Blog
NJ Eluding Case Law in New Jersey: State v. Mendez Lawyers
NJ Eluding Case Law in New Jersey: State v. Mendez Lawyers
Getting charged with eluding the police in New Jersey is scary. The penalties are severe, and a conviction can wreck your life. But you have rights – and the law may be on your side. One key case every eluding defendant should know is State v. Mendez.
In this article, I’ll break down the Mendez case and what it means for fighting eluding charges in NJ. We’ll cover:
- What exactly is “eluding” under NJ law?
- The facts and outcome of the Mendez case
- How Mendez impacts eluding defenses and jury instructions
- Why having an experienced eluding lawyer is so critical
I know you’re worried, but knowledge is power. So let’s dive in and see how Mendez could help your eluding case…
Understanding the Crime of “Eluding” in New Jersey
Under NJ statute 2C:29-2, you commit the crime of eluding if you:
- Knowingly flee or attempt to elude a police officer after receiving a signal to stop, AND
- You create a risk of death or injury to any person during the pursuit.
It’s important to note that eluding requires more than just failing to stop for police. Your driving must also pose a dangerous risk of injury or death. Common examples include:
- Speeding excessively
- Running red lights or stop signs
- Driving into oncoming traffic
- Causing an accident
If convicted of eluding in NJ, you face penalties of:
- 3 to 5 years in prison
- Fines up to $15,000
- 2 year mandatory driver’s license suspension
Plus, eluding often leads to additional charges like reckless driving, resisting arrest, or assault by auto. That’s why mounting an aggressive legal defense is so critical.
The Mendez Case and What It Means for Eluding Charges
State v. Mendez involved a defendant appealing his conviction for eluding police and resisting arrest. The case challenged jury instructions regarding the “attempt to elude” part of the statute.
At trial, the judge instructed jurors that the “attempt to elude” element is satisfied if the defendant’s driving “manifests an intent to elude” police. Mendez argued this was incorrect – an attempt requires proof of a “substantial step” towards eluding under general attempt liability principles.
The appellate court agreed with Mendez. They ruled that just manifesting an intent to elude is insufficient – the jury instructions should have required evidence that Mendez took substantial steps in a course of conduct planned to culminate in eluding police.
What This Means for Fighting Eluding Charges
The Mendez ruling has two big implications for defendants fighting eluding charges:
- Challenging “attempt to elude” evidence – The prosecution must prove more than just your intent to elude police. There must be evidence of substantial steps towards completing an eluding offense.
- Requesting proper jury instructions – If your case goes to trial, the jury must be instructed that “attempt to elude” requires proof of substantial steps, not just intent. This raises the prosecution’s burden of proof.
An experienced eluding defense attorney can leverage the Mendez decision to hold prosecutors to their burden of proof. It’s not enough to claim you intended to elude police – they must provide evidence of actions you took toward completing an eluding offense.
Why You Need a Top Eluding Lawyer in New Jersey
Trying to fight eluding charges without an attorney is extremely risky. These cases often come down to complex legal arguments – like those in Mendez – at suppression hearings and trial. Police and prosecutors know how to navigate the system against you.
A knowledgeable eluding lawyer will protect your rights at every stage by:
- Filing motions to suppress evidence from illegal police stops
- Obtaining video footage to challenge officer testimony
- Raising doubt about your intent and actions during the incident
- Citing Mendez to hold prosecutors to their burden of proof
- Presenting persuasive defenses and arguments to judges and juries
Don’t leave your fate solely in the hands of the police and courts. An experienced attorney can even the odds and give you the best chance at avoiding harsh eluding penalties.
Let Our New Jersey Eluding Lawyers Help Fight Your Charges
I know you feel scared and overwhelmed right now. But we can get through this together. My legal team has successfully defended hundreds of clients against eluding and other serious traffic charges. We have the skills and determination to protect your rights and future.
If you or a loved one has been charged with eluding police in New Jersey, contact us for a free consultation. We’re here to listen, provide honest answers, and start crafting an aggressive defense strategy for your case.