Blog
Mail Destruction Charges: Key Elements and Defense Strategies
Contents
Mail Destruction Charges: Key Elements and Defense Strategies
Getting charged with destroying or tampering with mail can lead to serious consequences. While it may seem harmless to throw away junk mail or open a letter addressed to someone else, these acts could potentially violate federal law. This article will break down the key elements of common mail tampering crimes and discuss potential defenses.
What is Considered Mail Tampering or Destruction?
There are a few main laws that prohibit tampering with or destroying mail:
- 18 U.S.C. § 1702 makes it illegal to obstruct correspondence or take letters from mailboxes.
- 18 U.S.C. § 1703 prohibits delaying or destroying mail.
- 18 U.S.C. § 1708 outlaws mail theft.
- 18 U.S.C. § 1709 bars postal employees from embezzling mail.
So what exactly constitutes tampering or destruction? Here are some examples:
- Taking mail out of a mailbox that isn’t addressed to you
- Opening, hiding, destroying, or stealing someone else’s mail
- Modifying or forging contents of a letter or package
- Deliberately delaying delivery of mail
- Stealing mail as a postal employee
- Vandalizing mailboxes
Basically, any unauthorized interference with mail is prohibited. It doesn’t matter if it’s junk mail or seems unimportant. Federal law protects the entire mail system.
Proving the Key Elements
For a mail tampering or destruction charge to stick, prosecutors have to prove a few key elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
- The defendant acted knowingly and intentionally, not by accident or mistake.
- The mail involved belonged to another person.
- The defendant obstructed correspondence or removed mail before delivery.
- The actions delayed or prevented mail from being delivered.
The prosecution also has to establish that the mail involved was part of the U.S. Mail system. This includes letters, packages, postcards, and other items handled by the United States Postal Service. Private couriers like FedEx don’t count.
For charges involving theft or embezzlement, the prosecution must prove the person willfully stole or took mail contents. And for mailbox vandalism, they have to show the defendant knowingly and intentionally damaged or destroyed a mailbox.
Understanding the Consequences
Penalties for mail tampering depend on the specific crime and circumstances. Many charges under these federal laws are felonies punishable by:
- Up to 5 years in prison
- Fines up to $250,000
- Probation
Stealing mail as a postal employee or vandalizing mailboxes can lead to even stiffer sentences. Defendants may also have to pay restitution. And a felony conviction stays on your criminal record, impacting future employment and other opportunities.
Building a Strong Defense
Fighting mail tampering charges starts with examining the prosecution’s case for weaknesses. A skilled defense lawyer will look for:
- Lack of criminal intent – Were actions just a mistake?
- Insufficient evidence – Is proof limited or circumstantial?
- Unlawful search or seizure – Were constitutional rights violated?
- Unreliable witnesses – Do they have motives to lie?
Other defense strategies include:
- Challenging if mail qualifies – Question if the item meets the legal definition of mail.
- Disproving criminal intent – Argue actions weren’t purposeful or willful.
- Contesting charges apply – Assert prosecutors used the wrong statute.
- Suppressing evidence – Seek to exclude evidence improperly obtained.
One of the best ways to fight mail tampering charges is cooperating with authorities early on. In some cases, this can lead prosecutors to drop or reduce charges. Accepting a plea deal is also an option if the evidence is overwhelming.
Avoiding Allegations
To steer clear of mail tampering trouble, keep this guidance in mind:
- Never take mail that isn’t addressed to you.
- Don’t open other people’s mail, even by accident.
- Promptly return misdelivered mail.
- Use your own mailbox – don’t place mail in others’ boxes.
- Keep your mailbox locked and undamaged.
Bottom line, respect other people’s mail. If you suspect an issue with delivery or theft, notify postal inspectors. And never take mail frustrations out on a mailbox!
Getting Legal Help
Dealing with federal charges for mail destruction or tampering is daunting. But an experienced attorney can help safeguard your rights. They will thoroughly examine the prosecution’s case and build an aggressive defense to achieve the best possible outcome.
Don’t leave your future to chance. Reach out to a skilled criminal defense lawyer for trusted advice and representation.
References
Mail Tampering Charges: Understanding the Elements and Building a Defense. https://www.federallawyers.com/criminal-defense/mail-tampering-charges-understanding-the-elements-and-building-a-defense/
Unraveling Defense Strategies for Federal Wire & Mail Fraud Charges. https://www.tpatrialattorneys.com/federal-wire-mail-fraud-defense/
UCMJ Article 109A: Mail Offenses. https://www.bileckilawgroup.com/court-martial-defense/articles-of-the-ucmj/article-109a-mail-offenses/
Theft of Mail Matter by Officer or Employee. https://www.thefederalcriminalattorneys.com/mail-theft
Mailbox Vandalism. https://www.uspis.gov/news/scam-article/mailbox-vandalism
Best Practices for Mail Screening and Handling Processes: A Guide for the Public and Private Sectors. https://www.cisa.gov/sites/default/files/publications/isc-mail-handling-screening-nonfouo-sept-2012-508.pdf