24/7 call for a free consultation 212-300-5196




When you’re facing a federal issue, you need an attorney whose going to be available 24/7 to help you get the results and outcome you need. The value of working with the Spodek Law Group is that we treat each and every client like a member of our family.

Can I be charged for lying about a product I sell?


Can I be charged for lying about a product I sell?

Selling a product and making false claims about it can definitely get you in legal trouble. There are laws against fraud and false advertising that are meant to protect consumers from being ripped off. As a seller, it’s important to be truthful in how you promote and describe your products.

If you lie about what your product can do, how it works, what it’s made of, etc., that could be considered fraud or false advertising. For example, say your selling a supplement and claim it cures cancer when it doesn’t. Or your selling a luxury purse but it’s really a cheap knock-off. That’s illegal!

Consumer protection laws

There are a bunch of laws, both federally and at the state level, that make it illegal to lie and decieve about products your selling. Some big ones are:

  • The Federal Trade Commission Act – this prohibits “unfair or deceptive acts or practices.” So lying about your product would qualify.
  • State consumer protection laws – most states have laws against false advertising and fraud.
  • The Lanham Act – a federal law that prohibits false advertising and promotional activities.

These laws all make it so sellers have to be truthful. You can’t lie and scam people just to make sales and money. That’s immoral and illegal!

What charges or penalties could their be?

There’s a bunch of ways you could get in trouble for lying about a product:

  • The FTC could bring civil charges against you and make you pay fines or do restitution.
  • You could face criminal fraud charges at the federal or state level.
  • Consumers could sue you themselves under consumer protection laws.
  • You’d have to stop selling the product and maybe do a recall.
  • Your company would get a lot of bad publicity.

So ya, it’s really not worth it to lie and misrepresent things. Your looking at big fines, lawsuits, maybe even jail time. And who wants to go to jail for selling some bogus product! Not fun.

What if it was an honest mistake?

Now sometimes sellers make honest mistakes and say things about a product that aren’t totally true. Like maybe you thought something was organic but it really wasn’t. Or you said a supplement would help with weight loss but don’t have solid proof it will.

In cases like that where it’s not intentional false advertising, you may be able to avoid civil or criminal charges. You’d still have to correct your marketing and stop making the claims. But authorities may see it as just a mistake, not fraud.

To avoid issues, always double check your claims and make sure their backed up. Consult lawyers if your ever unsure. Better safe than sorry!

What are some defenses people use?

Their are a few main defenses people use when accused of false advertising:

  • Lack of intent – you can argue you didn’t intend to mislead people and it was just an accident.
  • Free speech – you can claim false statements are protected free speech under the First Amendment.
  • Puffery – argue the claims were just exaggerated “puffery” that no reasonable person would take literally.

But these defenses don’t always work. If their’s clear evidence you intentionally lied or knew statements were false, the “lack of intent” argument fails. And false or misleading commercial speech isn’t protected the same as other speech.

It really comes down to the specific facts and circumstances of each case. But in general, just don’t lie about your products! That’s the best policy.

How can sellers be more ethical?

The best thing is just to be honest and transparent about what your selling. Some tips:

  • Research your product thoroughly and test all claims.
  • Consult lawyers if your ever unsure about marketing language.
  • Disclose details – don’t hide negatives.
  • Have evidence to back up all claims.
  • Update marketing if new info comes to light.
  • Don’t exaggerate – be realistic.

It’s always better to under-promise and over-deliver. Hype can increase sales temporarily but destroys trust long-term. Taking the high road of honesty might seem hard but it pays off!

The bottom line

Lying and deceiving about a product to make sales is not only unethical but illegal. Consumer laws exist to protect people from fraud. As a seller, you must be truthful and transparent. Sure, some exaggeration happens in advertising but outright lying crosses the line and can lead to serious penalties. Do your research, back up claims, and consult lawyers with any doubts. Staying honest and ethical isn’t just good values – it’s good business!


Schedule Your Consultation Now