Free Consultations & We're Available 24/7
WE'RE A BOUTIQUE LAW FIRM.
TRUST 50 YEARS OF EXPERIENCE.
WE SERVICE CLIENTS NATIONWIDE.
Welcome to Spodek Law Group. If the FBI just seized your phone, computer, tablet, and every other electronic device in your possession, you need to understand something immediately: they didn’t just take your property. They took your entire digital life. Every text message you’ve sent for years. Every photo. Every email. Every late-night Google search. Every contact in your phone. Your location history showing everywhere you’ve been. And here’s what most people don’t realize – the “deleted” files you thought were gone forever are exactly what FBI forensic examiners specialize in recovering.
Your devices are now sitting in an FBI evidence locker, and they will stay there for months. The average backlog at federal forensic labs is nine months before anyone even begins to examine your electronics. Then the actual analysis takes another six to eighteen months. During this entire time, you have no access to your own life – your contacts, your documents, your photos, your work files. Everything is locked away in federal custody while forensic specialists methodically extract every piece of data your devices ever contained.
Here’s the constitutional question that makes this situation even more terrifying: courts across the country are split on whether the government can force you to unlock your phone. The Fifth Amendment protects you from self-incrimination, and some courts say providing your password forces you to reveal “the contents of your own mind.” Other courts disagree. The Supreme Court hasn’t decided. So you’re facing a genuine constitutional question mark while your entire digital existence sits in an FBI lab.
When the FBI seizes your electronics, most people think about the devices themselves. Thats the wrong way to understand whats happening. The devices are just containers. What the FBI actualy seized is the comprehensive digital record of your life – and that record extends far beyond the physical devices agents carried out of your home.
Your phone contains years of text messages, including conversations you forgot you ever had. It contains every photo youve taken and every photo thats been sent to you. It contains your complete browsing history, your search queries, your app usage data, and your location history showing everywhere youve been for years. Modern smartphones track your movements constantly, and that data doesnt disappear when you leave a location.
Your computer contains every document youve created or downloaded. Every email youve received, including the ones you “deleted.” Every file youve accessed. Your login credentials for dozens of websites. Your financial records, your tax returns, your personal correspondence. The browsing history you thought “private mode” protected – forensic tools recover that too.
Every embarrassing photo, every angry text, every 3am Google search is now in FBI hands – not just what theyre investigating.
Heres what catches people off guard: cloud synchronization means the seizure extends far beyond the physical devices. Your phone syncs to iCloud. Your computer syncs to Google Drive or Dropbox. Your email lives on servers you dont control. When FBI agents seized your physical electronics, they gained access to everything those devices connect to. Theres no single location for your digital life anymore. Its everywhere – and the FBI can reach all of it with the appropriate warrants.
Attorney Todd Spodek has represented clients who were shocked to discover the scope of what FBI forensics revealed. One client had forgotten about text messages from three years earlier. Another had no memory of certain files on their computer. Your devices remember everything, even when you dont.
Heres something that surprises almost everyone whose electronics have been seized: your devices will probly sit in an evidence locker for months before any forensic examiner even touches them. The FBI operates 16 Regional Computer Forensics Laboratories around the country, in partnership with 130 state and local law enforcement agencies – and there still not enough to handle the volume.
The average backlog at federal forensic labs is nine months. Thats not how long the analysis takes. Thats how long your devices wait in line before the analysis even begins. During this time, your phone, your computer, your tablet – there all sitting in storage. You have no access to your contacts. You have no access to your photos. You have no access to your documents.
Think about what that means practically. If you ran your business from your computer, that computer is gone. If you stored client files on your laptop, those files are inaccessible. If all your contacts were in your phone, you cant reach anyone. If your password manager was on a seized device, you may not be able to log into accounts you need to function.
For many people, having there electronics seized is like having there entire existence frozen. You cant work normally. You cant communicate normally. You cant access your own memories – photos of your children, records of important events, documents you need for your daily life. All of it sits in federal custody while forensic examiners work through there backlog.
The timeline typically breaks down like this: During the first six months, forensic examiners are working through cases ahead of yours. Eventually they get to your devices and create whats called a “forensic image” – an exact copy of every bit of data on your hard drive. They analyze that image using specialized tools that can recover deleted files, examine metadata, and reconstruct your digital activity.
One of the most dangerous misconceptions people have is that deleted files are gone. FBI forensic examiners build there careers on recovering files that users thought they had destroyed. The technology for recovering “deleted” data is remarkably sophisticated, and FBI affidavits regularly reference files recovered months or even years after deletion.
Heres how deletion actualy works on most devices. When you delete a file, your computer dosent erase the data. It removes the pointer that tells the operating system where to find that file. The actual data remains on your hard drive until something else overwrites it. On a hard drive with plenty of free space, that could take months or years.
Beyond the data itself, your operating system keeps records in places you never see. “Swap” files, “recovery” files, and unallocated disk space all contain fragments of data youve supposedly deleted. Forensic tools are specificaly designed to find and reconstruct this information.
Computer files or remnants can be recovered months or years after they have been downloaded, deleted, or viewed – this is directly from FBI affidavits.
What about “private browsing” mode? It dosent protect you from forensic examination. Private mode prevents your browser from saving history locally in the normal location. It dosent prevent the data from being recoverable through forensic analysis. The ACLU has documented how forensic analysis can reconstruct supposedly private activity.
Theres only one thing that truly makes data unrecoverable: secure overwriting. If data has been overwritten multiple times with specialized wiping software, forensic recovery becomes impossible. But simply deleting files – even “permanently” deleting them, even emptying your recycle bin – leaves the data intact for forensic recovery.
This creates an impossible situation for many people. You cant go back and securely wipe files now – your devices are already in FBI custody. And if you had tried to wipe files after learning about an investigation, that itself could be obstruction of justice. The FBI says theres “rarely only one copy of something digital” anyway – communication servers, other people’s inboxes, cloud backups, and screenshots may all retain data you thought you deleted.
If FBI agents asked for your password during the seizure, you faced a question with no clear answer. Courts across the country are genuinly split on whether the Fifth Amendment protects you from being forced to reveal your password.
The Fifth Amendment protects against compelled self-incrimination. The question is whether providing your password counts as “testimonial” – whether it reveals “the contents of your own mind” in a way the Constitution prohibits.
Some courts say yes. The Utah Supreme Court in State v. Valdez held that demanding someone verbally provide a cell phone passcode violates the Fifth Amendment. The Pennsylvania Supreme Court reached the same conclusion in Commonwealth v. Davis. In these jurisdictions, you cannot be forced to reveal your password.
Other courts say no. The New Jersey Supreme Court in State v. Andrews held that if the government can prove you know the password, the “foregone conclusion” doctrine applies. Under this theory, the only testimonial aspect is whether you know the password – and if the government already knows you know it, theres nothing testimonial about making you provide it.
Wheres the Supreme Court on this? Nowhere. As of today, the highest court has not resolved this split. A petition for certiorari has been filed asking the Court to decide, but theres been no ruling. So your constitutional rights depend on which jurisdiction your case is in.
Heres where it gets even more complicated. Courts treat biometric unlocking differently then passwords. Some courts have held that forcing someone to use there fingerprint or face to unlock a phone is constitutional – because biometrics dont reveal “the contents of your mind.” Other courts disagree. The Northern District of California held in 2019 that biometric unlocking violates the Fifth Amendment because its functionally equivalent to a password.
At Spodek Law Group, we advise clients on password and device security before seizure situations arise – because once agents have your devices, your options are much more limited.
Even if FBI agents only walked out with your physical devices, they effectivly seized much more. Everything synced to cloud services is now within there reach – and in the modern world, almost everything syncs.
Your iPhone backs up to iCloud. Your Android backs up to Google. Your documents may sync to Dropbox, OneDrive, or Google Drive. Your email lives on servers operated by Google, Microsoft, or your email provider. Your photos automaticaly upload to cloud storage. Your text messages may be backed up without you even realizing it.
The FBI describes this challenge from there own perspective: executing searches in cloud environments means data is rarely in a single geographic location. But from your perspective, this means the seizure of your phone is effectivly a seizure of your entire digital ecosystem. Agents can obtain warrants for cloud data associated with the accounts on your seized devices.
This creates exposure you may not have anticipated. Messages you deleted from your phone may exist in cloud backups. Photos you removed from your device may persist in cloud storage. Email you cleared from your inbox still exists on the server. The FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin discusses how agents execute warrants across these distributed systems.
Theres rarely only one copy of anything digital. The text you deleted exists on the recipients phone. The email you erased is in the recipients inbox. The photo you removed was screenshotted by someone. Cloud services designed to protect your data through redundancy now mean your data exists in multiple places the FBI can potentially access.
After seizure, most people want to know: how long until I find out what happens? The honest answer is that it takes much longer then anyone expects – and the uncertainty itself is part of the punishment.
The typical timeline works like this. During months one through six, your devices sit in the forensic lab backlog. Examiners are working through cases that came before yours. Your electronics wait in evidence storage, untouched.
During months six through twelve, forensic examiners finally reach your devices. They create forensic images and begin there analysis. Theyre recovering deleted files, examining metadata, reconstructing your digital activity. This process is thorough and time-consuming.
During months twelve through eighteen, the case agent takes the forensic results and combines them with other evidence – witness interviews, financial records, surveillance. An Assistant US Attorney evaluates whether the evidence supports federal charges. If charges are coming, youll typically receive a target letter or agents will arrive with an arrest warrant.
Some cases stretch even longer. Weve seen investigations where four years passed between seizure and charges. The statute of limitations for most federal crimes is five years under 18 USC 3282, meaning the government can take its time.
During this entire period – potentially years – you have no access to your own digital life while facing complete uncertainty about your future.
This timeline creates extraordinary stress. You dont know what the FBI found. You dont know what there theory of the case is. You dont know whether charges are coming or when. Your electronics remain in federal custody. Your life is on hold while the system works at its own pace.
Can you get your electronics back? The answer is complicated – but its not hopeless.
The government cannot hold your devices indefinitly without justification. The Eighth Circuit federal appeals court has ruled that if the governments legitimate interests can be satisfied even if property is returned, continued retention becomes unreasonable. This means there are legal grounds to challenge prolonged seizures.
Federal Rule of Criminal Procedure 41(g) allows you to file a motion for return of property. If the government no longer needs your devices for investigation or prosecution, you may be entitled to get them back. This is especialy relevant if the investigation concludes without charges or if the case resolves.
However, several factors complicate this. First, if charges are filed, your devices become evidence and will be retained through trial and potentially appeals. Second, even if the government returns your physical devices, they keep the forensic images – copies of all your data. Third, the government may argue that civil forfeiture applies to your electronics, claiming they were used in criminal activity.
The practical reality is that most people dont get there devices back for a very long time. Even when devices are eventually returned, the government has already extracted everything. Your data is now in federal hands permanantly – returning the hardware dosent undo the forensic examination.
Todd Spodek has successfully argued for return of property in cases where clients faced extended seizures without being charged. But these motions require understanding the specific legal standards and timing. Filing too early may be futile; waiting too long means living without your electronics indefinitly.
If youre reading this because the FBI just seized your electronics, heres what you need to do immediatly.
First, document exactly what was seized. The agents should have provided an inventory or receipt. Review it carefully. Note every device taken – phones, computers, tablets, hard drives, USB drives, memory cards, gaming consoles, anything electronic. If you didnt recieve an inventory, request one through your attorney.
Second, do not discuss the seized devices with anyone except your attorney. Dont speculate with family about what might be on them. Dont text friends asking if they remember certain conversations. Dont post on social media about the seizure. Every statement you make could become evidence. Every communication could be construed as witness tampering.
Third, understand that you probly cant access the cloud accounts connected to seized devices without legal guidance. Logging into iCloud or Google to “check what they might find” creates evidence of your actions. Attempting to delete cloud data could be obstruction. Talk to an attorney before accessing any connected accounts.
Fourth, if you havent yet given your passwords to agents, consult with counsel immediately about the Fifth Amendment implications in your jurisdiction. The NACDL Compelled Decryption Primer provides background on this complex area, but you need attorney advice specific to your situation.
Fifth, prepare for an extended timeline. Your devices will probly be in federal custody for months or years. Start rebuilding your digital life – new phone, new computer, new accounts – while understanding that anything you create going forward could also become relevant if youre under investigation.
Sixth, retain federal criminal defense counsel immediatly if you havent already. This is not a situation where you wait to see what happens. An experienced attorney can communicate with the government, advise you on your rights, potentially negotiate return of property, and prepare for whatever comes next.
The seizure of your electronics is not the end of an investigation – its often closer to the middle or end. By the time agents showed up with a warrant, they already had significant evidence and a theory of the case. The forensic examination of your devices is about confirming what they suspect and gathering additional evidence.
At Spodek Law Group, we handle federal investigation cases nationwide. Call 212-300-5196 for a confidential consultation. Your digital life is now evidence – and how you respond in the coming days will shape everything that follows.
Very diligent, organized associates; got my case dismissed. Hard working attorneys who can put up with your anxiousness. I was accused of robbing a gemstone dealer. Definitely A law group that lays out all possible options and best alternative routes. Recommended for sure.
- ROBIN, GUN CHARGES ROBIN
NJ CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEYS