Blog
What is a Wells Notice? A Helpful Guide for the Layperson
Contents
What is a Wells Notice? A Helpful Guide for the Layperson
A Wells Notice can be an intimidating thing to receive. This straightforward guide aims to explain Wells Notices in simple terms, so you can understand what it means if you get one.
What is a Wells Notice?
A Wells Notice is a letter sent to you by a regulator like the SEC (Securities and Exchange Commission) or FINRA (Financial Industry Regulatory Authority). It says that the regulator has finished investigating you and thinks you may have broken some laws or regulations.The Wells Notice gives you a chance to explain your side before the regulator decides to take action against you. It doesn’t mean you’re guilty, just that the regulator is thinking about charging you with something based on what they found in the investigation.
Where Does the Name Come From?
Back in 1972, the SEC made a committee led by a guy named John Wells. This “Wells Committee” had to look at how the SEC did investigations and enforcement actions.One thing the committee suggested was giving people a heads up when the investigation found something before any charges got filed. That way, the person could give their side of the story first.The SEC liked the idea, so they started sending these Wells Notices at the end of investigations. The name stuck, even though the policy has changed a bit over the years.
What to Expect in a Wells Notice
The Wells Notice will list the specific laws or regulations the regulator thinks you broke based on the investigation. It will also tell you when you need to respond by if you want to tell your side of things.There’s usually a lot of routine language too, like telling you that you can respond in writing or make a video statement. The notice also warns that anything you say can be used against you later.Don’t let the boilerplate stuff scare you. The key parts are the alleged violations and the deadline to respond. Focus on those.
Do I Have to Respond?
You don’t have to respond to a Wells Notice. The regulator will decide whether or not to bring charges even if you don’t say anything.But most experts say you should respond, even though it’s not required. It’s your big chance to tell your side and maybe even get the regulator to back off. Even if charges do come, you might get a better settlement if you respond.Just don’t admit to anything you’re not 100% sure you did. Anything you say in your response can come back to haunt you later.
How Should I Respond?
You’ll want an experienced securities lawyer to help write your response. But in general, you’ll want to:
- Explain why you don’t think you broke the law, with evidence backing you up
- Point out any mistakes or gaps in the regulator’s case
- Show why it would be unfair or excessive to charge you
Stick to the facts and legal arguments. Getting angry or confrontational won’t help. Be persuasive but professional.You can also try negotiating with the regulator at this point to resolve things without charges. But be careful about admitting guilt too soon.
What Happens After I Respond?
The SEC staff will take your Wells Response and their evidence to the Commissioners, who ultimately decide on enforcement actions. They’ll consider both sides before voting on charges.If the Commissioners do authorize charges, settlement talks may begin to avoid litigation. But sometimes cases do end up in court if no deal is reached.In other cases, the Wells Response is persuasive and the SEC drops the matter without charges. But don’t get your hopes up too much. Wells Responses rarely get cases thrown out completely.
Key Takeaways
- A Wells Notice means a regulator is thinking about filing charges after an investigation. It’s not definitive.
- The notice gives you a chance to tell your side of the story before any action is taken.
- Responding is optional but usually advised. An experienced securities lawyer can help craft your response.
- Be persuasive but professional. Stick to facts and legal arguments. Don’t admit anything you’re unsure about.
- After your response, SEC Commissioners decide whether or not to authorize charges. Settlement talks often follow.
What Else Should I Know?
Here are some other quick facts about Wells Notices:
- The name comes from a 1970s SEC committee led by John Wells.
- Notices come from the SEC, FINRA, CFTC, and other financial regulators.
- There’s no set deadline to respond, but usually 1-3 weeks. Extensions are common.
- The notice comes after the investigation ends but before any charges are filed.
- Most say you can respond in writing or via video statement. Written responses are standard.
- Wells submissions are not confidential. The SEC can use them in any later case against you.
- Responding may help you get a better settlement if charges do come. But it’s no guarantee.
- Very few cases get dropped completely due to Wells Responses. But it happens occasionally.
- If you don’t respond, the SEC will just make their decision without hearing your side.
Conclusion
Wells Notices mark the end of an investigation and start of the enforcement process. Don’t panic if you get one, but take it seriously. Responding gives you a chance to tell your side of the story and potentially affect the outcome. A good lawyer is essential.The process can be nerve-wracking, but knowing what to expect will help you navigate it smoothly. With the right legal guidance, even a Wells Notice doesn’t have to mean the end. There are still options to defend yourself and aim for the most favorable resolution possible.