Blog
does a subpoena mean you are in trouble
Does Getting a Subpoena Mean You’re in Trouble?
If you’ve received a subpoena, you might be wondering – am I in some kind of legal trouble here? Getting dragged into a court case can be intimidating, so it’s normal to feel anxious when you get that knock on the door from the process server. Let’s break down what a subpoena actually is, what it means for you, and what you need to do next.
What is a Subpoena?
A subpoena is basically a court order for you to provide information related to a legal case. The info can be in the form of testimony, documents, or physical evidence. There ya go – that’s your quick n’ dirty definition right there.
Subpoenas are used in both criminal and civil cases. For example, if you witnessed a car accident, you might get a subpoena to testify in court about what you saw. Or if you work for a company involved in a lawsuit, you could get a subpoena requesting emails or other documents.
So getting a subpoena doesn’t necessarily mean you’re in trouble or did anything wrong. More likely, one of the parties in the case believes you have relevant info that could help their side of things.
Should You Be Worried?
Okay, just because a subpoena doesn’t automatically mean you’re in hot water doesn’t mean you should just shrug it off either. You’re still being compelled by the court to hand over information related to a legal dispute. This is serious business and needs to be handled carefully.
If the subpoena is requesting personal and confidential information from you, that can feel like an invasion of privacy. And if you’re being called to testify, having to take the witness stand and answer attorneys’ questions under oath can be nerve-wracking.
Plus, there may be legal implications if you fail to fully comply with the subpoena. Fines or even jail time for contempt of court are rare but still possibilities.
So in summary – no, getting a subpoena doesn’t inherently mean you’re in trouble. But you shouldn’t just blow it off. This is a formal court order that carries quite a bit of legal weight.
What Type of Subpoena Did You Get?
There are a few different types of subpoenas, each with their own specifics about what info is being requested and how you need to provide it:
- Subpoena ad testificandum – This scary-sounding Latin name just means a subpoena to testify, either in a deposition outside of court or during a trial.
- Subpoena duces tecum – Now we’re really breaking out the Latin! This type of subpoena orders you to produce physical evidence or documents.
- Grand jury subpoena – Issued on behalf of a grand jury hearing evidence about a potential criminal case. Still could be just informational.
- Trial subpoena – Yeah, this one means you’re likely being called to testify in court. Time to get that suit dry cleaned!
So the type of subpoena gives you a hint about your role in the case. The document should explain what specific info or testimony is required from you. Understanding those details will help you figure out the best way to respond.
What Are Your Options for Responding?
Generally speaking, you have three options after being served with a subpoena:
- Comply – Provide the requested info as spelled out in the subpoena. This is usually the best route, as long as the request seems reasonable and you have the information handy.
- Object – File a motion to “quash” (fancy legal-speak for cancel) the subpoena if you believe it is improper, unreasonable, or privileged. This asks the court to cancel or modify the subpoena.
- Disobey – You could choose not to respond at all, but then you risk being held in contempt of court if the subpoena is found to be valid. As they say on Reddit, “this is not the way”.
If you’re unsure what to do after being served a subpoena, don’t stress! Reach out to an attorney to understand your options. A lawyer can review the subpoena, explain what is being asked of you, and help craft your response.
Do You Need a Lawyer?
Great question! There’s no legal requirement to get a lawyer just because you received a subpoena. If it’s asking for basic info and you don’t mind providing it, you may be able handle it yourself without hiring counsel.
But for anything complex or sensitive, having an attorney in your corner is smart. Subpoenas can have tricky procedural rules and deadlines. An experienced lawyer knows how to respond correctly. They can also negotiate modifications or file motions to limit the scope if it seems unreasonable.
And if you’re being called to testify as a witness, prepping with a lawyer is clutch. Going through practice questions helps you feel less anxious handling the Q&A. In a worst-case scenario where you end up a target in a criminal investigation, you’ll definitely want to shut up and lawyer up.
Can You Get Out of Complying?
Let’s circle back to the question we started with – does receiving a subpoena mean you have to comply no matter what?
The answer is technically no. If you believe the subpoena violates a privilege or constitutional right, you can file a motion to quash with the court. This asks a judge to cancel or modify the subpoena.
Examples where you may be able to fight having to comply include:
- Attorney-client privilege
- Doctor-patient confidentiality
- Trade secrets
- Private info protected by privacy laws
If the subpoena seems overly broad or unduly burdensome, your lawyer can negotiate the scope or request reasonable fees to cover your costs.
But in many cases, attempting to avoid complying with a subpoena will be uphill battle. Judges expect parties to cooperate with evidence collection and discovery. Unless there’s a very clear basis like attorney-client privilege, you’ll likely have to produce something.
What Happens If You Don’t Comply?
It should be pretty clear by now that you can’t just ignore a subpoena. As an official court order, there may be consequences if you fail to respond:
Contempt of Court – A judge could rule you in contempt, leading to fines or even jail time in extreme cases.
Financial Penalties – Even without a contempt ruling, you may be ordered to pay the legal fees related to filing a motion to compel your compliance.
Bench Warrant – For serious violations, the judge might issue a warrant instructing law enforcement to arrest you and bring you to provide the required testimony or documents.
Default Ruling – If your participation is critical to a case, the judge can rule against a party for failure to comply with evidentiary rules.
These penalties are rare for minor infractions by third-party witnesses. But blatantly stonewalling the court’s authority almost always ends badly. Don’t go down that road if you can avoid it!
Stay Calm and Call a Lawyer!
Being served a subpoena can be unsettling, even if you don’t think you did anything wrong. Having to testify or share private information related to a legal dispute you’re not involved in can feel weird and invasive.
But now you know – receiving a subpoena doesn’t inherently mean you are personally in trouble or at risk. More likely, you simply have evidence that is relevant to help resolve the case.
The best plan is to stay calm, review the details, and call an attorney to discuss your options. With an experienced lawyer guiding you, you can properly evaluate the request and respond appropriately. Handled correctly, this stressful legal episode will be resolved smoothly and you can move forward.
And if it turns out the subpoena does indicate you’re being targeted in an investigation, your lawyer can protect your rights. Either way, you’ll rest easy getting pro tips from a legal eagle!