Free Consultations & We're Available 24/7
WE'RE A BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM.
TRUST 50 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
WE SERVICE CLIENTS NATIONWIDE.
Welcome to Spodek Law Group. Our goal is to give you information that might actually save your future – not the sanitized version you’ll find on other law firm websites. When the FBI contacts you, everything changes. And most people make catastrophic mistakes in the first 48 hours because they believe things about this process that simply aren’t true.
Here is the thing nobody tells you upfront. Innocent people are often the FBI’s easiest targets. Not because they are guilty of anything – but because they walk into interviews believing that honesty will protect them. They think if they just explain themselves clearly, the agents will understand and leave them alone. That is exactly what the FBI is counting on.
The most dangerous person to walk into an FBI interview isnt the career criminal with a lawyer on speed dial. Its the accountant whos never been in trouble. The business owner who thinks she has nothing to hide. The executive who wants to “clear things up” and get back to there normal life.
These people share something in common. They beleive the system works the way it should. They think FBI agents are trying to find the truth. They assume that being honest and cooperative will demonstrate there innocence and make everything go away. This is the fundamental misunderstanding that destroys lives.
This belief is not just wrong – its the exact psychological vulnerability that federal prosecutors exploit every single day. Your innocence dosent protect you. Your cooperation dosent protect you. Your honesty basicly creates the evidence that will be used against you in ways you cant even imagine right now.
Heres how the trap works in practice. Under 18 USC 1001, making any false statement to a federal agent is a crime punishable by up to five years in federal prison. You dont have to be under oath. You dont have to sign anything. You dont even have to know your being investigated for something. If you say something that turns out to be inaccurate – even if you genuinly beleived it was true when you said it – youve committed a federal crime.
And heres the part that should actualy terrify you if your thinking about talking to agents. The FBI agents interviewing you can legaly lie. They can tell you they have evidence they dont have. They can claim witnesses said things they never actualy said. They can misrepresent the entire nature of there investigation to get you comfortable. But if you respond to those lies with anything less than perfect accuracy, your the one facing prison time.
Let that sink in for a moment. They can decieve you completly. You cannot make a single mistake.
Most people think an FBI interview is about gathering information. They think the agents are trying to determine what happened so they can understand the situation. This is a fundamental misunderstanding of what’s actualy occuring in that room.
The interview is the crime scene being created in real time.
Think about that for a second. You walk in with one legal exposure – whatever there investigating you for. You walk out with two. Because now they have your statements on record. And those statements become the foundation for 18 USC 1001 charges that are often easier to prove then the underlying crime they were investigating in the first place. Prosecutors love this becuase its clean and simple.
This isnt speculation or paranoia. This is documented prosecutorial strategy that defense attorneys see play out constantly.
OK so how does this work practicaly in the real world? Lets say your being investigated for something that happened three years ago. You honestly dont remember the exact date of a meeting becuase it was years ago. You take your best guess and say it was March 15th. Later, the FBI finds an email showing it was actualy March 22nd.
You didnt lie. You made an honest mistake about something that happened years ago. Your memory isnt perfect – nobodys is. Dosent matter to prosecutors. Thats a false statement to a federal officer. Five years maximum sentence. And prosecutors will argue that your “inability to remember correctly” demonstrates consciousness of guilt about the underlying offense there investigating.
The innocent explanation you gave to help yourself just became evidence of a federal crime. Your trying to be helpfull literaly created new criminal exposure.
This is the asymmetry that destroys lives, and most people dont discover it until there already in handcuffs facing charges they never saw coming.
FBI agents interviewing you can legaly do all of the following:
Meanwhile, you cannot do any of the following without risking prosecution:
Read that list again. They can lie to you strategicaly. If you say anything that isnt perfectly accurate, your committing a federal crime. This isnt a level playing field designed to find truth. Its a trap specificaly designed to create criminal exposure during the interview itself.
And heres something else nobody tells you until its to late. These interviews are not recorded in most federal cases.
FBI agents dont record there interviews in most cases. Instead, they take notes. Sometimes during the interview. Sometimes after. Then they write up whats called an FD-302 – the official FBI report of what you supposably said during the conversation.
Heres were it gets really problematic for everyone who talks to agents.
According to FBI policy, the FD-302 should be completed within seven days of the interview. In practice, this deadline is routinly exceeded by days or even weeks. In Michael Flynn’s case – the former National Security Advisor – the FD-302 wasnt finalized until three weeks after the interview happened. And it went through multiple edits and revisions before reaching its final form.
Todd Spodek has seen cases where the FD-302 describes statements that the interviewee absolutly swears they never made. But theres no recording to prove otherwise. The agent’s written summary becomes the “official record” of what happened – and its basicly the agents word against yours in court.
Think about the last important conversation you had three weeks ago. Can you remember exactly what you said? Every single word? Every nuance and inflection? Now imagine someone else is writing that conversation down from there memory, with there own interpretation of what you meant, and there version becomes evidence at your trial.
Thats the FD-302 system that determins your fate.
The interviewee never sees the FD-302 before its finalized. They dont get to review it for accuracy. They dont get to correct misunderstandings or clarify what they actualy meant. The first time most people see there own “statements” is when there being used against them in court proceedings.
This system is designed to give federal agents complete narrative control over what was said in the interview. And if your words today and there FD-302 dont match, prosecutors will argue that proves your lying now – not that the FD-302 was wrong or incomplete back then.
Lets talk about Martha Stewart. Not because her case is unusual – but because it proves exactly what were discussing here in the starkest possible terms.
Martha Stewart was investigated for insider trading related to her sale of ImClone stock. The FBI came to interview her about it. She agreed to talk without a lawyer present because she beleived she had done nothing wrong and wanted to clear things up quickly. She was confident in her innocence.
She was never charged with insider trading.
Read that sentence again slowly. The underlying crime they were investigating? They never proved it happened. They never even charged her with it formally.
But during her interview with federal agents, she made statements about why she sold the stock and when she decided to sell it. Some of those statements were later deemed inaccurate based on other evidence investigators found. And thats what she went to prison for. Not the insider trading they were investigating. The statements she made trying to explain herself during a “voluntary” interview.
Martha Stewart served five months in federal prison and five months of home confinement after that. Her crime wasnt insider trading. Her crime was talking to the FBI without a lawyer and saying things that prosecutors later characterized as false statements to federal officers.
Heres the lesson most people completly miss when they hear about this case. Even if your completly innocent of whatever there investigating, you can still go to prison for what you say during the interview. Your attempt to prove your innocence can actualy become the crime itself. Your own words become the evidence against you.
So what do you actualy do when FBI agents show up at your door unexpectedly or call your phone wanting to talk?
First, understand this clearly: you are not required to talk to them. The Fifth Amendment protects your right to remain silent. Exercising that right cannot be used against you in court. This is a constitutional protection that exists specificly because the founders understood the danger of government interrogation without safeguards.
Heres exactly what to say when agents contact you:
“I decline to answer any questions without my attorney present.”
Thats it. Thats the complete statement. You dont need to explain your reasoning. You dont need to apologize for inconveniencing them. You dont need to schedule a future conversation to show cooperation. You definately dont need to give them “just a few minutes” or answer “a couple quick questions” to prove your cooperative.
If they push back – and they will push back becuase thats there job – repeat the same statement calmly. “I decline to answer any questions without my attorney present.”
If they say your making yourself look guilty by not talking, dont argue with them. Your response is exactley the same. “I decline to answer any questions without my attorney present.”
If they say they just want to clear things up and it will only take five minutes, your answer is unchanged. “I decline to answer any questions without my attorney present.”
Heres why this matters so much. Nothing you say in this moment can help you legaly. Literaly nothing you could say will make things better. If there going to charge you, your statements wont change that decision. If there not going to charge you, you dont need to give them statements anyway. The only possible outcome of talking is creating additional criminal exposure that didnt exist before you opened your mouth.
At Spodek Law Group, weve seen clients who thought a “quick conversation” would resolve everything and make it go away. It never works that way. What it does is give prosecutors ammunition they didnt have before you talked.
Some people worry that refusing to talk will make them look guilty or escalate the investigation against them. This is understandable and very common – but its not how federal investigations actualy work in practice.
FBI agents conduct thousands of interviews every year. Some people talk freely. Some people assert there rights. The ones who exercise there constitutional rights dont get treated worse because of it. The investigation proceeds based on evidence – and your silence isnt evidence of anything they can use.
What actualy happens when you assert your rights properly:
The agents will probly leave a business card with contact information. They might say something designed to make you reconsider talking to them. They may contact you again later through different channels. They may reach out to family members or coworkers to gather information – thats legal and common practice.
But they wont have your statements to use against you in court. They wont have an FD-302 full of your words that might be slightly different from what actualy happened years ago. They wont have the 18 USC 1001 backup charge that they so often use when the underlying case is weak or hard to prove.
Heres what you should do immediatly after declining to answer there questions:
Contact a federal criminal defense attorney that day. Not tomorrow. Not after youve “thought about it” for a while. Not next week when things calm down. Immediately. The hours after FBI contact are criticaly important for understanding the scope of the investigation and developing a legal strategy.
At Spodek Law Group, the conversation you have with us IS privileged and protected by law. Unlike your conversation with FBI agents, nothing you tell your lawyer can be used against you. Thats the only safe place to tell your full story without creating legal exposure.
Maybe your reading this article to late. Maybe you already sat down with agents and answered there questions honestly. Maybe you thought you were helping yourself and now your worried about what you said and how they might use it.
Do not contact the FBI to “correct” or “clarify” anything you said previously.
This is the instinct that creates additional exposure almost every time. People realize they misstated something or remembered a detail wrong and want to fix it. But reaching back out to agents just creates more documented statements that can be analyzed for inconsistencies with your previous statements.
Contact a federal criminal defense attorney immediatly instead. At Spodek Law Group, weve intervened in cases where clients spoke to agents without counsel and helped minimize the damage. Its not the ideal situation – but its definately not hopeless either.
The attorney can potentialy do the following on your behalf:
The worst thing you can do is sit there worrying while doing absolutly nothing about the situation. Federal investigations move forward wheather your paying attention to them or not. Getting counsel involved as soon as possible gives you the best chance of navigating whatever comes next in the process.
The FBI knocking on your door or calling your phone unexpectedly is one of the most stressful moments in anyones life. Everything feels urgent and overwhelming. You want the situation resolved as quickly as possible. You want to explain yourself and make the whole thing go away.
But the system isnt designed for that outcome. The system is designed to use your natural instincts against you. Your desire to cooperate, your beleif in your own innocence, your assumption that honesty is always the best policy – these are the exact vulnerabilities that create federal criminal exposure where none existed before.
Call Spodek Law Group at 212-300-5196 today. The conversation you have with us is the only one thats actualy protected by law. Dont let your next conversation be with someone whos job is to build a case against you using your own words.
Sources:
Very diligent, organized associates; got my case dismissed. Hard working attorneys who can put up with your anxiousness. I was accused of robbing a gemstone dealer. Definitely A law group that lays out all possible options and best alternative routes. Recommended for sure.
- ROBIN, GUN CHARGES ROBIN
NJ CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS