Criminal Defense Lawyers

dismissal of case with prejudice

Understanding Dismissal of a Case With Prejudice

Being involved in a lawsuit can be an incredibly stressful and confusing time. You may have questions about the meaning of certain legal terminology or what impact various rulings from the court may have on your case. One term you may come across is “dismissal with prejudice” which refers to a specific type of dismissal order issued by a judge.

What Does It Mean to Dismiss a Case With Prejudice?

When a judge dismisses a case “with prejudice”, it means the case is dismissed permanently and the person or company suing you is barred from filing another lawsuit against you for the same claim. Some key things to understand about dismissal with prejudice include:

• It is a final ruling – the court will not revisit the claims in that lawsuit again. This prevents the plaintiff from filing repetitive lawsuits for issues already settled.
• The plaintiff forfeits the claims forever – they cannot sue you again in the future for that same incident or issue, even if new evidence comes to light later.
• Res judicata applies – this legal doctrine prevents re-litigating the same case with the same parties over again.

Essentially, dismissal with prejudice provides closure and prevents the plaintiff from “having another bite at the apple” against you for that claim. It is generally seen as a very favorable outcome for defendants.

Reasons Why a Case May Be Dismissed With Prejudice

There are a few common reasons why a judge may decide to dismiss a case with prejudice:

• Multiple failures to state a legal claim properly – If the complaint has fundamental flaws or the plaintiff has tried and failed multiple times to fix errors, the judge may dismiss the case to prevent repeated amendments.
• Discovery abuse – If the plaintiff does not comply with discovery orders or share evidence as required, it can result in dismissal of the case as a sanction.
• Failure to prosecute – If the plaintiff is not actively pursuing the case by meeting court deadlines, it may be dismissed with prejudice for failure to prosecute.
• Voluntary dismissal – Sometimes the plaintiff decides to withdraw the lawsuit, resulting in voluntary dismissal with prejudice.

Procedural missteps like these can cause a case to be tossed out permanently.

What Happens When a Case Is Dismissed With Prejudice?

The effects of having your case dismissed with prejudice are significant:

• The case cannot be re-filed – The court will not hear that plaintiff’s claims against you on that incident again.
• Claims are forfeited – That plaintiff loses legal rights to damages or remedies from you for that incident.
• No appeal is possible – An involuntary dismissal with prejudice cannot be appealed to a higher court.
• Fees may be awarded – If the lawsuit was frivolous or lacking evidence, you can ask the court to order the plaintiff to pay your attorney fees.

So in essence, a dismissal with prejudice closes the book on that case. It allows you to move forward knowing the claims have been forfeited and cannot be brought again later.

How to Seek Dismissal With Prejudice in Your Case

If you are currently facing a lawsuit, there are steps your attorney may take to request dismissal with prejudice:

• File a motion to dismiss – This asks the judge to review the complaint and dismiss the case due to lack of merit or other deficiencies.
• Seek sanctions for discovery violations – If the plaintiff is not cooperating with evidence requests or deadlines, your lawyer can seek sanctions, including dismissal.
• Highlight failure to prosecute – If lack of action by the plaintiff is stalling the case, this may justify dismissal.
• Request voluntary dismissal with prejudice – Your lawyer may negotiate this settlement of the claims with the plaintiff.

An experienced attorney knows best when and how to strategically seek dismissal with prejudice in your civil lawsuit.

What to Do If Your Case Is Dismissed With Prejudice

If you receive notice that your case has been dismissed with prejudice, be sure to take these steps:

• Get it in writing – Have your attorney formally file the court’s dismissal order in the case record. This will prevent any confusion later on.
• Close the matter fully – Double check that the dismissal closes not just part of the case but the entire case. You want no loose ends.
• Recover fees if applicable – Ask your lawyer about next steps to recover attorney fees or sanctions from the plaintiff if the lawsuit was frivolous or abusive.
• Watch for an appeal attempt – In rare cases, the plaintiff may improperly try to appeal the dismissal. Your lawyer can shut this down quickly.
• Celebrate and move on – Take a breath knowing this lawsuit cannot resurface again in the future to haunt you!

Using these tips will help ensure you take full advantage of a dismissal ruling in your favor.

Common Questions About Dismissal With Prejudice

If you have been through the stressful experience of facing a lawsuit, you likely still have plenty of questions even after your case is dismissed. Here are some common questions to help you understand dismissal with prejudice fully:Can the plaintiff simply re-file the same lawsuit again in the future?No, dismissal with prejudice bars that plaintiff from bringing another lawsuit against you for those same claims in the future. The ruling is permanent.What if new evidence supporting their case is found later?The dismissal with prejudice still stands – that case cannot be reopened even if the plaintiff finds evidence supporting their claims after the fact. So you can rest assured it is over for good.Could the plaintiff sue me again for a different claim related to the same incident?No, the principle of res judicata prevents the plaintiff from suing you again related to the same incident and parties. If they try, your lawyer can immediately request dismissal based on res judicata.What happens if plaintiff appeals the dismissal – could I still end up back in court?It is very rare for a plaintiff to successfully appeal an involuntary dismissal with prejudice. If they try to appeal, your attorney can file motions to reject the appeal and uphold the dismissal order. This will likely be the end of the road for additional court proceedings.Having definitive and reliable answers to concerns like these can help you sleep better at night when dealing with a lawsuit. An experienced lawyer guides you through the process.

Final Thoughts

Going through litigation is draining emotionally, physically, and financially. Receiving formal dismissal with prejudice – meaning that case is over for good – can be an incredible relief. Be sure to celebrate the win! But also reflect on steps to prevent getting dragged into court again down the road.An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure – staying abreast of laws impacting your business, maintaining thorough records, and promptly addressing disputes before they escalate can help reduce lawsuit risk substantially. Here’s to many years ahead lawsuit-free!

Resources

https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/5byvv4/my_case_was_dismissed_with_prejudice_what_does/
https://www.avvo.com/legal-guides/ugc/what-does-dismissal-with-prejudice-mean
https://www.lawinfo.com/resources/civil-procedure/dismissal-with-prejudice.html https://www.findlaw.com/litigation/legal-system/what-is-res-judicata-.html
https://www.quora.com/In-what-situations-would-a-case-get-dismissed-with-prejudice https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/7s835c/what_does_it_actually_mean_for_a_case_to_be/
https://www.avvo.com/legal-guides/ugc/how-to-get-your-case-dismissed https://www.quora.com/If-a-case-is-dismissed-with-prejudice-what-does-that-mean-for-the-parties-involved https://www.avvo.com/legal-guides/ugc/what-does-dismissal-with-prejudice-mean
https://www.lawinfo.com/resources/civil-procedure/dismissal-with-prejudice.html https://www.findlaw.com/litigation/legal-system/what-is-res-judicata-.html https://www.reddit.com/r/legaladvice/comments/5byvv4/my_case_was_dismissed_with_prejudice_what_does/