Do You Have to Attend Hearings in Person in New York?

By max@dotcomlawyermarketing.com
July 7, 2024
7 min read
48+ Years of Combined Experience
Featured in Netflix's Inventing Anna
Available 24/7 for Emergency Cases
Todd Spodek - Managing Partner

Schedule Your Free Consultation with Todd Spodek

Immediate Response Available • Attorney-Client Privilege • No Financial Obligation

100% Confidential • No Obligation

Time-Sensitive Legal Matters: Early intervention can significantly impact your case outcome. Schedule your consultation today.

Netflix Featured
10.0 Avvo Rating
700+ 5-Star Reviews
Super Lawyers
federal defense

Do You Have to Attend Hearings in Person in New York?

CONGRATULATIONS! You've found yourself involved in a legal matter in New York. Whether you're excited or anxious about your upcoming hearing, you're probably wondering - do you actually have to show up in person? Well, buckle up buttercup, because we're about to take you on a wild ride through the world of New York court appearances.At Spodek Law Group, we've seen it all when it comes to court hearings. From traffic tickets to federal investigations, we know the ins and outs of New York's legal system. So let's dive in and explore whether you'll need to dust off that suit or if you can attend your hearing in your pajamas from the comfort of your couch.

The General Rule: In-Person Attendance

Traditionally, New York courts have required in-person attendance for most hearings. There's just something about seeing the whites of someone's eyes that judges seem to love. But let's break it down a bit further:

Criminal Cases

If you're facing criminal charges, you'll likely need to show up in person for most hearings. This includes:
  • Arraignments
  • Bail hearings
  • Pre-trial conferences
  • Trial proceedings
The court wants to make sure you understand the charges against you and that your rights are protected. Plus, let's be honest, they want to make sure you haven't skipped town.

Civil Cases

For civil matters, the rules can be a bit more flexible. Some hearings may allow for remote attendance, especially for:
  • Status conferences
  • Motion hearings
  • Settlement discussions
But don't get too comfy in those sweatpants just yet. If your case goes to trial, you'll probably need to grace the courtroom with your physical presence.

The COVID-19 Game Changer

Now, here's where things get interesting. The COVID-19 pandemic threw a wrench in the traditional court system. Suddenly, judges realized that maybe, just maybe, we could conduct some business without everyone breathing the same air.During the height of the pandemic, New York courts embraced virtual hearings like a long-lost friend. Many proceedings moved online, including:
  • Arraignments
  • Bail applications
  • Plea hearings
  • Some evidentiary hearings
This shift showed us that remote appearances CAN work in many situations. But will this trend continue? Well, that's the million-dollar question.

The Current Landscape: A Mixed Bag

As we emerge from the pandemic haze, New York courts are taking a hybrid approach. Some hearings are back to in-person, while others remain virtual. It's like a legal version of Russian roulette - you never know what you're gonna get!Here's a quick breakdown of what you might expect:
Hearing Type Likely Format
Criminal Arraignments In-person
Traffic Violations Virtual option available
Family Court Proceedings Mix of in-person and virtual
Civil Motion Hearings Often virtual
Criminal Trials In-person
But here's the kicker - it often depends on the specific court and judge handling your case. Some judges are embracing the digital age with open arms, while others are clinging to their robes and insisting on face-to-face interactions.

Factors That Influence Attendance Requirements

So how do you know if you'll need to show up in person? Several factors come into play:
  1. Nature of the Case: Criminal matters are more likely to require in-person attendance than civil cases.
  2. Stage of Proceedings: Initial appearances and trials usually require physical presence, while status conferences might allow for remote options.
  3. Court's Technological Capabilities: Some courts are better equipped for virtual hearings than others.
  4. Judge's Preference: Each judge has their own style and preferences when it comes to running their courtroom.
  5. Parties' Requests: In some cases, you or your attorney can request a specific format for the hearing.

The Benefits of Remote Hearings

Now, you might be thinking, "Why would I want to attend remotely? I look GREAT in a suit!" Well, hold onto your hat, because remote hearings can offer some serious perks:
  • Convenience: No need to battle New York traffic or find parking near the courthouse.
  • Cost Savings: Save on travel expenses and potentially reduce attorney fees.
  • Flexibility: Attend hearings from anywhere with a stable internet connection.
  • Reduced Stress: For some, appearing virtually can be less intimidating than facing a courtroom.
But remember, with great power comes great responsibility. If you're attending remotely, you'll need to ensure you have a reliable internet connection and a quiet, professional-looking space for your appearance.

When In-Person Attendance is a Must

Despite the rise of virtual options, there are still times when you'll need to grace the courtroom with your physical presence:
  1. Criminal Trials: The Constitution guarantees your right to face your accusers, so you'll need to be there in person.
  2. Witness Testimony: If you're testifying, the court will likely want to see you in the flesh to assess your credibility.
  3. Evidence Presentation: Some complex cases require in-person examination of physical evidence.
  4. High-Stakes Hearings: For major decisions like sentencing, judges often prefer to see defendants in person.
  5. When the Judge Says So: Ultimately, if the judge orders you to appear in person, you'd better show up with bells on.

How to Know What's Required for Your Case

Feeling a bit lost in the legal labyrinth? Don't worry, we've got your back. Here's how to figure out if you need to show up in person:
  1. Check Your Court Notice: Your hearing notice should specify whether it's in-person or virtual.
  2. Ask Your Attorney: If you have one, they should be able to guide you on attendance requirements.
  3. Contact the Court Clerk: They can provide information on the court's current procedures.
  4. Review Local Court Rules: Many courts post their policies online.
  5. When in Doubt, Plan to Attend in Person: It's always better to be safe than sorry!

The Spodek Law Group Advantage

Now, we know what you're thinking - "This all sounds complicated! How can I possibly navigate this on my own?" Well, that's where we come in. At Spodek Law Group, we're not just lawyers - we're your legal GPS, guiding you through the twists and turns of the New York court system.Our team of experienced attorneys stays up-to-date on the latest court procedures and attendance requirements. We'll make sure you know exactly where you need to be (or log in) for every hearing. Plus, we'll advocate for the format that best serves your interests, whether that's in-person or virtual.With Spodek Law Group by your side, you'll never have to wonder, "Do I really have to go to court today?" We've got you covered, from traffic tickets to federal investigations and everything in between.

The Bottom Line

So, do you have to attend hearings in person in New York? The answer is... it depends. (Come on, you didn't really expect a straight answer from a lawyer, did you?)The landscape of court appearances is evolving, with a mix of in-person and virtual options available. While some hearings still require physical presence, others offer the flexibility of remote attendance. The key is to stay informed about your specific case requirements and be prepared for either scenario.Remember, whether you're appearing in person or virtually, the most important thing is to present your case effectively. And that's where having a skilled attorney in your corner can make all the difference.Ready to tackle your legal challenges head-on? Give us a call at 212-300-5196 or visit our website at https://www.federallawyers.com. Let Spodek Law Group be your guide through the maze of New York court appearances. We promise we won't make you wear a tie if it's a virtual hearing!

Share This Article:

Todd Spodek

About the Author

Todd Spodek, Managing Partner

Todd Spodek is the Managing Partner of Spodek Law Group, a premier NYC law firm specializing in divorce, family law, and criminal defense. Featured in Netflix's "Inventing Anna," Todd brings over 48 years of combined legal experience to every case. Known for his strategic approach and dedication to clients, he has successfully handled thousands of complex legal matters throughout New York.

48+ Years Experience
Netflix Featured
10.0 Avvo Rating

Don't Navigate Your Legal Challenges Alone

Our experienced attorneys are here to guide you through every step of your case

Available 24/7 • Free Case Evaluation • No Obligation

FEATURED IN MAJOR MEDIA

Todd Spodek • Legal Expert • Media Commentator

New York Post
Newsweek
CNN
The Cut
The Spectator
Business Insider
TIME
Netflix

SPODEK LAW GROUP

TREATING YOU LIKE FAMILY SINCE 1976

HOW CAN WE HELP YOU?

24/7 Free Consultation • No Obligation Case Review

*
*
*
*
*

* required fields