What are the penalties for making false statements?

What are the Penalties for Making False Statements?

Making false statements, also known as perjury or lying under oath, can have serious legal consequences. But what exactly are the penalties? Well, it depends on a few key factors.

Federal vs. State Laws

There are both federal and state laws prohibiting false statements. At the federal level, a key statute is 18 U.S. Code § 1001, which prohibits knowingly and willfully making false statements in matters within the jurisdiction of the federal government. This covers lying to federal agents, in court testimony, or on federal documents. The maximum penalty is 5 years in prison.

States also have their own perjury laws. These often mirror the federal statutes but can have different penalties depending on the state. For example, in California the maximum prison sentence for perjury is 4 years^[1], while in Florida it goes up to 15 years^[2]. So the specific state matters.

Type of False Statement

Not all false statements are treated equally under the law. Statements made under oath (in court testimony or affidavits) are generally considered more serious. There may also be enhanced penalties for certain types of lies – like making false statements related to terrorism or national security matters.

For example, at the federal level, the maximum penalty for perjury is 5 years in prison. But for making false statements related to terrorism, the potential prison sentence goes up to 8 years^[3].

Actual vs. Potential Harm

When determining penalties, courts also consider how much harm was caused or could have been caused by the lie. Making false statements that obstruct an investigation or undermine the integrity of legal proceedings are seen as more serious. While lies that have little material effect may receive lighter punishment.

So in cases where significant damage was done or could have resulted, judges tend to impose longer sentences within the statutory guidelines.

Underlying Conduct

If the false statements are related to or concealing some other illegal activity, penalties can stack up through separate convictions.

For example, Martha Stewart was convicted not only of making false statements to federal investigators (sentenced to 5 months prison) but also obstruction of justice related to insider trading investigations (5 month sentence served concurrently) ^[4]. So while the false statement charge carried 5 months, the total penalty was longer due to other convictions relating to the underlying conduct.

Sentencing Guidelines

Federal judges use sentencing guidelines to determine appropriate penalties. The guidelines provide a sentencing range based on the defendant’s criminal history and details of the offense. These guidelines are advisory but judges must consider them^[5].

Where the false statements fall on the guidelines can impact the ultimate sentence. Those that trigger higher offense levels mean longer recommended sentences.

Aggravating and Mitigating Factors

Courts can also consider aggravating and mitigating circumstances that may move the sentence higher or lower.

Things like intentionally lying about very serious matters, lying repeatedly over an extended time, or trying to suborn perjury from others are aggravating factors. On the other hand, owning up to the lies right away, showing remorse, or cooperating with investigators are mitigating factors.

Other things like advanced age, health issues, family obligations, charitable works or lack of criminal history might also reduce sentences.

Plea Agreements

Many false statement cases end up in plea agreements with prosecutors rather than going to trial. This gives the defendant some control over the penalties through negotiated deals.

Plea agreements often come with an agreed upon sentencing recommendation from prosecutors that caps prison time substantially below the statutory maximums. Though the judge still has final say.

Avoiding Criminal Charges

In some cases it may be possible to avoid criminal false statement charges altogether.

If federal agents approach you as part of an investigation, getting experienced legal counsel early on is important. An attorney can sometimes convince prosecutors not to press charges or at least negotiate pretrial diversion programs. These come with conditions (like fines, probation, community service) but allow you to avoid a criminal conviction.

—-

So in summary – penalties for false statements depend on the jurisdiction, type of lie, resulting harm, related convictions, sentencing guidelines and other factors. There is often room for defense lawyers to negotiate pleas or mitigate punishments. But potential prison time is still steep depending on the circumstances.

Getting experienced legal counsel right away is key if you find yourself questioned in relation to an investigation or if you have any concerns about past statements made to federal authorities. Don’t wait and hope it goes away on its own – that can turn out much worse in the end.