Blog
Meeting Federal Appeal Filing and Form Requirements
Contents
Meeting Federal Appeal Filing and Form Requirements
Filing an appeal in federal court can seem daunting, with lots of rules and requirements to follow. But having a good understanding of the basics can help make the process smoother. This article provides an overview of some key things to know when filing a federal appeal.
The Notice of Appeal
The first step in any appeal is filing the notice of appeal. This is a simple document that identifies the party appealing, the order or judgment being appealed, and the court where the appeal is being filed. But it must be filed within strict deadlines, usually 30 days from the entry of the order or judgment being appealed[1].
The notice of appeal should follow the standard federal forms as closely as possible. Using the standard forms helps ensure all required information is included. Forms 1A and 1B provide templates for appeals from district court orders and judgments[2].
Parties sometimes try to appeal orders that are not final judgments, hoping for an exception. But the notice of appeal should explain why an interlocutory or collateral order is appealable if that is the case. Otherwise the appeal may be dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.
Filing and Service Requirements
In federal appeals, most documents must be filed with the circuit clerk’s office and served on all parties[3]. While electronic filing is now common, traditional paper filing rules still apply. For paper filing, documents must arrive at the clerk’s office within the filing deadline. Using first-class mail or a commercial delivery service helps ensure timely filing.
For incarcerated parties, most circuits have special “legal mail” systems and “mailbox rules.” These provide that papers are deemed filed when deposited in the prison mail system. So prisoners should be sure to use legal mail procedures whenever possible.
Briefs
Appellate briefs have strict formatting and length limits. In federal appeals, briefs are generally limited to 14,000 words or 50 pages when typed[4]. Briefs must use double spacing and reasonable margins. A certificate of compliance with length limits is also required.
Briefs must contain specific sections, including tables of contents and authorities, jurisdictional statements, statements of issues, statements of the case, summary of argument, argument, and conclusion. Following the required format helps ensure all key information is included.
When citing legal authorities, briefs should use consistent citation format, like Bluebook or ALWD. Hyperlinks or web addresses should never be used, however. Briefs must contain standard legal citations.
Motions
Many types of motions may be filed in appeals. Common examples are motions for extension of time, motions to dismiss, and motions for stays pending appeal. Motions have their own filing and service rules, and often have deadlines for any responses or replies.
Motions also frequently require separate supporting documents like affidavits or declarations. These must follow format rules for font, spacing, page limits, and organization. Using the standard federal forms for declarations helps ensure compliance.
One key requirement for motions is conferring with opposing counsel before filing. Most courts require a statement that the parties conferred and whether the motion is opposed. This helps avoid unnecessary motions.
Record Excerpts
When citing trial transcripts or evidence in briefs, parties must provide excerpts of the relevant portions. Federal appeals rules generally discourage filing of entire trial records. Excerpts should only include directly relevant portions.
The excerpts must be organized logically and be self-contained. All cited portions of transcripts or documents must be included. Excerpt formatting rules for binding, covers, and page numbers must also be followed.
For immigration appeals, however, excerpts are not required. Immigration cases rely solely on the record before the Board of Immigration Appeals.
Oral Argument
Oral argument is not guaranteed in federal appeals. But if granted, there are rules for timing, rebuttal, and conduct. Common requirements include limits on time per side, prohibitions on reading from prepared scripts, and requirements to avoid repetition from briefs.
Court rules encourage attorneys to focus on main points and respond effectively to judges’ questions. Moot courts help attorneys practice this focused, conversational style. Proper courtroom decorum is also expected at oral arguments.
Petitions for Rehearing
After losing an appeal, parties may file a petition for rehearing or reconsideration. But these petitions are limited to 15 pages and rarely granted. Usually, petitions for rehearing are only granted if the court overlooked key issues or facts.
The deadline for petitions for rehearing is strict—just 14 days from the appellate judgment. This deadline is jurisdictional and cannot be extended. So any rehearing petitions must be prepared and filed within 2 weeks of the appellate loss.
If granted, the appellate court may order new briefing and argument or may simply amend its prior opinion. But most petitions for rehearing are denied without court action. The odds of success are low.
Conclusion
Federal appeals rules may seem complex, but having a roadmap helps. Understanding the basic requirements for notices of appeal, briefs, motions, records, and oral argument makes navigating the process much easier. Adhering to all the formatting, filing, and service rules ensures appeals proceed smoothly and efficiently.
With some diligence and attention to detail, parties in federal appeals can meet all the key requirements and avoid common pitfalls. Focusing on deadlines and following the standard federal forms prevents most procedural problems. And understanding the overall process prepares parties to present their best case on appeal.
References
[1] Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure Rule 4
[2] US Courts Appellate Rules Forms