Criminal Defense Lawyers

Responding to Federal Subpoenas for Physical Evidence or DNA

Responding to Federal Subpoenas for Physical Evidence or DNA

Receiving a subpoena for physical evidence or DNA can be an intimidating and stressful experience. However, there are steps you can take to make the process go more smoothly. This article provides an overview of federal subpoenas, your rights and responsibilities when served with one, and some practical tips on responding.

What is a Subpoena?

A subpoena is a writ or order issued by a court or other legal authority demanding that you produce documents, physical evidence, or testify at a hearing, trial or deposition

.There are two main types of subpoenas:

• Subpoena ad testificandum – Requires you to testify or provide oral evidence.
• Subpoena duces tecum – Requires you to produce documents, records, or physical evidence
  4

  . This is the type of subpoena typically used to demand DNA samples or other physical evidence.

Subpoenas are powerful legal tools that compel cooperation. If you fail to comply with a federal subpoena, you could face civil or criminal contempt charges. However, you do have certain rights when responding.

Your Rights When Served with a Subpoena

• You have the right to object to the subpoena if you believe it is overly broad, vague, irrelevant, or improperly issued. This must be done promptly in writing.
• You can file a motion to quash or modify the subpoena if you believe compliance would be unreasonable or oppressive.
• You may be entitled to have your attorney’s fees paid if the subpoena is found to be improper.
• You can’t simply ignore a subpoena. You must take action to challenge it or negotiate alternatives.
• Law enforcement officers serving the subpoena must not exceed the scope of the subpoena or engage in harassment.
• You have the right to speak with an attorney before proceeding.

Practical Tips for Responding

• Don’t wait – Act promptly if you plan to object or file a motion. Delayed action may be seen as noncompliance.
• Negotiate – See if you can reach an agreement on a modified subpoena. This may save time and legal costs.
• Take it seriously – Complying with a subpoena takes precedence over other commitments. Make sure you meet all requirements.
• Review carefully – Make sure you understand what is being requested and the timeline for responding. Double check for accuracy.
• Consult an attorney – Get legal advice to protect your rights and interests. An attorney can also interface with the party issuing the subpoena.
• Preserve evidence – As soon as you receive a subpoena, take steps to preserve relevant evidence. Don’t destroy or alter anything related to the subpoena.
• Craft your response – If you are objecting, be clear, specific, and cite relevant laws or rules. Get help from a legal professional.
• Meet deadlines – Tardiness is not an option. Calendars fill up fast, so book appointments for depositions or testimony well in advance.
• Follow procedures – Carefully comply with all logistical requirements for submitting evidence or appearing in court.
• Maintain records – Keep copies of all communications and documents related to the subpoena for your personal records.
• Get a receipt – When physically delivering evidence, get a signed receipt listing everything that was provided.
• Be truthful – It is a crime to lie or knowingly withhold information requested by a subpoena.
• Limit disclosure – Only provide what is expressly requested in the subpoena. Do not volunteer additional information.

Subpoenas for DNA Evidence

DNA evidence can definitively link a suspect to a crime scene, exonerate the wrongly accused, identify remains, and more. However, compulsory DNA sampling also raises privacy concerns.Law enforcement typically uses subpoenas to obtain DNA from people connected to an investigation who are not under arrest. This includes victims, witnesses, or third parties. DNA cannot be collected from an arrestee without a search warrant.If you receive a subpoena for DNA, you may consider seeking legal advice to understand your rights and obligations. An attorney can help determine if the demand for DNA is valid or challenge it if there are issues.Some other tips when dealing with DNA subpoenas:

• Find out exactly what DNA sample is required – saliva, hair, blood, etc. Comply only with what is specified.
• Confirm the timeline and proper procedure for submitting your DNA sample. Meet all chain of custody requirements.
• Ensure the DNA will be used only for the purpose stated in the subpoena. Additional testing shouldn’t occur without your permission.
• Request safeguards for preserving the privacy of your genetic information. Ask for confidentiality agreements and data encryption.
• If testing excludes you as a suspect, request that your DNA sample and profile be immediately destroyed.
• Get written confirmation when your DNA is collected stating the purpose, authority, and assurance of destruction when no longer needed.

Subpoenas for Physical Evidence

A subpoena duces tecum may require you to produce physical objects relevant to an investigation, such as:

• Weapons, ammunition, or explosives
• Computers, phones, and electronic devices
• Security camera footage
• Business records and invoices
• Medical records, X-rays, and testing results
• Clothing, fabric samples, or bloodstained items
• Vehicle registration, maintenance records, or accident photos
• Correspondence, receipts, financial statements
• Photographs, videos, diaries, calendars

Carefully read the subpoena to determine exactly what items you need to provide and any special handling procedures. Consult an attorney if you have concerns about the scope of evidence demanded.When producing physical evidence, take steps to properly preserve and document the chain of custody:

• Label everything clearly for identification.
• Pack items securely to prevent loss or damage.
• Obtain signed and dated receipt listing every item handed over.
• Keep a copy of the receipt for yourself.
• Take high resolution photos or video of evidence before surrendering it.
• Request return of evidence when no longer needed.

Conclusion

Receiving a federal subpoena can be unsettling, but understanding your rights and responsibilities makes the process less intimidating. Act promptly, get legal advice, comply fully with all requirements, and document every step. With the help of an attorney, you can appropriately respond and protect your interests when served with a subpoena for DNA evidence or other physical items.