Best Indianapolis Criminal Lawyers

If you or a loved one have been charged with a crime in Indianapolis, you need an experienced criminal defense attorney on your side. The criminal justice system can be confusing and intimidating, but a good lawyer will advocate for your rights and help you understand the process. This article provides an overview of working with criminal lawyers in Indianapolis – from finding the right attorney to understanding the stages of a criminal case.

Finding the Right Criminal Lawyer in Indianapolis

The first step after an arrest is finding a criminal defense lawyer you can trust. Here are some tips:

  • Ask friends and family for recommendations. Word-of-mouth is often the best way to find a great lawyer.
  • Search lawyer directories like the Indiana State Bar Association. You can browse by practice area and location.
  • Look for a lawyer with significant experience handling your type of criminal case. An experienced DUI lawyer is ideal for drunk driving charges, for example.
  • Make sure the lawyer is licensed in Indiana. You want someone familiar with state laws.
  • Schedule consultations with a few lawyers before deciding. Most offer free initial consultations.
  • Consider lawyers who offer flat fees or payment plans. Criminal cases can get expensive.
  • Go with someone you feel comfortable with. This is a stressful time, so you want an attorney you can trust.

Don’t just choose the cheapest lawyer or the first one you talk to. Vet them thoroughly – this is your future on the line.

Understanding the Criminal Justice Process in Indianapolis

Once you’ve hired a lawyer, they’ll guide you through the stages of the criminal justice process. Here’s what you can generally expect:

Arrest and Booking

If police have probable cause, they can arrest you without a warrant. You’ll be photographed, fingerprinted and held until bail is set. Don’t say anything until your lawyer arrives.

Initial Hearing

Within 48 hours of arrest, you’ll go before a judge who informs you of the charges and sets bail. Your lawyer can argue for lower or no bail. Don’t speak unless your attorney advises it.

Grand Jury Hearing

For felonies, a grand jury decides if there’s enough evidence for indictment. Your lawyer can argue against indictment. If approved, your case moves forward.


You’ll appear in court to enter a plea – guilty, not guilty or no contest. Your lawyer will guide your plea. Not guilty means taking your case to trial.

Pretrial Motions

Your attorney can file motions to get evidence dismissed or suppress evidence obtained illegally. This is an important step.

Plea Bargaining

Your lawyer may negotiate with the prosecutor to get charges reduced or dropped in exchange for a guilty plea.


If no plea bargain, your case will go to a bench trial (judge only) or jury trial. Your lawyer will defend you throughout the trial process.


If found guilty, the judge determines your penalty – jail, prison, probation, fines, etc. Your lawyer argues for minimal sentencing.This is just a general overview – each case is unique. An experienced criminal attorney knows how to navigate the system and protect your rights. Lean on their expertise.

Common Criminal Charges in Indianapolis

The charges you face impact how your case proceeds. Here are some of the most common criminal offenses in Indianapolis:

Drug Crimes

Drug charges like possession, distribution, trafficking and manufacturing carry steep penalties. A drug crime lawyer can often get charges reduced or dismissed.


Driving under the influence is aggressively prosecuted in Indiana. A DUI lawyer can challenge breathalyzer results or get charges pleaded down to reckless driving.


From shoplifting to home break-ins, theft charges range from misdemeanors to felonies. A lawyer fights to get charges dropped or reduced.

Domestic Violence

Domestic violence charges can be complex given the relationships involved. An experienced lawyer is key to navigating family dynamics.

Sex Crimes

Sex crimes like assault, statutory rape and solicitation are very serious. An attorney experienced with these cases is critical.

White Collar Crime

Fraud, embezzlement and other financial crimes require lawyers versed in following the money trail.

Violent Crimes

Charges like murder, manslaughter and aggravated assault call for aggressive, seasoned criminal defense.

Traffic Violations

Speeding tickets or license suspensions seem minor but can impact your record. A lawyer helps minimize consequences.As you can see, the legal landscape is vast. Don’t go it alone – retain counsel who regularly handles your type of case.

Building Your Defense Strategy

After reviewing the charges and evidence, your Indianapolis criminal lawyer will develop a defense strategy. Common strategies include:Insufficient Evidence – Police must prove you committed the crime beyond reasonable doubt. If the evidence is flimsy, your lawyer can get charges dismissed.Unlawful Search & Seizure – If police didn’t have probable cause or a warrant, evidence may be inadmissible. A lawyer moves to suppress it.Mistaken Identity – Eyewitness misidentification is common. A lawyer shows police arrested the wrong person.Self-Defense – Using reasonable force to protect yourself is legal. A lawyer shows you acted justifiably given the threat.False Accusations – People sometimes lie to police for various reasons. Your lawyer proves no crime occurred.Mental State Defenses – Illness or diminished mental capacity can be used to mitigate intent. Psychiatric evaluation helps.Plea Bargaining – Work prosecutors for lesser charges or sentencing leniency in exchange for a guilty plea.An experienced criminal lawyer assesses the options and crafts the strongest defense. The goal is dismissal or acquittal, but they’ll pursue every possibility for the best outcome.

The Benefits of Hiring a Lawyer

Navigating the criminal justice system alone can have disastrous results. Here’s how an Indianapolis criminal defense lawyer helps:Expertise – They know how local courts, judges and prosecutors work and use that insight to your advantage.Objectivity – Emotions run high for the accused. A lawyer rationally focuses on the legal process.Resources – Seasoned lawyers have relationships with forensics experts, investigators and other specialists to build your defense.Efficiency – They know what motions and actions yield the best outcomes versus wasting time and money.Negotiation Skills – Experienced lawyers work out favorable plea bargains with prosecutors when appropriate.Trial Skills – If a trial is unavoidable, skilled litigators adeptly argue before judges and juries.Peace of Mind – The lawyer handles the complex legal matters so you can focus on your family, job and life.Freedom – Criminal convictions result in jail, fines and life-long stigma. An attorney fights for your liberty.While hiring a criminal lawyer isn’t cheap, not hiring one can be far more costly if you receive a harsh conviction or sentence. In criminal law, you get what you pay for – so invest in the best representation you can afford.

Questions to Ask When Hiring an Indianapolis Criminal Lawyer

To find the best attorney for your case, come prepared with questions at your consultation. Here are some to ask:

  • How long have you practiced criminal law? Look for at least 5-10 years experience.
  • What percentage of your caseload is dedicated to criminal defense? Specialization is key.
  • How many cases similar to mine have you handled? Find someone familiar with your charges.
  • Are you a former prosecutor? This provides insight into the other side.
  • What are the possible penalties I’m facing if convicted? You need to know the stakes.
  • What defense strategies do you recommend for my charges? Gauge their strategic thinking.
  • Will you be the lead attorney handling my case? Big firms sometimes switch out lawyers.
  • What are your fees and when is payment required? Get fee details upfront.
  • What are the next steps if I hire you? They should have a plan in place already.

The lawyer’s experience with cases like yours and grasp of strategic options are most important. Their confidence and rapport with you also come into play.


Facing criminal charges in Indianapolis can be daunting, but an experienced criminal defense lawyer can guide you through the complex legal system. They’ll aggressively defend your rights, build the strongest case possible, and negotiate for the best outcome under the circumstances. Don’t leave your fate to chance – hire a trusted advisor and advocate. With an excellent lawyer on your side, you can face the future with hope instead of fear.