Criminal Defense Lawyers

Securities Fraud: How Cooperation with the SEC Can Mitigate Penalties

Securities Fraud: How Cooperation with the SEC Can Mitigate Penalties

Securities fraud involves making false or misleading statements to investors about a company’s finances or business prospects. It’s a serious offense that can result in stiff penalties from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). However, cooperating with the SEC’s investigation can help mitigate those penalties.

What Constitutes Securities Fraud

There are a few main types of securities fraud:

• Accounting fraud – This involves cooking the books through fraudulent accounting practices to make a company’s finances appear better than they are. Common techniques include revenue recognition fraud, asset overvaluation, and expense hiding.
• Insider trading – This occurs when corporate insiders use non-public information to trade shares of their company’s stock. Since they have an unfair advantage, this is considered securities fraud.
• Pump-and-dump schemes – This is when fraudsters promote a stock through false and misleading statements, causing the share price to rise. They then sell their shares at the inflated price before the stock crashes back down.

All of these schemes undermine investor confidence in the fairness and integrity of the stock market. So the SEC takes securities fraud very seriously.

Consequences of Securities Fraud Charges

If the SEC determines that securities fraud has occurred, it can bring civil charges against the perpetrators. The penalties for securities fraud can be severe:

• Fines – The SEC often imposes fines of millions of dollars on individuals or companies charged with securities fraud. These fines are meant to punish wrongdoers and deter future violations.
• Disgorgement – Wrongdoers may have to give up (disgorge) any profits made from their fraudulent schemes. This prevents them from benefitting from their misconduct.
• Bars from the Industry – For serious offenses, fraudsters can be banned from working in the securities industry or serving as officers or directors of public companies.
• Jail Time – If the Department of Justice gets involved, securities fraud charges can also lead to criminal prosecution. This can result in years in prison.

The SEC aims to protect investors and maintain confidence in capital markets. So they come down hard on securities fraud to send a message that it won’t be tolerated.

How Cooperating with Investigations Can Help

Facing SEC charges can be daunting. But cooperating with the investigation rather than fighting the charges may lead to reduced penalties.

The SEC offers powerful incentives for cooperation, including:

Leniency Programs

The SEC runs several programs that offer leniency to those who come forward with information about misconduct. For example:

• The Whistleblower Program provides monetary awards to individuals who provide valuable tips that lead to successful SEC cases. Awards can range from 10-30% of penalties collected.
• The Cooperation Initiative offers reduced penalties to companies and individuals that self-report violations and cooperate with investigations. In some cases, fines can even be waived completely.

So if you have information about securities fraud, cooperating upfront through one of these programs can really pay off.

Credit for Cooperation

Even if you don’t come forward through a formal program, cooperating with an ongoing investigation can still help.

The SEC considers cooperation to be a crucial factor when determining penalties. Those viewed as cooperative may face:

• Lower financial penalties
• No officer/director bars or industry bans
• Continued ability to access capital markets

Essentially, playing ball with investigators can enable individuals and companies to resume normal business operations once the dust settles.

Negotiating a Settlement

The vast majority of SEC cases end in a settlement agreement rather than going to trial. Settlements allow the SEC to resolve cases efficiently while sparing defendants from a lengthy legal battle.

Settlements typically involve paying a fine and agreeing to cease any ongoing misconduct. But through skillful negotiation, defense lawyers can often get favorable settlement terms for clients who have cooperated.

So cooperating early on creates room for discussion and deal-making later that can dramatically limit penalties.

What Constitutes Cooperation?

Of course, the SEC expects more than empty promises of cooperation. To qualify for leniency programs or credit in settlement talks, genuine cooperation must be demonstrated through actions like:

• Self-reporting violations as soon as they are discovered
• Preserving relevant documents and data for investigators
• Identifying individuals involved in the misconduct
• Providing the factual narrative of how the scheme was perpetrated
• Making current and former employees available for interviews
• Providing restitution to harmed investors

Additionally, companies may need to commit to internal reforms regarding compliance, training, auditing etc. to show they are serious about preventing future violations.

Simply stonewalling investigators or withholding information can eliminate eligibility for cooperation benefits. The key is demonstrating an authentic willingness to uncover the truth.

Is Cooperation Always advisable?

Cooperating with securities fraud investigations doesn’t guarantee reduced penalties. And in some cases, it may not be advisable.

It’s important to weigh factors like:

• Strength of the regulators’ case
• Likelihood of prevailing at trial
• Potential damage to company reputation

For severe charges with strong evidence against you, attempting to settle may be the best option. But in close calls where guilt is uncertain, putting the SEC to their proof in court may pay off.

Additionally, some companies may determine that the public airing of dirty laundry cooperation would involve poses a greater risk than potential SEC penalties.

So while cooperation incentivizes are attractive, companies need to consider their specific situation rather than automatically cooperating.

Takeaway on Securities Fraud Investigations

Securities fraud is a serious violation that can spur severe civil penalties and even criminal prosecution. But cooperating with SEC investigations can provide powerful benefits like reduced fines, industry bars waived, leniency program awards, and negotiated settlements.

Still, the decision to cooperate involves weighing various factors concerning the strength of regulators’ case, potential reputational damage, and prospects at trial. Under the right circumstances, working with the SEC can mitigate penalties and allow companies and individuals to move past securities fraud violations.

The key is engaging experienced white collar defense counsel to interface with regulators and map out an optimal response strategy. With skilled legal guidance, it’s possible for those facing securities fraud charges to take control of the narrative and achieve the best possible outcome.