27 Nov 23

The Role of Forensic Evidence in Long Island Criminal Cases

| by

Last Updated on: 6th December 2023, 11:06 pm

The Long Island Serial Killer Case and the Vital Role of Forensic Evidence

The recent arrest of Rex Heuermann as a suspect in the infamous Long Island serial killer case highlights how critical forensic evidence can be in solving cold cases. This case has confounded law enforcement for over a decade, but advances in DNA analysis and digital forensics are finally enabling prosecutors to piece together enough evidence to charge a suspect.

In this article, we’ll look at how various types of forensic evidence helped crack this case, and what it means for prosecuting cold cases more broadly. Specifically, we’ll touch on:

  • The discovery of key DNA evidence
  • Surveillance footage and digital traces
  • Implications for prosecuting cold cases

DNA Evidence: The “Turning Point”

As experts have noted, DNA evidence is the “gold standard” when building a murder case, even circumstantial ones. In the early 2010s, partial DNA samples were recovered from the bodies of victims linked to the Long Island serial killer. However, this DNA did not initially match to any known suspect in CODIS (the FBI’s DNA database).

A break in the case came when investigators were able to link DNA from pizza crust Heuermann had thrown out to genetic material found on one victim’s remains. As the DA noted, this DNA hit marked a “turning point” in directly tying a suspect to the killings after so many years. Additional DNA testing also revealed the suspect’s familial connections to material found on victims.

The fact that advances in DNA testing enabled investigators to identify a suspect after over 10 years highlights its unmatched value. As one former detective noted, “DNA doesn’t forget, it doesn’t die, it just waits there to be tested.” Even if other evidence goes cold, preserved DNA can potentially lead to arrests decades later as technology improves.

Surveillance and Digital Evidence

Beyond DNA, prosecutors have revealed that their evidence against Heuermann includes an enormous cache of digital traces – 2,500 pages of records, hundreds of hours of surveillance footage, etc.

Specifically, surveillance video captures Heuermann interacting with victims before their deaths. Phone and computer records also place him communicating with victims, researching their deaths afterward, and searching for violent pornography.

This shows how the expansion of digital devices and surveillance systems is transforming how cold cases are prosecuted. Detectives can now scour vast digital archives for long-buried clues, from timestamped photos to browser histories. Technologies like facial recognition can also match suspects to fuzzy surveillance footage that would have been useless 20 years ago.


Implications for Prosecuting Cold Cases

The Long Island serial killer case shows that even the coldest case can be cracked given today’s forensic capabilities. As one former prosecutor commented, “the passage of time always seems to be working in favor of the killer. Now it’s working in favor of law enforcement.”

Advances in fields like forensic genetics, digital forensics, geospatial tracking, etc. are making it increasingly hard for killers to hide their tracks forever. Preserved DNA evidence can retain its integrity for decades under proper storage conditions. Digital archives tend to expand over time as more data is recorded, increasing the chances that critical evidence will emerge.

For these reasons, law enforcement agencies are ramping up efforts to systematically re-test cold case biological evidence and dig into digital records for new leads. Given enough manpower and technology, experts believe the vast majority of cold cases could eventually be solved.

The Long Island case highlights that forensic evidence remains the core of prosecuting cold cases. As one detective noted, even circumstantial cases require a strong forensic backbone linking the suspect and victims. While DNA gets the most press, digital evidence is rapidly emerging as just as vital in placing suspects. We may never know exactly what happened along Ocean Parkway beach all those years ago. But thanks to advances in forensic technology, the victims’ families may finally get some long-awaited answers and justice.