Service & Results.

nyc criminal lawyers over 30 years of experienceWe Know How To Win Cases

Spodek Law Group handles tough cases
nationwide, that demand excellence.

Get Free Consultation

Faced 5+ Years in Prison

People Vs Joseph Amico

Covered by NYDaily News. Las Vegas man accused of threatening a prominent attorney and making vile remarks.

Faced 10+ Years in Prison

People Vs. Anna Sorokin

Covered by New York Times, and other outlets. Fake heiress accused of conning the city’s wealthy, and has an HBO special being made about her.

Faced 3+ Years in Prison

People Vs. Genevieve Sabourin

Accused of stalking Alec Baldwin. The case garnered nationwide attention, with USAToday, NYPost, and other media outlets following it closely.

Faced Potential Charges

Ghislaine Maxwell Juror

Juror who prompted calls for new Ghislaine Maxwell trial turns to lawyer who defended Anna Sorokin.

Why Choose Us

Clients can use our portal to track the status of their case, stay in touch with us, upload documents, and more.

Regardless of the type of situation you're facing, our attorneys are here to help you get quality representation.

We can setup consultations in person, over Zoom, or over the phone to help you. Bottom line, we're here to help you win your case.

Law in the Media

View All

Meet Todd Spodek


The Spodek Law Group understands how delicate high-profile cases can be, and has a strong track record of getting positive outcomes. Our lawyers service a clientele that is nationwide. With offices in both LA and NYC, and cases all across the country - Spodek Law Group is a top tier law firm.

Todd Spodek is a second generation attorney with immense experience. He has many years of experience handling 100’s of tough and hard to win trials. He’s been featured on major news outlets, such as New York Post, Newsweek, Fox 5 New York, South China Morning Post, Insider.com, and many others.

In 2022, Netflix released a series about one of Todd’s clients: Anna Delvey/Anna Sorokin.

Why Clients Choose Spodek Law Group

The reason is simple: clients want white glove service, and lawyers who can win. Every single client who works with the Spodek Law Group is aware that the attorney they hire could drastically change the outcome of their case. Hiring the Spodek Law Group means you’re taking your future seriously. Our lawyers handle cases nationwide, ranging from NYC to LA. Our philosophy is fair and simple: our nyc criminal lawyers only take on clients who we know will benefit from our services.

We’re selective about the clients we work with, and only take on cases we know align with our experience – and where we can make a difference. This is different from other law firms who are not invested in your success nor care about your outcome.

If you have a legal issue, call us for a consultation.
We are available 24/7, to help you with any – and all, challenges you face.

Federal Subpoenas for Police Misconduct Records: Available Defenses

By Spodek Law Group | January 21, 2024
(Last Updated On: January 21, 2024)

Federal Subpoenas for Police Misconduct Records: Available Defenses

Being served with a federal subpoena for police misconduct records can be an intimidating and concerning experience. As a police department or municipality, you have an obligation to cooperate, but you also need to protect sensitive information and the rights of your officers. This article provides an overview of federal subpoenas, what they entail, available defenses to fight or limit them, and steps to take if you receive one.

What is a Federal Subpoena?

A federal subpoena is a written order requiring you to provide documents, records, testimony or physical evidence relevant to a federal criminal investigation or trial. They are issued under the authority of the court.Subpoenas can request a wide range of records related to police misconduct allegations, including:

  • Internal affairs investigation files
  • Citizen complaint records
  • Disciplinary reports
  • Use of force reports
  • Officer personnel files

Failure to comply can result in civil or criminal contempt of court charges. However, there are certain defenses available.

Available Defenses Against Federal Subpoenas

While federal subpoenas carry serious weight, there are defenses available to fight or limit them:

Law Enforcement Privilege

  • Argues investigative files should remain confidential to protect law enforcement techniques and sources
  • Courts balance this against the subpoena’s relevance to the case
  • Can limit what needs to be disclosed

Deliberative Process Privilege

  • Shields internal advisory communications and deliberations
  • Goal is to encourage open policy discussions
  • Courts again weigh this against case relevance

State Confidentiality Laws

  • Many states have laws protecting police personnel records
  • Argue these laws override the subpoena
  • Success depends on strength of confidentiality rules

Overbreadth and Relevance Challenges

  • Argue subpoena requests more than is relevant or necessary
  • Ask court to narrow scope to directly relevant materials

Burdensomeness Claims

  • Argue compiling and redacting documents is overly burdensome
  • May get additional time or resources to comply

While these defenses can limit disclosure in some cases, courts tend to favor enforcement if relevance to the case is clear.

What to Do When You Receive a Federal Subpoena

If your department receives a federal subpoena for police misconduct records, here are important steps to take:

  • Contact attorneys immediately to discuss response
  • Develop legal strategy based on available defenses

2. Notify Affected Officers

  • Alert officers named in the subpoena
  • Discuss process and what materials may be disclosed

3. Negotiate Scope and Terms

  • Seek to narrow subpoena through legal negotiations
  • Get sufficient time to pull relevant materials

4. Gather and Review Responsive Records

  • Work with counsel to identify all responsive docs
  • Redact protected personal information

5. Produce Required Materials

  • Provide subpoenaed materials by the deadline
  • Continue objecting to overbroad elements

Having an action plan prepared can help you appropriately respond while protecting sensitive records.

How an Attorney Can Help With Challenging Subpoenas

Working with an attorney experienced with federal subpoenas is highly recommended. They can:

  • Evaluate scope and validity of subpoena requests
  • Raise various legal challenges and defenses
  • Negotiate with prosecutors to limit disclosure
  • Ensure compliant response process and redactions
  • Defend against contempt charges if dispute arises

Getting expert legal advice can give you the best chance of protecting sensitive records and limiting disclosure.

Example Cases of Successful Challenges

There have been many cases where police departments have successfully fought against overbroad federal subpoenas requesting misconduct records:In U.S. v. City of New York, the NYPD challenged a subpoena requesting all civil lawsuit documentation against officers over a 5-year period. They argued it was too burdensome and irrelevant. The court limited the scope to documents directly related to the civil rights claim.The Seattle Police Department fought a request for 15 years worth of records related to police violence during protests. Again citing overbreadth, the court narrowed the subpoena to use of force reports occurring within a 1-month timeframe.These cases demonstrate that while challenging federal subpoenas is difficult, the right legal strategy can help limit disclosure.


Receiving a federal subpoena for police misconduct records or investigative materials is serious business. While departments have an obligation to cooperate, several defenses allow fighting overbroad or unduly burdensome requests. Working closely with legal counsel, narrowing the scope where possible, and appropriately redacting protected information is key to balancing disclosure and confidentiality when responding. With the right strategy, departments can produce required materials while preventing unnecessary invasion of sensitive records and personnel privacy.


Overview of federal subpoenas: https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladviceofftopic/comments/f1x14t/how_do_federal_subpoenas_work/Types of records requested: https://www.avvo.com/legal-guides/ugc/what-is-a-federal-subpoenaSubpoena defenses: https://www.quora.com/What-are-some-defenses-one-can-raise-to-resist-a-federal-subpoenaAttorney assistance: https://www.findlaw.com/litigation/legal-system/responding-to-a-subpoena-request.htmlU.S. v. City of New York:
https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/new-york/nysdce/1:2008mc00347/321396/39/Seattle Police Department subpoena challenge:

Free Consultation


I was searching for a law firm with some power to help me deal with a warrant in New York . After 6 days I decided to go with Spodek Law Group. It helped that This law firm is well respected by not only the top law firms in New York , but the DA , Judge as well. I...

~Fonder Brandon

5 Stars
It was my good fortune to retain Spodek Law Group for representation for my legal needs. From the beginning, communication was prompt and thorough. Todd, Kenneth and Alex were the first people I worked with and they all made me feel comfortable and confident that the team was going to work hard for me. Everything was explained and any concerns...

~A G

5 Stars
After meeting with several law firms, I chose the Spodek Law Group not only for their professionalism and experience, but for the personal attention given to me right from the initial consultation. It is important to recognize how crucial having the right legal team is when faced with potentially life altering events that impact families and the lives of loved...

~George Cherubini

Spodek Law Group

White Glove Service

We Provide Superior Service, Excellent Results, At A Level Superior To Other Criminal Defense Law Firms. Regardless Of Where Your Case Is, Nationwide, We Can Help You.
View More

Request Free Consultation

Please fill out the form below to receive a free consultation, we will respond to
your inquiry within 24-hours guaranteed.


85 Broad St 30th Floor, New York, NY 10004


get directions

Los Angeles

611 S Catalina St Suite 222, Los Angeles, CA 90005


get directions


35-37 36th St, 2nd Floor Astoria, NY 11106


get directions


195 Montague St., 14th Floor, Brooklyn, NY 11201


get directions
Call Now!