Criminal Defense Lawyers

Is Spanking Your Child Illegal

Is Spanking Your Child Illegal?

Spanking is a controversial form of discipline that involves hitting a child’s bottom with an open hand. It remains a common practice in many households, with around 35% of parents in the U.S. reporting that they have spanked their children. However, views on spanking are shifting and an increasing number of countries have moved to ban corporal punishment of children completely. So is spanking illegal where you live? Let’s take a look at the laws and research surrounding this complex issue.

The Legal Landscape on Spanking

There is no federal law in the U.S. banning the spanking or corporal punishment of children. The Supreme Court has upheld the right of parents to use reasonable corporal punishment on their children. However, many states have banned the use of corporal punishment in public schools. As of 2022, corporal punishment is banned in schools in 31 states and D.C.On the family level, a few states have restricted the use of corporal punishment by parents. For example, California bans corporal punishment in licensed daycares. New Jersey prohibits corporal punishment of children in foster care. And Delaware has made it a misdemeanor to physically mistreat a child under 18.However, in most states, it is still legal for parents to use reasonable corporal punishment for discipline in the home. Of course, there is always a debate around what constitutes “reasonable” punishment. Prosecutors have brought child abuse charges in severe corporal punishment cases that resulted in bruising, bleeding or other injuries.Internationally, 63 countries have banned corporal punishment of children in all settings, including the home. These countries span Europe, South America, Africa and parts of Asia.So in summary:

• No federal U.S. ban on parental corporal punishment
• 31 states + D.C. ban corporal punishment in public schools
• Few states restrict parental corporal punishment
• 63 countries prohibit all corporal punishment of kids

The tide is turning globally against corporal punishment. But in most of the U.S., spanking remains a legal form of parental discipline. Of course, just because something is legal does not mean it is advisable. There is a growing mountain of evidence on the potential harms of spanking children.

Research on the Impacts of Spanking

Many parents feel spanking is a reasonable and effective way to discipline their children. However, decades of research suggest otherwise. Here is a summary of what we know about the impacts of spanking from scientific studies:

Aggression and Antisocial Behavior

Numerous studies have found connections between spanking and increased aggression in children over time. For example, one recent meta analysis evaluated 75 studies on corporal punishment. It found that spanking was associated with a 13% increased risk for aggressive behavior in children. Researchers suggest spanking models and normalizes violence as a solution to problems.

Mental Health Issues

Beyond aggression, the meta analysis above found links between spanking and increased risk for depression, anxiety, substance abuse and other mental health problems later in life. A 2010 study found similar associations. Researchers suggest spanking may negatively impact relationships between parent and child.

Cognitive Ability

Harsh physical discipline has been connected with slower cognitive development and lower academic achievement. One analysis found children who were spanked before age 5 scored lower on thinking skill tests as teenagers. Researchers hypothesize stress from physical punishment may negatively impact brain development.In summary, a wide body of research has linked spanking to increased risk for aggression, mental health issues, and cognitive problems in children. Spanking is also not associated with any positive long-term child outcomes. Of course, some children seem unaffected by spanking, while others are deeply harmed. But researchers suggest it is not worth the gamble given the potential for harm.

Arguments Around Spanking Laws

Given the research, why does opposition to legal bans on corporal punishment persist in the U.S.? Here are some of the primary arguments in this debate:

Parental Rights

Some argue legal bans infringe on parental rights to make childrearing decisions. They worry about government overreach into family matters. However, others counter that the state has a duty to protect vulnerable children from harm. There are already many laws governing how parents must care for children.

Religious Freedom

Certain religious teachings promote corporal punishment as a method to correct children. Some believe legal bans violate religious freedoms. Though, many religious leaders argue scriptures should not be interpreted to endorse harming children.

No Definitive Proof

Some claim that the research does not definitively prove causation between spanking and negative outcomes. They argue spanking is only harmful in certain contexts and when children are very young or spanked severely and frequently. However, most researchers advocate erring on the side of caution given indications of risk.

Slippery Slope

There are fears that restrictions on corporal punishment are a slippery slope leading to bans on reasonable discipline that is not physically punitive. However, many countries with full bans still allow non-physical punishments like time-outs or privilege removal.The debate around spanking laws remains heated because it touches on sensitive issues of parental rights, religious freedom and government reach into family life. However, a consensus is emerging that protecting children from harm should be the top priority.

Looking to the Future

It seems likely that more laws restricting or regulating parental corporal punishment will emerge in coming years. However, changing social norms and public education may prove more immediately impactful. Here are some signs of shifting attitudes:

• Prominent children’s organizations like the American Academy of Pediatrics strongly discourage corporal punishment. Such positions influence societal norms.
• Public awareness campaigns highlight research on alternatives to spanking that promote positive behavior. Improved understanding of child development provides tools to discipline without physical force.
• School bans help educate parents-to-be on non-physical discipline before they have children. Over time, more parents may come to view spanking as unacceptable.
• Medical professionals are increasingly screening for corporal punishment during child visits and reporting concerns. This places more scrutiny on the practice.
• Parenting styles evolve across generations. Surveys indicate more young parents today strive to use non-punitive, patient and gentle discipline approaches.

While legal bans gain momentum abroad, grassroots shifts in attitudes and parenting norms may spur more organic change in the U.S. Regardless, it is clear that support for corporal punishment is declining across all fronts. The message is resonating that children should have the right to grow up free from physical harm or degrading treatment – even light spanking.So is spanking your child illegal where you live? In most of the U.S., the answer remains no. But whether legal or not, a wide body of research indicates spanking is an ineffective discipline method that risks long-term harm to children. Cultural views on this once commonplace practice are shifting rapidly. The tide seems to have turned against parental corporal punishment, whether banned by courts and legislators or not.