Can I be charged for lying about being sick?
Contents
Can I be Charged for Lying About Being Sick?
We’ve all been tempted to fake an illness to get out of work or school. But is it actually illegal? Can you face legal charges for lying about being sick? The short answer is maybe. There are some cases where lying about an illness can get you in legal trouble. But there are also defenses and exceptions. Let’s break it down.
When Lying About Illness Becomes Fraud
In most cases, simply calling in sick when you’re not actually ill is not illegal. Employment lawyers say it’s usually not considered fraud for an employee to “play hooky” from work. After all, you are giving up a day’s pay. And most bosses chalk it up to people needing the occasional mental health day.
But in certain situations, faking sickness crosses the line into committing fraud. This can happen when:
- You lie about having a serious illness like cancer or COVID-19 to scam money from people through fundraisers or GoFundMe campaigns. That’s obtaining money under false pretenses, which is illegal.
- You fake an illness to try to collect disability benefits you aren’t entitled to. Disability fraud cheats taxpayers and is prosecuted aggressively.
- You lie about being sick to get extended FMLA leave. Using up FMLA leave under false pretenses can count as fraud.
- You falsely claim to have COVID or another illness that requires you to quarantine to avoid work or legal obligations. That becomes an illegal excuse in many cases.
So lying about illness becomes fraud mainly when it causes economic harm or deprives others of rights/resources illegally. Most simple “little white lies” don’t rise to the level of being prosecuted. But lies that scam or cheat people/companies can mean felony fraud charges.
What About Doctor’s Notes?
Faking a doctor’s note to excuse an illness seems to up the ante. After all, now there’s a forged medical document involved. But legal experts say a phony doctor’s note alone usually isn’t illegal. It typically only becomes an issue if you use it as part of a larger fraud scheme. Some key points on fake doctor’s notes:
- Simply forging a doctor’s signature on a note for work/school is not by itself against the law in most states. It may violate company policy and get you fired. But it’s not a crime.
- Some states make it illegal to falsify medical records. But a sick note is not considered an official medical record in most cases. So this law does not usually apply.
- Using a fake doctor’s note could be evidence supporting a fraud charge if you lied about having an illness to scam money or benefits.
- If you share/sell fake medical notes as part of an organized business, you could potentially be charged with health care fraud. But notes used individually are not likely to trigger this.
The bottom line is a phony doctor’s note alone is not going to land you in legal jeopardy in most instances. It’s usually not considered fraud by itself – but could contribute to a larger fraud case.
What Defenses Exist to Illness Fraud Charges?
Let’s say you told some major lies about having cancer or COVID-19 and now face fraud accusations. What defense options do you have? There are a few strategies a defense lawyer might use, like:
- Free speech – Arguing the illness claims were simply free speech rather than fraud. Free speech covers some lies that don’t directly swindle people.
- Mental health – Claiming mental illness or delusions led you to believe the lies yourself. This could mean entering mental health treatment rather than jail.
- Lack of intent – Arguing you never intended to defraud anyone for economic gain. This could punch holes in the prosecution’s case.
- Technicalities – Many fraud accusations hinge on technical elements like specific legal definitions or documentary evidence. Nitpicking these details could create reasonable doubt of guilt.
But while defenses exist, it’s still best not to lie about major illnesses in the first place. The public takes diseases like cancer very seriously. And COVID scams have become high priority for prosecutors. So don’t take the risk if you can avoid it.
What Penalties Are Possible for Illness Fraud?
Let’s say you do get convicted of fraud related to faking sickness. What penalties might you face? It depends on factors like:
- How much money was involved in the fraud
- How many victims were defrauded
- What state you live in
- Whether you have a past criminal record
But in general, common consequences can include:
- Felony fraud charges instead of misdemeanors due to larger dollar amounts
- Prison time measured in years for major fraud convictions
- Massive fines up to $250,000 in some states
- Restitution to pay back victims what you fraudulently obtained
- Probation lasting multiple years with strict conditions
- Permanent criminal record making jobs, licensing, housing difficult
So while going to jail for a day or two of playing hooky seems far-fetched – extended prison time for major illness fraud is very real. The risks involved make faking major illnesses extremely short-sighted. Don’t let lies and temptations today ruin the rest of your life.
What If My Boss Orders Me to Work While Sick?
The COVID-19 pandemic shone a spotlight on the issue of bosses pressuring employees to work while ill. What rights do workers have? Can you get in trouble for refusing to work sick? A few key points:
- The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) says it’s illegal for employers to retaliate against workers refusing to do an unsafe job – like working closely with others while contagious.
- But most states also have “at will” employment laws. These let employers fire workers for almost any reason. There are limited protections for unjust firing.
- Talk to an employee rights group to understand your options. Getting sick coworkers on record about unsafe practices can bolster claims. Review company policies too.
- Threatening to report OSHA violations may convince employers to back off demands to work while sick. But you could still ultimately be fired in some states.
So the situation ends up being complex for employees with few easy answers. We all need to keep advocating for improved worker protection laws around illness. Because no one should have to risk their livelihood to recover from major surgery, COVID, or other health crises. Health experts say a culture supporting sick leave improves public health outcomes too. There are still gaps in the system, but we’ll get there through perseverance.