at the specified time, you can face:

  • Civil contempt charges – A judge could issue a warrant for your arrest and bring you before the court to explain why you did not comply.
  • Fines – You could be ordered to pay steep daily fines until you comply with the subpoena or appear before the court.
  • Jail time – In some cases, a judge can order that you be sent to jail for a period of time as punishment for ignoring the subpoena.
  • Obstruction charges – Prosecutors might choose to bring criminal charges against you for obstructing justice if your refusal to comply seems intentional.

So in almost all cases, the consequences for ignoring a federal trial subpoena are quite severe. Fines, arrest, and jail time are all possibilities. Even if you do not have any helpful information, you are still legally obligated to appear. Pleading ignorance or forgetting about it are not valid legal excuses.The best path is to promptly consult an attorney if you have any concerns about the subpoena. They can advise you on the specific laws in your jurisdiction and represent you in filing motions to modify or quash the subpoena if appropriate. But outright ignoring it is not advisable and can lead to charges.

What Should I Do If I Can’t Afford an Attorney?

The legal process can be complex and intimidating for anyone without formal legal training. While you do not have an automatic right to a court-appointed attorney as a subpoenaed witness, there are still options if you cannot afford legal representation (Quora.com):Contact Legal Aid – Organizations like the Legal Services Corporation provide free or low-cost legal help to those who qualify. Visit LawHelp.org to find a local legal aid office near you.Look into Law School Clinics – Many accredited law schools offer legal clinics where law students provide assistance under attorney supervision at no cost. This can be helpful for basic questions and document review.Search for Pro Bono Assistance – Various bar associations and non-profit legal groups may be able to connect you with an attorney who can provide limited services free of charge as part of their pro bono commitment.Appear Without an Attorney – While risky, you always have the right to appear at your scheduled testimony without formal legal counsel if absolutely necessary. The judge can appoint you an attorney if needed.The most prudent option is finding low-bono or pro bono legal resources in your area. Lacking funds should not prevent you from getting advice prior to appearing. Reach out to local legal aid clinics and explain your situation.

What Can I Expect at the Trial?

If it’s your first time testifying, it’s normal to feel anxious or unprepared. Having an idea of what to expect can help ease those concerns (Avvo):Step 1 – Check In – You will need to check in with the courtroom clerk or officer upon arriving at the courthouse. Have your subpoena available.Step 2 – Wait – Trials often run behind schedule. You may have to wait awhile before being called to the stand. Use this time to review your documents and testimony.Step 3 – Take the Oath – The court officer will have you swear under oath to tell the truth before testifying. This oath is legally binding.Step 4 – Answer Questions – The lawyer who subpoenaed you will ask you questions first. The opposing counsel may then cross-examine you. Answer every question honestly with facts – not guesses or assumptions. Say if you don’t know or don’t remember.Step 5 – Review Your Testimony – After testifying, the court reporter may show you the written transcript to review and sign to certify its accuracy.Step 6 – You’re Done – After reviewing your testimony, you are free to leave. However, the court may request you remain available in case you need to be recalled later during the trial.While the legal process can seem complex and even frightening, having a roadmap of what generally occurs can reduce uncertainty. Be sure to seek guidance from the issuing attorney prior to appearing if you have any outstanding questions.

Key Takeaways

  • Federal trial subpoenas are court orders to appear that you must legally comply with or challenge appropriately.
  • You have certain rights around compensation, document access, representation, and constitutional protections.
  • Reach out to the issuing attorney immediately if you have concerns and seek legal aid if needed.
  • There are steep penalties like fines and arrest for ignoring subpoenas, so respond formally.
  • Understanding the step-by-step process for testifying can minimize anxiety.

Being well-informed is vital when facing something as consequential as a federal trial subpoena. Consult resources like the issuing attorney, legal aid clinics, and pro bono services to protect your rights and obligations. While unsettling, a subpoena does not have to be faced alone or without assistance.

Resources

What to Do if You Receive a Subpoena – YouTube video with additional adviceResponding to a Federal Grand Jury Subpoena – Overview from the DOJWhat Rights Do I Have as a Witness? – More on victim/witness rights