Blog
Is Sodomy Illegal
Contents
Is Sodomy Illegal? A Complicated Legal History
Sodomy laws in the United States have a long and complicated history. Simply put, sodomy refers to certain sexual acts, like oral or anal sex, that were historically criminalized in many states, even between consenting adults in private. However, over the past few decades, court rulings at both the state and federal level have overturned or struck down most sodomy laws as unconstitutional.So is sodomy currently illegal? The short answer is – no, sodomy is legal between consenting adults in private throughout the United States. However, some states still have these outdated laws on the books. Let’s take a closer look at the history and current legal status of sodomy laws.
A Brief History of Sodomy Laws
Sodomy laws in the U.S. originated from English “buggery” laws brought over by colonists in the 1600s. These laws prohibited and criminalized “unnatural” sexual acts, including both homosexual and heterosexual acts beyond just intercourse. Over time, states began passing their own sodomy statutes outlawing oral and anal sex.Historically, sodomy laws were used to punish and discriminate against LGBTQ individuals engaging in consensual same-sex intimacy. However, the laws also impacted consenting opposite-sex couples. By the 1960s, every state had enacted some form of legislation against sodomy. Penalties ranged from fines to lengthy prison terms.This began to change in the latter half of the 20th century, as social attitudes shifted and LGBTQ advocacy groups brought legal challenges. In 2003, the Supreme Court’s ruling in Lawrence v. Texas was a watershed moment – it struck down Texas’ sodomy law, invalidating sodomy prohibitions in 13 other states. However, some states still kept these laws on the books.
Where Sodomy Laws Stand Today
The Lawrence decision was monumental, ruling that sodomy laws violated the 14th Amendment’s guarantees of liberty and privacy. However, it did not automatically invalidate sodomy statutes nationwide.Over a dozen states still have sodomy laws, though they go largely unenforced after Lawrence. For example, Idaho’s law calls for up to life imprisonment for sodomy. In 2019, the Idaho legislature updated the law to remove the phrase “infamous crime against nature,” but kept the felony penalty.Some states like Montana and Kansas have repealed their sodomy laws post-Lawrence. In 2022, legislation was introduced in Louisiana to fully repeal their invalidated statute. Progress has been piecemeal though – in Virginia, an attempt to repeal their sodomy law just failed in 2023.The continued existence of these outdated laws is concerning to civil rights groups. They warn that sodomy statutes could still potentially be used to harass marginalized groups, or be reinstated if federal courts shift rightwards.
Lingering Effects of Historical Sodomy Laws
Though unenforceable, existing sodomy laws still have harmful effects. For one, their presence perpetuates stigma and the concept that certain sexual acts are “criminal.”Research also suggests that sodomy laws impacted HIV prevention efforts. A 2022 study found higher rates of HIV diagnoses in states that had sodomy laws post-Lawrence versus those that repealed them promptly. The researchers posit that “the stigmatization of same-sex intimacy” hindered funding and legislation around HIV education and testing.There are also concerns around sex offender registration. Some states may still require registration for consensual sodomy acts, even though the laws are unconstitutional. Defendants may plead down to sodomy charges to avoid more serious offenses. This means individuals are placed on the sex offender registry when no crime occurred under Lawrence.
Looking Ahead – Efforts to Remove Remaining Sodomy Laws
Civil rights organizations continue pushing to wipe sodomy statutes off the books for good. They argue that the government has no place regulating private intimacy between consenting adults, regardless of sexual orientation. However, some conservative and religious groups still support sodomy laws.The sodomy law battle shows that while much progress has been made on LGBTQ rights, more work remains to be done. As one legal expert put it: “The government should not be peering into people’s bedrooms, and it shouldn’t be criminalizing consensual sexual activity.” Even unenforced, sodomy laws are vestiges of intolerance that open the door for potential civil liberties violations. Their repeal is an important step towards ensuring equality under the law.