FEDERAL CRIMINAL LAWYERS

When Does the Clock Start Running on PPP Fraud Charges?

Welcome to Spodek Law Group. Our goal is to help you understand exactly when your PPP exposure actually ends—because it’s probably not when you think. If you’re here calculating dates and trying to figure out when you’re finally “safe,” you need to understand something that changes everything.

Here’s what most people get wrong: they assume the 10-year statute of limitations starts from when they received their PPP loan. April 2020 loan means April 2030 exposure, right? That would be logical. That would be simple. And that would be completely wrong for most borrowers.

The clock doesn’t start from when you got the money. It starts from your LAST fraudulent act related to that loan. For most people, that wasn’t the application—it was the forgiveness application they filed in 2021 or 2022. You filed for forgiveness to END your PPP chapter. But that forgiveness application—with its certifications under penalty of perjury—became your last fraudulent act. The exit you thought would save you actually extended your exposure by one to two years.

The Forgiveness Trap: Why Your Clock Started Later Than You Think

Heres the thing most people completely misunderstand about how the statute of limitations works for PPP fraud.

When you recieved your PPP loan in 2020, you signed certifications. You made representations about your business, your employees, your payroll. If those were false, thats when your fraud began. But fraud dosent stop there. Its a continuing offense under federal law, which means every subsequent false statement restarts the clock.

Then came the forgiveness phase. Maybe six months later, maybe a year later, maybe even in 2022. You filed that forgiveness application becuase you wanted the loan converted to a grant. You wanted the chapter closed. You wanted to move on with your life. You probly thought getting forgiveness would end your legal exposure. The exact opposite is true.

That forgiveness application required new certifications. You had to certify that you used the funds apropriately. That you maintained payroll at the required levels. That you followed all the program rules. Each of those certifications was a statement under penalty of perjury—a federal crime if false.

If your original loan application was fraudulent, your forgiveness certifications were necessaraly false too. You certified you used funds properly when you hadn’t. You certified you maintained payroll when maybe you didnt have employees to begin with. You certified compliance when there was nothing legitimate to comply with.

Your forgiveness application—not your loan application—likely determines when your exposure ends. Think about the timeline. If you got your loan in April 2020 but didnt file for forgiveness until September 2021, your statute of limitations runs from September 2021. Thats September 2031—not April 2030. You just added seventeen months to your exposure without realizing it.

And heres the irony that should keep you up at night: the harder you worked to get forgiveness, the longer the government has to prosecute you. Diligent borrowers who filed forgiveness quickly after there funds ran out gave prosecutors MORE time, not less. The thing designed to close the chapter actually extended it.

The Last Act Rule: Federal Fraud Law 101

OK so understanding why this works requires knowing something about how federal fraud statutes actually operate.

Federal fraud statutes operate on whats called the “last act” rule. The statute of limitations dosent begin when you commit your first fraudulent act. It begins when you commit your last one. This exists because fraud is considered a continuing offense—each false statement, each use of fraudulent funds, each false certification restarts the clock. The system is designed so you can never outrun fraud by committing it early and then waiting.

The governments position is straightforward: your fraud wasnt complete when you submitted your application. It wasnt complete when you recieved the funds. It wasnt complete when you spent the money. Your fraud was complete when you submitted that final forgiveness application with its false certifications. Everything before that was preperation. The forgiveness application was the culmination.

The DOJ Criminal Resource Manual explicitely addresses this. For fraud schemes involving multiple acts, the statute runs from the last overt act in furtherence of the fraud. Your forgiveness application was definitely an overt act. It was in furtherence of the fraud. And for most people, it was there last one.

You cant calculate your safe date with certainty unless you know exactly when your last fraudulent act occured. Most people assume it was the loan application. But the government will argue it was the forgiveness application—and theyve got a strong argument. The certifications in that forgiveness application are seperately chargeable offenses, which gives prosecutors flexibility in determining the relevant date.

At Spodek Law Group, weve seen clients who thought they were months away from safety only to discover there exposure extends years into the future. The forgiveness trap catches almost everyone who dosent understand how the last act rule works. Its not that people are stupid—its that this rule is counterintuitive. You would naturally assume the clock starts when you first do something wrong. The law says otherwise.

Three Clocks You Might Be Running: Loan, Forgiveness, Conspiracy

Let that sink in for a moment. The situation is more complicated then most people realize. You might not be running one clock. You might be running three separate clocks simultaneously.

Clock One: The Original Loan

If you never filed for forgiveness—if you just repaid the loan in full—your clock probly started from your last use of fraudulent funds or your last false statement to the lender. That might be sometime in 2020. But almost nobody took this path. The whole point of PPP was forgiveness. Repaying a forgiveable loan is like leaving money on the table.

Clock Two: The Forgiveness Application

This is were most people are. You filed for forgiveness sometime between late 2020 and 2022. Your clock starts from that forgiveness date, not your loan date. If you filed in March 2022, your looking at March 2032 exposure. Thats still aproximately seven years away from now.

Clock Three: The Conspiracy Clock

If you conspired with anyone, their actions after your loan extend your statute of limitations. This is the one that absolutely destroys people who thought they acted alone.

You dont have to think of yourself as a conspirator for the government to treat you as one. You dont have to have made a formal agreement. If you worked with a preparer who submitted multiple fraudulent applications, you might legaly be part of a conspiracy. If a friend referred you to someone who “helped” with applications, you might be part of a conspiracy. If a lender employee pushed through questionable applications, everyone they helped might be connected in the governments eyes.

In conspiracy cases, the statute of limitations runs from the LAST overt act by ANY conspirator. Not your last act. Any conspirators last act. If someone you worked with submitted there own fraudulent forgiveness application in 2022, your exposure might extend to 2032—based on there actions, not yours.

Think about the Nieto case. He created 87 fake payroll checks for forgiveness applications. Everyone whose application he touched is potentialy connected. There clocks dont run from there individual applications. There clocks run from his last act in the conspiracy. One persons actions extended dozens of peoples exposure.

What Counts as a “Fraudulent Act”?

Heres the part that trips people up: what actually qualifies as an “act” that can restart or extend the clock? The answer is broader then you probably think.

The obvious ones are the applications themselves—your initial PPP application and your forgiveness application. Each false statement in those documents is a seperate potential charge and a seperate act for statute purposes. But those are just the begining.

Every certification you signed is an act. The certifications in your loan application. The certifications in your forgiveness application. The certifications you signed when the funds hit your account. The certifications you signed during the forgiveness review process. Each one is a representation under penalty of perjury.

And it dosent stop at documents. Using fraudulently obtained funds is itself an act. If you spent PPP money on personal expenses through December 2020, your last act might be December 2020—not April 2020 when you originaly got the loan. Every purchase, every transfer, every use of those funds is potentialy your “last act.” The government has records of where the money went, and they can trace each expendature.

Todd Spodek has seen prosecutors argue creative interpretations of what constitutes the last act. Some have argued that continuing to benefit from the fraud—keeping the forgiveness, not disclosing the problems, not making restitution—constitutes ongoing criminal conduct. Courts have been mixed on this particular argument, but the arguments definately being made in federal courtrooms across the country.

The uncomfortable reality is that you probly dont know when your last act was. You know when you submitted applications. You might remember aproximately when you finished spending funds. But do you remember every certification you signed? Every document that went to the lender? Every statement you made during the forgiveness process? The government has all of this documented in there files. You probly dont have your own records anymore.

The Conspiracy Multiplier: When Other People’s Actions Extend Your Clock

Heres were peoples exposure really explodes: the conspiracy problem deserves detailed attention becuase of how dramatically it can extend your timeline.

The federal conspiracy statute—18 U.S.C. § 371—has its own rules about when the clock starts. Those rules are extremely harsh for defendants who didnt act alone.

In a conspiracy, the statute of limitations runs from the LAST overt act by ANY member of the conspiracy. Not the last act in furtherance of YOUR fraud specificaly. The last act in furtherance of the COLLECTIVE fraud. If your part of a conspiracy that continued operating after you got your money, your clock kept running without your knowledge or consent.

Consider a common scenario. You applied for your PPP loan in May 2020 through a preparer who was running a scheme. You got your money. You filed for forgiveness in 2021. You thought you were completly done with the whole thing.

But that preparer kept operating. They submitted more applications in 2021. They helped more people file fraudulent forgiveness applications in 2022. Every one of those acts extended the conspiracys exposure—and YOUR exposure as a member of that conspiracy. You werent even involved anymore, but your clock kept running.

You dont control when your clock expires if you conspired with others. Someone elses actions in 2022 extend your exposure to 2032. And you might not even know those actions occured until prosecutors show up with indictments.

The Kabbage settlement ilustrates this perfectly. The company paid $120 million to resolve claims that it falsely certified PPP loans for forgiveness. Everyone who got a fraudulently processed loan through Kabbage is potentialy connected to that conspiracy. The fraudulent activity continued long after individual borrowers thought there involvement had ended.

The question you should be asking yourself is sobering: do you know for certain that nobody you worked with committed any acts related to PPP fraud after your involvement ended? If you cant answer that with complete confidence, you cant calculate your exposure with confidence either. The uncertainty itself is a form of risk.

Calculating Your Real Exposure Date

OK so how do you actually figure out when your exposure ends? The honest answer is that you probably cant—not with complete certainty. But the analysis is still worthwhile becuase it helps you understand the range of possibilities.

Step One: Identify Your Last Personal Act

When did you personaly last do something that could be characterized as part of the fraud? This might include:

• Your forgiveness application date
• Your last use of fraudulent funds
• Your last certification or representation to the lender
• Your last statement to anyone about the loan

Take the latest of these dates. Thats your personal clock start date. Most people underestimate this becuase they forget about certifications and statements made during the forgiveness process.

Step Two: Add 10 Years

If your last act was March 2022, your exposure runs until March 2032. If it was September 2021, your looking at September 2031. The math is simple, but the starting point matters enormosly. Getting it wrong by even a few months can mean the diffrence between thinking your safe and realizing your still exposed.

Step Three: Consider Conspiracy Exposure

Did you work with anyone at all? A preparer? A lender employee? A friend who referred you? Anyone who might have been involved in multiple applications or who continued operating after your involvement ended?

If yes, you need to consider wheather you might legaly be part of a conspiracy. And if you are, your clock runs from there last act—which you might not even know about. This is the variable that makes calculation virtualy impossible for many people.

Step Four: Accept the Uncertainty

Each false certification in your forgiveness application is a separate potential federal charge. And the government gets to argue when the last act occured. They might identify something you completly forgot about. They might connect you to a conspiracy you didnt know existed. They might find documents you dont remember signing becuase you signed so many during the frantic PPP application process.

At Spodek Law Group, we tell clients the uncomfortable truth: unless your situation is extremly simple—one loan, no forgiveness application, no preparers, no connections to anyone else—you probly cant calculate your safe date with confidence. The system is designed this way deliberatly. You can never outrun fraud by committing it early and waiting. The last act rule ensures that escape route is blocked.

The 2032 Problem: Second-Draw Loans and Late Forgiveness

Think about the people with maximum exposure becuase you might be one of them without realizing it.

The PPP program had two rounds. First-draw loans started in April 2020. Second-draw loans became available in early 2021. Many businesses got both loans becuase the program allowed it and the money was essentialy free if you qualified.

If you got a second-draw loan in March 2021 and filed for forgiveness in March 2022, your exposure on THAT loan runs until March 2032. Thats not a hypothetical situation. Thats basic math that applies to millions of borrowers.

But the situation is even more complicated then that. You might have two seperate clocks running simultaniously. Your first-draw loan might have exposure through 2031. Your second-draw loan might have exposure through 2032. And if there connected—if the second-draw application referenced the first, if the same preparer handled both, if the same false representations appear in both—the government will likely argue its all one scheme.

One scheme means one clock. And that clock starts from the latest act in the scheme. Your 2022 forgiveness application for the second-draw loan becomes the starting point for EVERYTHING—including the first-draw loan fraud.

Consider what that actualy looks like in practice:

• First-draw loan: April 2020
• First-draw forgiveness: December 2020
• Second-draw loan: February 2021
• Second-draw forgiveness: March 2022

If these are treated as one continuing scheme, your exposure runs from March 2022 to March 2032. Not from April 2020 to April 2030. You effectivly added two full years to your exposure by getting that second loan and filing for forgiveness on it. The second loan didnt just create new exposure—it extended your exposure on the first loan too.

And this situation is extremly common. Anyone who got both loans and filed for forgiveness on both has this problem. Anyone who filed forgiveness late—in 2022—has this problem. Anyone who worked with preparers who were still operating in 2022 has this problem. Thats not a small group of people. Thats potentialy millions of borrowers who thought there exposure ended years earlier then it actualy does.

The question you should be asking yourself isnt “will they eventualy get to me?” Its “what position will I be in when they do?” The governments backlog is being processed steadily. There automated systems flagged loans years ago. There now working through that queue methodicaly and permanantly. And the 10-year window gives them plenty of time to reach everyone, regardless of how long it takes.

Recent enforcement actions show this timeline in action. The DOJ has charged over 3,500 defendants in PPP fraud cases so far, with sentences ranging from probation to decades in federal prison. The cases being prosecuted now involve applications from 2020 and 2021—prosecutors are working through the backlog exactly as you would expect. Your loan is somewhere in that queue, and the 10-year window ensures it wont age out before they reach it.

Todd Spodek and the team at Spodek Law Group have guided clients through exactly this analysis. Understanding your actual exposure date—not the date you assumed—is the first step toward making informed decisions about your situation. The diffrence between thinking your safe in 2030 and realizing your exposed until 2032 is the diffrence between false comfort and accurate planning.

If your PPP loan involved any complexity—multiple loans, forgiveness applications, preparers, connections to others—call us at 212-300-5196. The clock you thought you were watching might not be the clock thats actualy running. And knowing the truth, even when its uncomfortable, is definately better then discovering it when the FBI shows up at your door with a warrant and a list of questions.