Criminal Defense Lawyers

what do no contest mean

Understanding “No Contest” Pleas

Entering a “no contest” plea, also known as a “nolo contendere” plea, can be a strategic legal move in certain criminal cases. But what exactly does “no contest” mean and when might it make sense to use this type of plea?

Overview of No Contest Pleas

A “no contest” plea is legally similar to pleading guilty in a criminal case, but it cannot be used as evidence of guilt in future civil cases stemming from the same incident. Essentially, the defendant neither admits nor disputes the charges when pleading no contest.Some key things to understand about no contest pleas:

• The defendant accepts punishment without admitting guilt
• Judges usually treat no contest pleas the same as guilty pleas for sentencing
• No contest pleas cannot be used against the defendant in related civil cases
• Defendants give up rights to trial when pleading no contest

Defense attorneys sometimes recommend no contest pleas as a strategic move to avoid directly admitting guilt. This can help limit legal liability in associated civil cases.

When Are No Contest Pleas Used?

There are a few situations where entering a no contest plea makes the most strategic sense for defendants:

• Avoiding civil liability – As mentioned, no contest pleas cannot be used to establish liability in related civil cases. So it allows the defendant to resolve the criminal case without increasing vulnerability to civil damages.
• Obscure details – If the details of what happened are unclear, a no contest plea may be preferable to pleading guilty. The defendant can accept the conviction and punishment without affirming the prosecutor’s version of events.
• Negotiated pleas – Prosecutors may offer a lighter sentence or dropped charges in exchange for a no contest plea rather than forcing the defendant to plead guilty. This allows both sides to resolve the case.

So while legally similar to pleading guilty, no contest pleas can provide strategic advantages in certain cases. Experienced criminal defense lawyers like those at Arizona Defense Firm can advise if it makes sense to use this option.

How No Contest Pleas Work

The actual process for entering a no contest plea is essentially the same as pleading guilty:

1. The defendant enters the no contest plea at an arraignment hearing.
2. The judge asks questions to confirm the defendant understands their rights and the implications of the plea. This establishes that the plea is entered knowingly and voluntarily.
3. The judge accepts the plea after covering all required advisement topics.
4. Sentencing typically takes place at a later date, just like with guilty pleas. This allows time for things like victim impact statements and preparation of sentencing memorandums.

One key difference is that the judge will not ask the defendant to admit guilt during the plea colloquy questions. The no contest plea speaks for itself in replacing an admission of guilt.

Strategic Benefits of No Contest Pleas

Let’s explore some of the potential strategic benefits of no contest pleas compared to pleading guilty:

• Avoids detailed admission – Defendants do not have to provide the factual basis underlying the charges, avoiding a detailed admission that could be used in civil cases later.
• Limits civil liability – Without an admission of guilt, there is no estoppel effect that prevents the defendant from contesting the facts in related civil lawsuits. This maintains stronger legal ground in the civil context.
• Preserves appeal rights – In some cases, no contest pleas still allow appeal rights, unlike guilty pleas. This provides another avenue for challenging the conviction if needed.
• Potential better sentencing – Some judges may look upon no contest pleas more favorably than guilty pleas in terms of sentencing.
• Sounds better – The lack of clear admission can help defendants save face in terms of public reputation damage.

Experienced criminal defense attorneys can advise if pleading no contest makes sense compared to the alternatives like pleading not guilty or guilty.

When Would a No Contest Plea Not Make Sense?

While no contest pleas have some useful strategic benefits, they do not make sense in every case. A few examples of when pleading no contest may not be wise:

• Serious charges – Judges tend to disfavor no contest pleas for very serious crimes like murder, rape, kidnapping due to the lack of clear admission.
• Strong prosecution evidence – If prosecutors have rock solid evidence proving guilt, pleading no contest provides little benefit compared to guilty.
• Codefendants – In multi-defendant cases, no contest pleas can seem suspicious if other defendants plead guilty. Judges may wonder if the defendant pleading no contest is withholding facts.
• Immigration cases – No contest pleas generally count as convictions for immigration purposes. So in deportation cases, there is often no strategic value.
• Weapons charges – No contest pleas can still trigger enhanced sentences for future weapons charges in some jurisdictions, just like guilty pleas.

Because of factors like these, experienced criminal lawyers can best advise if a no contest plea is the right move compared to alternatives.

Questions to Ask About No Contest Pleas

When considering entering a no contest plea, some key questions to think through include:

• How would a no contest plea affect my sentencing guidelines range compared to pleading guilty?
• Does pleading no contest help limit civil lawsuit exposure related to this criminal case?
• Would a no contest plea impact my immigration status or future eligibility for benefits?
• Would I still retain any appeal rights after pleading no contest?
• Could pleading no contest undermine my credibility if I were to testify in co-defendant cases?

Going through these issues with a top criminal defense lawyer can shed light on whether pleading no contest makes sense in your particular situation.

Getting Legal Help With No Contest Pleas

If you are facing criminal charges and want to better understand no contest pleas, the experienced defense attorneys at Smith & White can advise you. We have successfully represented thousands of clients facing charges ranging from misdemeanors to serious violent felonies.Our award-winning criminal lawyers will thoroughly analyze the prosecution’s evidence against you, identify any constitutional rights violations or other weaknesses in their case, and then advise you regarding the smartest plea to enter. We will clarify whether pleading no contest makes strategic sense compared to alternatives like guilty or not guilty pleas given the unique circumstances.To set up a free case evaluation with our criminal defense team, call us today at 555-555-5555. Don’t leave your rights and future in the hands of an overworked public defender. The top criminal lawyers at Smith & White have the resources and expertise to provide the vigorous representation you deserve. Let us fight to achieve the best possible outcome in your case through negotiation or trial. The call and consultation are 100% free and confidential.

References

https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladviceofftopic/comments/9vm9w9/what_exactly_is_a_nolo_contendere_plea/
https://www.avvo.com/legal-guides/ugc/what-does-it-mean-to-enter-a-plea-of-no-contest https://www.lawinfo.com/resources/criminal-defense/plea-bargains/when-is-a-nolo-contendere-plea-used.html
https://www.findlaw.com/criminal/criminal-procedure/how-does-a-no-contest-plea-work.html https://www.avvo.com/legal-guides/ugc/should-i-plead-guilty-or-no-contest https://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/resources/criminal-defense/defendants-plea-bargaining/when-a-no-contest-plea-is-not-best