29 Nov 23

Do Treason Charges Really Carry the Death Penalty?

| by

Last Updated on: 15th December 2023, 01:56 pm

Do Treason Charges Really Carry the Death Penalty?

Treason is considered one of the most serious crimes someone can commit against the United States. The Constitution defines treason as levying war against the U.S. or giving aid and comfort to its enemies. So it’s not surprising that treason carries severe penalties, including potentially the death penalty.

But does a treason conviction really mean an automatic death sentence these days? The answer is more complicated than you might think. While treason charges can technically result in capital punishment, the reality is that no one has been executed for treason in the U.S. for over 60 years.

What the Law Says

According to federal law, anyone convicted of treason “shall suffer death, or shall be imprisoned not less than five years and fined under this title but not less than $10,000.” So technically, yes – the death penalty is an option for treason.

However, the law also gives judges discretion to impose a lesser sentence if they choose. The law states that the death penalty applies “except where the court exercises its power to impose a lesser sentence.” This provision gives judges some flexibility based on the specific circumstances of each case.

Recent History and Precedent

While treason can carry the death penalty, legal precedent and historical practice suggest it’s rarely applied nowadays. The last time anyone was executed for treason in the U.S. was back in 1953.

In that case, Julius and Ethel Rosenberg were convicted of passing nuclear secrets to the Soviet Union during the Cold War and executed in the electric chair. However, even at the height of Cold War tensions, their execution was controversial.

Since then, lighter punishments have been more common. For example, in 1994, Aldrich Ames was sentenced to life in prison after pleading guilty to spying for the Soviet Union and later Russia while serving as a CIA officer.

So while the death penalty is still on the books for treason, legal experts argue that modern interpretations of “cruel and unusual punishment” make it highly unlikely that execution would be imposed or upheld today except in extreme cases like treason during wartime.

LEARN MORE  Criminal Tax Fraud in the Second Degree: NY Tax Law 1805

Why the Death Penalty for Treason Is So Rare

There are several reasons why the death penalty is rarely applied for treason convictions anymore despite technically being an option under the law.

First, legal interpretations of the Eighth Amendment have made capital punishment much less common over time for all crimes. The Supreme Court has ruled that the death penalty constitutes “cruel and unusual punishment” in many circumstances. Treason during peacetime would likely fall into this category.

Second, treason cases are extremely rare overall. According to one analysis, fewer than 30 Americans have been convicted of treason in the entire history of the United States. So there just aren’t many opportunities for prosecutors to seek the death penalty.

Finally, there are often extenuating circumstances or political considerations that make a death sentence unlikely. For example, sentences may be reduced in exchange for cooperation, or to avoid creating a political martyr.

What About Other Penalties?

Even if the death penalty is not imposed, a treason conviction still carries harsh penalties. As noted above, federal law mandates a minimum prison sentence of 5 years. However, life in prison is common for treason.

In addition to imprisonment, convicted traitors typically face fines of tens of thousands of dollars or more. They generally lose citizenship rights as well, including the right to hold public office, vote, and access government benefits.

So while capital punishment for treason is still permitted by law, a conviction effectively means life-altering consequences at a minimum, even if execution is deemed “cruel and unusual punishment” in modern courts.

Could Treason Charges Today Carry a Death Sentence?

Given legal precedents and evolving standards around capital punishment, most legal experts think a death sentence is highly unlikely for treason today except in extreme cases like treason during open warfare.

However, federal prosecutors still have discretion to seek the death penalty under the letter of the law. Ultimately, judges and juries would decide whether such a punishment is constitutional and appropriate on a case-by-case basis.

So while the death penalty for treason seems like mostly a relic of history, the possibility can’t be ruled out entirely in the right circumstances. Treason charges remain among the most serious allegations someone can face under U.S. law.

The bottom line is treason convictions still carry very real risks to life and liberty. So we’re unlikely to see treason charges thrown around lightly, even if execution remains an outlier outcome given modern legal interpretations.