Criminal Defense Lawyers

How Long is a Subpoena Valid For After Being Issued?

How Long is a Subpoena Valid For After Being Issued?

Subpoenas are powerful legal tools that compel individuals and organizations to provide documents, testify at depositions, or appear in court. But subpoenas are not indefinite – they expire after a certain period of time if unused. Knowing how long a subpoena remains valid and enforceable is important for both the issuing party and the subpoena recipient. This article provides an overview of subpoena duration limits and factors that can affect how long a subpoena stays in effect after being issued.

What is the Default Validity Period for Subpoenas?

In most state and federal courts in the U.S., the default rule is that subpoenas have a “return date” falling no more than 30 days after the subpoena’s date of issuance. The return date is the date by which the subpoenaed party must comply by producing the requested documents or testimony.If the return date passes without the subpoena being served on the recipient, then the subpoena expires and has no legal force. Essentially, a subpoena has a 30-day shelf life from when it’s issued if not properly served.For example, if a subpoena was issued and signed by the court clerk on January 1st and specifies a return date of January 30th, then it must be served on the recipient by January 30th to remain valid. If the deadline passes without proper service, the subpoena holder would need to obtain a new subpoena with an updated return date.Some state laws and court rules provide exceptions or longer validity periods for certain types of subpoenas, so the 30-day duration is not absolute. But in general, 30 days is the standard default lifespan.

When Does the Subpoena Clock Start Ticking?

A key question is when does the 30-day countdown begin for a subpoena to “expire” if not used? There are a few key trigger dates:

• Date of issuance – The most common trigger is the date the subpoena was signed and issued by the court clerk, attorney, or other authorized officer. Even if not served, many courts deem subpoenas to expire 30 days from issuance.
• Date of service – Some courts start the 30-day duration upon service of the subpoena to the recipient, rather than the earlier issuance date. Each day the subpoenaed party has to comply counts against the 30-day limit under this approach.
• Return date – A few courts have held that the return date specified on the subpoena represents the expiration date, regardless of issuance or service date. However, this is a minority approach.
• Date of compliance – In rare cases, the clock may run from when the subpoena recipient has to produce documents or testify, rather than issuance/service dates. This is highly jurisdiction-specific.

The issuance date is the most common controlling date, but be sure to check local court rules on subpoena duration. The service date may control in some courts.

How Does the Return Date Affect Duration?

As noted above, subpoenas typically must include a “return date” by which the recipient must comply. Return dates are usually set no more than 30 days from issuance, which reinforces the 30-day validity period.But parties sometimes improperly make return dates longer than 30 days, like 60 or 90 days in the future. Does this make the subpoena valid for 60-90 days? Not necessarily.Many courts hold that no matter the return date, subpoenas still expire 30 days from issuance or service. An outlying return date beyond 30 days is invalid and gets shortened to 30 days automatically.So while return dates often align with the 30-day duration, they don’t necessarily extend a subpoena’s shelf life beyond the standard period. Check local rules on whether courts strictly enforce the 30-day cap regardless of return date.

Can a Subpoena Be Extended Beyond 30 Days?

What if a party needs more than 30 days to properly serve and enforce a subpoena to get required evidence? In some cases, it may be possible to extend the duration of a subpoena by requesting the court to issue a new order with a further-out return date. Grounds for extensions may include:

• Difficulty locating and serving the subpoena recipient within 30 days.
• Recipient negotiations to limit subpoena scope taking longer than 30 days.
• Need for additional time to comply with expansive or complex document requests.
• Unavoidable delays due to intervening holidays, illnesses, or other exceptional circumstances.

Motions to extend subpoena return dates are not guaranteed to be granted. Courts will weigh factors like diligence in trying to serve the subpoena and fairness to the recipient. But extensions can buy additional time if really needed.Without a court-ordered extension, though, a subpoena will expire 30 days from issuance or service in most jurisdictions.

How Does Service by Mail Affect Duration?

When a subpoena is served by first-class mail, additional time is allowed for receipt before the return date kicks in. Under federal rules and most states’ rules, five extra days are added to the duration when service is by mail.For example, say a subpoena with a 30-day return date is mailed on January 1st. The recipient is then allowed until February 4th to comply – 30 days for the return date plus five days for mail service.So the effective duration becomes 35 days for mailed subpoenas. This accounts for potential mail delays. If personally served, the 30-day limit would be strict with no five-day grace period.

What Happens If a Subpoena Expires Before Compliance?

If a subpoena recipient has not complied by the return date and the subpoena expires, the requesting party loses the ability to directly enforce compliance. Expired subpoenas no longer provide any grounds to compel production of documents or testimony.However, even if a subpoena has expired, the underlying case or investigation does not simply go away. There are still options to pursue the evidence, including:

• Issuing a new, replacement subpoena with an updated return date.
• Negotiating voluntary cooperation from the recipient.
• Seeking a court order to reopen discovery and allow a new subpoena.
• Using alternative discovery tools like requests for production and interrogatories.

So while an expired subpoena cuts off one avenue, creative attorneys have ways to work around it and still obtain the needed evidence through other lawful means.