How do I find the best criminal defense attorney for my case in New York City?

How to Find the Best Criminal Defense Attorney in New York City

If you’ve been arrested or charged with a crime in New York City, having the right lawyer by your side is crucial. But with so many options, how do you find the very best criminal defense attorney for your specific case?

This article explains what to look for and how to choose a top NYC criminal lawyer to protect your rights and give you the strongest defense.

Focus on Criminal Defense Experience

The first thing to look for is a lawyer who specializes specifically in criminal defense. Handling criminal cases is very different from other legal practice areas.

Seek out attorneys who devote at least 50% or more of their work to criminal defense. Check their website or consultations to understand their level of criminal law experience.

Avoid dabblers who take the occasional criminal case but focus mainly on other areas. Your freedom is on the line – you want an expert criminal defense lawyer fighting for you.

Find Someone Local to the NYC Courts

Look for a lawyer who is intimately familiar with the New York City court system. Every county’s courts have their own unique procedures, personalities and politics.

An NYC attorney who regularly practices in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx or Staten Island will know the judges, prosecutors and court staff. They’ll understand the unwritten rules and nuances to effectively navigate the local legal system.

Check Their Credentials

A good criminal lawyer should have strong educational and professional credentials, including:

• Graduated from a top law school
• Earned a Juris Doctor (J.D.) degree
• Admitted to the New York State Bar
• No history of disciplinary issues or license suspensions

Be wary of lawyers who went to unaccredited schools or got a law degree online. Also confirm they are currently licensed and in good standing.

Look for Trial Experience

The very best criminal defense attorneys have extensive courtroom and trial experience. Ask:

• How many jury trials have they taken to verdict?
• What types of criminal cases have they tried?
• What are their win/loss rates?

A lawyer who constantly goes to trial will be comfortable mounting an aggressive defense in front of a jury if your case goes to trial.

Consider Former Prosecutors

Former prosecutors can make excellent criminal defense attorneys. As a prosecutor they gained direct experience building criminal cases. This gives them insight into the prosecution’s strategies and how to counter them.

But make sure they now devote their practice 100% to criminal defense rather than still working both sides.

Find Someone Passionate About Their Work

The best attorneys are passionate about defending the accused. During consultations, get a feel for why they practice criminal law and their dedication to protecting client rights.

Beware lawyers who seem indifferent, arrogant or too busy to focus on your case. Look for someone committed to obtaining the best possible outcome for you.

Consider Boutique Firms

Smaller, specialized criminal defense firms are a good option. Benefits include:

• More focus and expertise in criminal law
• Lower caseloads so they can devote time to your defense
• Less bureaucracy than large general practice firms

But make sure the firm has adequate resources to handle serious felony cases if needed.

Check Reviews and Recommendations

Spend time researching lawyers’ reputations and feedback from past clients, including:

• Online reviews on Google, Avvo, etc.
• Testimonials on their website
• References you can speak with directly
• Referrals from trusted friends, family or other attorneys

This helps assess their client relationships, communication skills and success record.

Interview Multiple Attorneys

Speak with a few candidates before deciding. Compare qualifications, experience, case strategies and communication styles.

Schedule initial consultations, which are often free. Be ready with questions to assess if they are the right fit.

Consider Rapport and Communication

This is a relationship built on trust. Make sure you feel comfortable with and confident in the lawyer. Look for:

• Clear communication skills
• Patience in answering your questions
• Respectful towards you as a client
• Responsive to calls/emails

You’ll be working closely together, so it’s crucial to have a strong rapport.

Discuss Legal Strategy

A skilled lawyer will analyze the charges and evidence against you and explain possible defenses and negotiation strategies. If they can’t articulate a solid game plan, cross them off your list.

Compare Legal Fees

Factor legal fees into your decision, but don’t let it be the determining factor. Public defenders are free but often overburdened. Private attorneys’ rates vary widely.

Balance cost with experience and track record. Quality legal representation may be worth paying more for, especially for serious charges.

Trust Your Gut

Go with your instincts. If a lawyer seems disinterested, unethical or untrustworthy, look elsewhere. You need someone who inspires confidence they will fight for the best outcome in your case.

The Bottom Line

Choosing the right criminal lawyer is an important decision when your life or livelihood is on the line. Do diligent research and ask questions to find an attorney with the skills, experience and determination to be your zealous advocate.

References

• Tips for Hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer | Nolo
• When and How to Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney | Lawyers.com
• A Consumer’s Guide to Hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer
• Hiring a Lawyer | NY CourtHelp
• Working with a Lawyer | New York City Bar