Criminal Defense Lawyers

How Parents Can Fight Federal Subpoenas for Children’s Mental Health Records

How Parents Can Fight Federal Subpoenas for Children’s Mental Health Records

As a parent, you have the fundamental right to make decisions regarding your child’s healthcare and to protect their privacy. This includes mental health records that contain sensitive information about your child. However, in some cases, the federal government may attempt to subpoena these confidential records without your consent.If you receive a federal subpoena demanding your child’s mental health records, don’t panic. There are steps you can take to fight the subpoena and protect your child’s privacy rights. Here is what you need to know:

Understanding Federal Authority to Subpoena Records

The federal government has the authority to issue subpoenas to obtain records as part of federal investigations or legal proceedings. However, federal agencies must follow protocols and have legitimate justification to subpoena confidential health records, especially those of a minor.According to mental health lawyers, federal subpoenas typically must establish:

• Probable cause – valid, factual evidence that the records contain information relevant to an investigation
• Particularity – precisely identify the records sought and the relevant timeframes
• Patient notice – inform the patient or legal guardian regarding the request

If these conditions are not explicitly met, the subpoena may be vulnerable to getting quashed.

Grounds for Motioning to Quash the Subpoena

As soon as you receive notice of a federal subpoena for your child’s records, contact a lawyer to discuss filing a motion to quash. This is a formal request asking the court to cancel or void the subpoena before records are released.Possible grounds for quashing the subpoena include:

• Lack of probable cause – the subpoena is vague or records irrelevant to investigation
• Unreasonable breadth – the request is overly broad and invasive of privacy
• Privileged communications – records obtained would violate patient confidentiality
• Undue burden – fulfilling the request is unreasonably time-consuming or expensive

An experienced lawyer can help demonstrate these deficiencies to the court in order to protect your child’s records from release.

Using HIPAA and FERPA to Uphold Privacy Rights

Two key federal laws establish important privacy protections for health records that parents can leverage to fight subpoenas:

1. HIPAA

The [Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)] regulates protection and sharing of medical information. Under HIPAA, mental health records are considered Protected Health Information.Key HIPAA provisions parents can cite to uphold their child’s privacy rights include:

• Patients or legal guardians must receive notice of all disclosures of protected health information
• Covered entities may only disclose minimum health information needed for the purpose
• Disclosures should be limited to what is expressly permitted under the law

If a subpoena violates these HIPAA rules, argue that compliance would contradict federal privacy standards.

2. FERPA

The [Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA)] governs access to student records held by schools. This could include mental health records of children and teens.Important FERPA provisions include:

• Parents and eligible students must receive notice of all requests to access records
• Schools require written parental consent to release records or personally identifiable information to third parties

If a federal subpoena attempts to bypass this consent, cite violation of FERPA as grounds for a motion to quash.

Seeking Legal Representation

Fighting a federal subpoena is complex, with short deadlines. Therefore, legal help is critical for parents disputing demands for a child’s confidential mental health records.

• Consult a lawyer immediately if your child’s records are subpoenaed so motions can be filed urgently
• Consider contacting the [ACLU] or [Mental Health Legal Advisors Committee] for advice and possible legal aid
• Hire an attorney experienced in federal subpoenas, administrative law, and health privacy statutes
• Be prepared to cover legal fees, which may range from $200-$500 per hour

Though expensive, a good lawyer well-versed in relevant laws can give parents the best chance to successfully resist unlawful subpoenas and protect their child’s rights.

What to Do If the Motion to Quash Fails

If your best efforts fail and the court orders your child’s mental health records to be released per the federal subpoena, don’t lose hope. As the child’s legal guardian, you still have options:

• Negotiate redaction – Offer to release records only if all personally identifying information is blacked out
• Limit scope – Try to minimize the timeframe or specific types of records disclosed
• Protect originals – Ensure federal agents or agencies do not retain any original records after making copies
• Request destruction – Require they destroy all copies provided after use for the case
• Appeal ruling – Contest the court’s decision permitting disclosure by filing an appeal

Though not ideal, attempting to negotiate limitations can still help mitigate privacy violations if efforts to quash the subpoena fail.

Questions Parents Should Ask Attorneys

If your child’s mental health records are subpoenaed, interview potential lawyers with questions like:

• What experience do you have fighting federal demands for confidential records?
• What are the most effective legal arguments to quash this subpoena for my child’s records?
• What is your strategy for compelling evidence of probable cause and particularity?
• How quickly can you take action to file a motion to quash?
• What other options do parents have if the subpoena is not successfully quashed?
• What steps can we take to maximize privacy protections for my child if records must be disclosed?

Find a lawyer who can confidently answer these questions and demonstrate a strong grasp of current laws and past cases. An attorney well-versed in protecting sensitive data can help you uphold your rights as a parent.

Conclusion: Act Quickly and Persistently to Fight Subpoenas

Receiving a federal subpoena for your child’s confidential mental health records is undoubtedly stressful. However, by acting swiftly to engage legal representation, parents can take steps to resist release of sensitive information. Grounds like lack of probable cause, overbreadth, privacy rights violations and undue burden may convince a court to quash an improper subpoena. If records must still be disclosed, continuing to firmly negotiate limitations and privacy safeguards can help mitigate harm. With persistence and commitment to protecting your child, parents can overcome many obstacles in fighting government demands for mental health data.

Resources

Articles with Additional Information:

• [What is a Motion to Quash?]
• [Responding to Improper Subpoenas for Medical Records]
• [How to Protect Patient Privacy from Investigation Requests]

Videos Explaining Motions to Quash:

• [Challenging a Subpoena: Motions to Quash – What You Need to Know]

References:

: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/arguhv/how_to_prevent_the_federal_government_from/
: https://www.avvo.com/topics/mental-health-law: https://www.lawinfo.com/resources/civil-rights/motion-to-quash.html: https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-individuals/guidance-materials-for-consumers/index.html: https://studentprivacy.ed.gov/faq/what-ferpa: https://www.aclu.org: https://mhlac.org/
: https://www.findlaw.com/litigation/legal-system/what-is-a-motion-to-quash-.html
: https://www.americanbar.org/groups/gpsolo/publications/gp_solo/2012/november_december2012privacy/responding_improper_subpoenas_medical_records/
: https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/how-to-protect-patient-privacy-from-7480289/
: https://youtu.be/JEEPf-n34Bo