Blog
Understanding the Difference Between White Collar and Blue Collar Criminal Attorneys in NYC
Contents
Understanding the Difference Between White Collar and Blue Collar Criminal Attorneys in NYC
When you’re facing criminal charges in New York City, one of the most important decisions you’ll make is choosing the right attorney. Should you hire a white collar or blue collar criminal defense lawyer? Although they’re both criminal attorneys, there are some key differences between the two.
What is a White Collar Crime?
White collar crimes are non-violent crimes committed by businesses or high-status individuals, usually for financial gain. Some examples include:
- Securities fraud
- Embezzlement
- Money laundering
- Tax evasion
- Identity theft
- Insider trading
White collar crimes typically involve complex financial transactions and sophisticated schemes. The perpetrators are often wealthy, educated professionals with resources to conceal their activities. While violent crime rates have dropped over the past decades, white collar crime has increased with the digital age.
What is a Blue Collar Crime?
Blue collar crimes are committed by everyday people, rather than white collar professionals. They include:
- Assault
- Theft
- Vandalism
- Drug crimes
- DUI
Blue collar crimes are often crimes of desperation rather than greed. The perpetrators usually don’t have specialized knowledge to carry out complex schemes. While both types of crime are illegal, blue collar crimes are generally viewed as more “street crimes.”
How Do the Lawyers Differ?
Given the differences between white collar and blue collar crimes, the defense attorneys have different backgrounds, skills, and approaches.
Education and Experience
White collar attorneys typically have degrees from top law schools and work at large, prestigious firms. They focus exclusively on defending white collar crime and have experience with complex financial cases. Blue collar defense attorneys are more likely to come from local law schools and smaller firms. They defend a wide variety of street crime cases.
Investigation Process
White collar cases require meticulously tracing paper and digital trails. Attorneys pore over thousands of documents, emails, bank records, etc. Blue collar cases focus more on physical evidence from the crime scene and witness interviews. The investigation approach is different.
Trial Strategy
In white collar trials, the focus is often on technicalities – the intricacies of financial transactions and points of law. The goal is to get charges dismissed on a technicality or receive a favorable plea bargain. Blue collar trials involve more emotional appeals, character witnesses, and arguments for reasonable doubt.
Client Relationships
White collar clients tend to be sophisticated executives. The relationship is more formal. Blue collar clients often come from disadvantaged backgrounds so the attorney-client relationship is more personal and supportive.
Fees and Expenses
White collar firms charge higher hourly rates and case expenses. Hiring top white collar attorneys costs tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars. Blue collar attorneys have lower overhead and charge more affordable rates for everyday people.
Why Does the Difference Matter?
The right lawyer makes all the difference in getting charges reduced or dismissed. Here are some reasons the white collar vs. blue collar distinction is important:
- A white collar attorney won’t know how to interact with the client and win over a blue collar jury.
- A blue collar lawyer may not grasp complex financial schemes at the heart of white collar cases.
- The discovery process is completely different – white collar cases have mountains of documents.
- Plea bargaining and sentencing guidelines differ for white collar crimes.
- Judges handle street crimes every day but may rarely see a white collar case.
The bottom line is specialized knowledge and experience is needed. Don’t assume any criminal lawyer can successfully defend your specific case.
How to Choose the Right Criminal Defense Attorney
When selecting a NYC criminal attorney, here are some tips:
- Carefully examine their background, education, experience with your type of crime.
- Ask about their track record getting charges dismissed or reduced.
- Choose someone who makes you feel comfortable – you’ll be working closely.
- Understand the fee structure and expected costs.
- Look for great communicator who will fight aggressively in court.
By choosing the right lawyer for your case – whether white collar or blue collar – you’ll maximize your chances of the best possible outcome. Don’t leave your fate to chance.
References
Here are some references used in this article: