Securities Fraud: How the SEC Investigates Insider Trading Allegations
Contents
Securities Fraud: How the SEC Investigates Insider Trading Allegations
Insider trading has long been a thorn in the side of securities regulators. When corporate insiders use non-public information to trade stock in their own companies, it undermines investor confidence in the fairness of the markets.
The SEC, as the main securities regulator in the U.S., takes insider trading very seriously. They have extensive resources dedicated to detecting, investigating, and prosecuting insider trading cases. For individuals found guilty, the penalties can be severe, including huge fines and even jail time.
What Constitutes Illegal Insider Trading
Illegal insider trading occurs when a corporate insider trades stock based on material, non-public information about that company. This gives them an unfair advantage over other investors and erodes confidence in the stock market.
Information is considered “material” if a reasonable investor would consider it important when deciding whether to buy, sell, or hold stock. This could include unpublished financial results, plans for a merger or acquisition, a significant cybersecurity breach, or the gain or loss of a major customer or contract.
Information is considered “non-public” if it has not been widely disseminated to the public through a press release, SEC filing, or other common communication channels.
It’s also illegal to pass material non-public information to someone else who then trades on it. This is called “tipping” and both the tipper and tippee can face insider trading charges if caught.
How the SEC Detects Insider Trading
The SEC uses sophisticated stock surveillance techniques to detect potential insider trading. This includes closely monitoring trading activity around significant corporate events and news announcements. Unusual trading volume or well-timed trades right before major news can raise red flags.
SEC examiners also closely review stock trading records of company insiders like executives, directors, and large shareholders. Sudden spikes in trading activity or suspiciously timed trades are scrutinized further for any whiff of impropriety.
Tips from investors, company employees, and whistleblowers make up a significant portion of insider trading investigations as well. The SEC offers bounties to whistleblowers who provide information leading to significant penalties or disgorgement of illegal profits.
The Insider Trading Investigative Process
Once the SEC identifies suspicious trading activity, they launch a formal investigation. The Enforcement Division issues subpoenas to collect trading records, phone logs, emails, and other evidence that may reveal improper sharing or use of material non-public information.
SEC attorneys thoroughly interview witnesses, including traders suspected of insider trading, the source of any leaked information, and other executives or employees of the company. False statements or obstruction of justice during SEC interviews can lead to criminal charges.
The investigation process aims to determine:
- Whether material non-public information was obtained
- If it was illegally shared in breach of a fiduciary duty
- Who traded stock based on this confidential information
- The amount of illegal profits from improper insider trades
SEC staff attorneys present findings from the fact-gathering investigation to the Commission. If approved, the SEC then launches enforcement actions seeking stiff civil penalties, disgorgement of profits, and injunctive relief.
The Consequences of Insider Trading
The SEC pursues insider trading violations through civil court actions seeking penalties and profit clawbacks. But illegal insider trading can also trigger criminal prosecution by the Department of Justice leading to prison sentences.
Recent high-profile cases like Raj Rajaratnam who received an 11 year prison sentence, demonstrate the SEC’s determination to stamp out insider trading through harsh punishments.
Defending against insider trading charges is extremely difficult given the power of SEC subpoenas and civil prosecution tools. But skilled securities attorneys can sometimes negotiate reduced charges or sanctions based on the strength of evidence and other mitigating factors.
Successful SEC prosecution of insider trading relies on weaving together a compelling chain of suspicious circumstances, well-timed trades, and financial motive. But building an ironclad case can prove challenging, especially if defense lawyers can introduce reasonable doubt.
The Controversial Nature of Insider Trading Laws
Despite long-standing legal precedent, some legal scholars and investors argue that insider trading laws go too far infringing on personal liberties. They contend that investors should be free to capitalize on stock tips as they see fit.
Others counter that unpoliced insider trading tilts the investment playing field unfairly to the well-connected. Permitting unrestrained insider trading also removes incentives for proper corporate transparency and governance.
Regardless of the ethical debate, insider trading laws remain firmly entrenched making compliance mandatory. Steep punishments await those flouting securities trading regulations by exploiting confidential corporate information for profit.
Sources: