NJ Insurance Surcharges Lawyers

NJ Insurance Surcharges Lawyers

Getting a traffic ticket in New Jersey can be a real headache. Not only do you have to pay the fine, but your auto insurance rates are likely to go up as well. This is because New Jersey is one of just a handful of states that imposes insurance surcharges on drivers for certain motor vehicle violations.

These surcharges, which are meant to deter unsafe driving, can add hundreds or even thousands of dollars to your annual insurance premium. And in some cases, the surcharges apply for multiple years after the violation occurred. Needless to say, this extra financial burden can be a real problem for New Jersey drivers.

That’s where an experienced New Jersey insurance surcharge lawyer can help. If you’ve been slapped with surcharges that you feel are unfair or excessive, a lawyer may be able to get them reduced or even eliminated entirely.

What Are Insurance Surcharges?

In New Jersey, insurance companies are required by law to impose surcharges on drivers who are convicted of certain motor vehicle offenses. These surcharges are added on top of your regular insurance premium.

The most common violations that trigger surcharges include:

• Drunk driving
• Reckless driving
• Excessive speeding (26 mph or more over the limit)
• Careless driving
• Leaving the scene of an accident
• Driving without insurance

For first offenses, surcharges typically add 3% to 30% to your auto insurance costs for three years. For subsequent offenses within a three-year period, the surcharges can be even higher.

So for example, if your annual premium is $1,000, a 15% surcharge would add $150 per year for three years, for a total additional cost of $450. And if you get hit with multiple surcharges, they can really add up.

Are Insurance Surcharges Mandatory in NJ?

Yes, insurance companies are required by the New Jersey Merit Rating Plan to impose surcharges for the violations listed above. They do not have discretion in this matter – if you are convicted of one of these offenses, you will pay the corresponding surcharge.

The surcharge percentages are set by state law and decrease each year for three years from the date of conviction. But even though the rates go down over time, three years of surcharges can still mean thousands of dollars in extra costs.

Can I Fight NJ Insurance Surcharges?

Yes, you may be able to fight the surcharges and get them lowered or dismissed. There are a few main ways to do this:

1. Challenge the underlying traffic violation. If you can get the original ticket dismissed or downgraded to a lesser offense, you may avoid surcharges altogether or qualify for lower ones.
2. Provide proof of other insurance. Surcharges only apply to policies issued in New Jersey. So if you switch coverage to an out-of-state policy, you may avoid surcharges (but this has some downsides).
3. Claim financial hardship. You may qualify to have surcharges waived if you can demonstrate that paying them would cause undue financial hardship.
4. Negotiate with the insurance company. In some cases, your lawyer may be able to negotiate with the insurer to reduce the surcharges as a good faith gesture.

An experienced New Jersey insurance surcharge attorney will know all the nuances of the system and have the best chance of getting your surcharges lowered or dismissed. Don’t just accept them as mandatory – fight back.

Should I Hire a Lawyer to Fight NJ Insurance Surcharges?

Trying to fight insurance surcharges on your own can be an uphill battle. Insurance companies have little incentive to reduce surcharges out of the goodness of their hearts. But an attorney who specializes in this area will know how to craft an effective argument on your behalf.

A lawyer can review the details of your case, identify any procedural problems or errors, and negotiate aggressively with the insurance company. They will also be familiar with recent court rulings that may impact your case.

In addition, a lawyer can provide expert guidance on whether challenging the underlying traffic ticket makes sense, and what defenses may apply. This is critical, because getting the ticket dismissed or downgraded is often the key to avoiding surcharges.

The cost of hiring a lawyer is likely to pay for itself multiple times over in savings on reduced insurance surcharges. Don’t let these unfair penalties wreck your finances – fight back with experienced legal representation.

What Defenses Can My Lawyer Use?

There are various technical and procedural defenses a skilled lawyer may use to fight your surcharges, including:

• The traffic stop was unlawful
• Your Miranda rights were violated
• The officer lacked probable cause for the stop
• You weren’t properly informed of the surcharge consequences
• Mistakes in the ticket or paperwork
• Lack of proper calibration of breath test equipment (DUIs)

In addition, for speeding tickets – which often trigger hefty surcharges – a lawyer can argue that:

• Your speed wasn’t properly clocked or recorded
• Traffic conditions made the speed reasonable
• You weren’t the driver of the vehicle

A skilled New Jersey traffic ticket attorney will thoroughly examine every aspect of your case to find grounds to get the ticket dismissed or downgraded. This can help you avoid insurance surcharges entirely.

Recent Changes to NJ Insurance Surcharges

After years of criticism that New Jersey’s insurance surcharge system was unfairly punitive, reforms were finally passed in 2020 to reduce surcharges over time. But the changes will be phased in slowly.

Under the new law, by 2025 surcharges will be reduced 15% per year for each year of safe driving. However, for now, the surcharges remain in effect at the same high levels.

The legislation also requires creation of a “careless driving” tier to replace the “failure to maintain lane” offense. This will carry lower surcharges than reckless driving. However, the specifics remain to be seen.

While the reforms are a step in the right direction, for now drivers still face the same stiff surcharges. So it remains critical to consult an experienced attorney if you get slapped with these penalties.

Fighting NJ Surcharges – Your Legal Options

To summarize, here are your main options for fighting New Jersey auto insurance surcharges:

1. Hire a lawyer to contest the underlying traffic violation
2. Provide proof you switched to an eligible out-of-state insurance policy
3. Demonstrate to the DOBI that surcharges would cause undue financial hardship
4. Have your lawyer negotiate with the insurance company for a reduction
5. Explore technical and procedural defenses to dismiss the ticket

Don’t just accept unfair insurance surcharges – take action. An experienced traffic ticket attorney can review your case and map out the best strategy. There are always options to reduce or eliminate excessive surcharges.

Finding the Right NJ Insurance Surcharge Lawyer

If you decide to hire a lawyer to help with your insurance surcharges, make sure to choose someone with specific experience in this niche area. General practitioners may not have the right skills.

Look for an attorney who advertises handling New Jersey traffic tickets, DUI/DWI charges, license suspensions, and insurance surcharge cases. Read online reviews and ask about their success record in fighting surcharges.

Also consider lawyers who offer free consultations. This gives you a chance to discuss your case and evaluate whether you feel comfortable with their approach.

Fighting insurance surcharges takes expertise. So do your research to find the right lawyer.

Is It Worth Challenging My Surcharges?

Due to the high cost of New Jersey insurance surcharges, it is almost always worth at least consulting with a lawyer to understand your options. Even if the lawyer’s fees are $500-$1000, you can still come out way ahead if they get your surcharges significantly reduced or dismissed.

Don’t just pay exorbitant surcharges without exploring your legal defenses. And remember – getting the original traffic ticket thrown out is the golden ticket, since it often eliminates the basis for the surcharges.

While every case is different, an experienced attorney can usually find some way to fight back against excessive penalties. It costs nothing to ask a lawyer for help. Why not give yourself the best chance for savings?

Can I Avoid Surcharges by Switching Insurers?

Under New Jersey law, your surcharges follow you when you switch insurance companies. The new insurer will impose the same penalties based on your motor vehicle record.

So generally, you cannot avoid surcharges simply by changing carriers after getting a ticket. The surcharges apply based on your driving history, not any specific insurer.

However, there are a couple potential exceptions:

• Switching to an eligible out-of-state policy can sometimes avoid NJ surcharges.
• Finding an insurer who offers a “forgiveness” program for first-time offenses.

But these options are limited. For most drivers, the key is getting the underlying ticket dismissed or downgraded through an experienced lawyer.

Should I Just Pay the Surcharges and Move On?

It may be tempting to simply pay your insurance surcharges and chalk it up as an expensive lesson. But surcharges can cost you thousands of dollars over three years. So it’s usually worth taking some time to understand your legal options.

Consulting with a lawyer knowledgeable in this area takes little time or money, but can potentially save you big in the long run. You have nothing to lose by learning more.

If you do decide paying the surcharges is your best course of action, at least make an informed choice. Don’t just accept them as an immutable consequence of a ticket without exploring your alternatives.

And remember – surcharges increase exponentially with multiple offenses. So even if you pay them once, it’s smart to fight any future tickets to avoid compounding penalties.

Conclusion

Getting hit with New Jersey auto insurance surcharges can be incredibly frustrating and expensive. But working with an experienced lawyer gives you the best chance to reduce or eliminate these unfair penalties.

Don’t just pay up without exploring your options – surcharges can cost you thousands. It’s worth investing a little time and money up front with a lawyer to potentially achieve huge savings down the road.

Every case is different, but the penalties are usually negotiable with the right legal strategy. So be proactive and fight back against excessive insurance surcharges. An attorney who specializes in this area can be your ally.

References

[1] New Jersey Merit Rating Plan

[2] New Jersey Surcharge Reform Law

[3]