SEC Regulation FD Violations and Enforcement.
Regulation FD does not itself define “material nonpublic information.” Materiality is drawn from the judicial standard: information is material if there is a substantial likelihood that a reasonable investor would consider it important in making an investment decision, and information is nonpublic if the issuer has not disseminated it to the public. Determining the nonpublic status of information is straightforward. Determining materiality requires more care. It requires an analysis of both (i) the substance of the information and (ii) the circumstances under which it was disclosed.
A violation of Rule 100(a)(1) occurs if “an issuer, by means of a written or oral statement, or by use of other means that convey information, discloses material nonpublic information to any covered recipient, and promptly does not disclose said information to the public.” Selective disclosure is a violation if:
- The selective disclosure was intentional. To avoid a violation, the covered issuer must disclose the information “simultaneously,” or, as a minimum, immediately following the selective disclosure.
- The selective disclosure was inadvertent. To avoid a violation, the covered issuer must disclose the information “promptly,” or, as a minimum, as soon as reasonably practicable.
Rule 101(d) defines “promptly” to mean as soon as reasonably practicable, but in no event after the later of 24 hours or the commencement of the next day’s trading on the New York Stock Exchange.
With respect to materiality, the SEC and the federal courts rely on the “federal materiality standard.” Under this standard, information is considered material if it meets the following criteria:
- The information is such that there is “a substantial likelihood that a reasonable investor would consider it important in making an investment decision,” and
- The information, if omitted or misstated, would have significantly altered the “total mix” of information made available to a reasonable investor.
As a result, an issuer violates Rule 100(a) if it makes a selective disclosure of information that is both material and nonpublic. This is true, however, only if the person who made the selective disclosure “knew or recklessly disregarded the fact that the information was material and nonpublic.”
Who and what does Regulation FD actually cover?
What is an Issuer?
Rule 100 covers disclosures made by “issuers” and persons acting on an issuer’s behalf. Under Rule 101, an issuer is an entity “that is registered, or is required to register, under Section 12 of the Exchange Act, or is a reporting issuer under Section 15(d) of the Exchange Act.”
This definition, in turn, includes:
- Companies with a class of securities registered under Section 12 of the Exchange Act
- Companies required to file reports under Section 15(d) of the Exchange Act
- Debt issuers that report under Section 15(d)
- Closed-end investment companies
What is a Covered Recipient?
A covered recipient includes the following parties and categories of parties:
- Brokers, dealers, and their associated persons
- Investment advisers, institutional investment managers, and their associated persons
- Investment companies, hedge funds, and their affiliated persons
- Holders of the issuer’s securities, where it is reasonably foreseeable that the holder will trade on the basis of the information
Disclosures to persons who owe the issuer a duty of trust or confidence, or who expressly agree to maintain the information in confidence, are excluded from Regulation FD under Rule 100(b)(2).
What Information is Considered “Material” Under Regulation FD?
In the context of the SEC’s Regulation FD, “material” information is information that has a “substantial likelihood of being viewed as significantly altering the “total mix” of information available to a reasonable investor in making an investment decision.”
Notably, the “reasonable investor” standard is objective rather than subjective, although its application will depend on the specific circumstances at issue. In determining materiality under Regulation FD, the SEC and the federal courts generally refer to the judicial materiality standard set forth in the U.S. Supreme Court case on materiality.
Who is a Senior Official?
Under Rule 101(f), a “senior official” is a “director, executive officer, investor relations or public relations officer, or other person with similar functions.”
Separately, Rule 101(c) treats as a “person acting on behalf of an issuer” any other officer, employee, or agent of the issuer who regularly communicates with covered recipients or with the issuer’s security holders.
Who are Other Employees or Parties that Can Act on an Issuer’s Behalf?
Under Rule 101(c), a “person acting on behalf of an issuer” is any senior official of the issuer, or any other officer, employee, or agent of the issuer who regularly communicates with covered recipients or with the issuer’s security holders. Individuals acting on an issuer’s behalf under Regulation FD include:
- Directors
- Officers
- Investor-relations officers
- Executive officers
- Company insiders
- Company employees that regularly communicate with covered recipients
Where Are Foreign Issuers Fit In?
Although Regulation FD reaches issuers that have a class of securities registered under Section 12 of the Exchange Act, or that are required to file reports under Section 15(d) of the Exchange Act, Rule 101(b) expressly excludes foreign private issuers and foreign governments from the definition of “issuer.”
Rule 101(b) expressly excludes certain entities from the definition of “issuer,” and Rule 100(b)(2) excludes certain categories of communications from the scope of Regulation FD. However, this exclusion does not apply to registered investment companies other than open-end investment companies (i.e.,closed-end funds).
How quickly must a company correct selective disclosure?
Correcting Selective Disclosure and Regulation FD’s Timing Provisions
Regulation FD’s timing provisions, and the timeline for responding to selective disclosures, are set forth in 17 C.F.R. §§ 243.100 and 243.101. Under Rule 101(d), the response clock starts ticking when a company’s senior official learns of a selective disclosure (with certain exceptions). The outside deadline for corrective public dissemination is whichever of the following comes later:
- 24 hours from the time the company’s senior official learned of the selective disclosure, or,
- The commencement of the next NYSE trading day.
Permissible Forms of Public Dissemination
Under Rule 101(e), a company can publicly disclose information via a Form 8-K, press release, conference call, webcast, or “any other means of wide and non-exclusionary dissemination, as appropriate under the circumstances.”
With respect to the SEC, the Form 8-K is the primary means of public dissemination. When filed under Item 7.01, the Form 8-K is treated as “furnished” rather than “filed.” This is an important distinction for investors and companies alike. Under General Instruction B.2 to Form 8-K, information furnished under Item 7.01 is not treated as having been “filed” under the Exchange Act. As a practical matter, this means the furnished information is not subject to liability under Section 18 of the Exchange Act and is not automatically incorporated by reference into the company’s Securities Act registration statements.
The Role of Form 8-K and Item 7.01
While the Form 8-K is the primary means of public dissemination for issuers, the SEC requires companies to file Form 8-Ks only when certain triggering events occur. This is a key distinction from Regulation FD’s mandate to correct selective disclosures of material nonpublic information. A company must correct a selective disclosure regardless of whether a triggering event has occurred.
Generally speaking, any selective disclosure of material nonpublic information should be corrected via a Form 8-K filed under Item 7.01. A Form 8-K filed under Item 7.01 should contain only the required information and no additional information, and should refer investors to an accompanying press release, if applicable.
Recognized Channels of Public Dissemination
Even in the absence of a Form 8-K filing, press release, conference call, or webcast, Regulation FD may apply the notion of a “recognized channel of public dissemination.” For example, companies can establish a social media platform as a recognized channel by providing prior notice to the investing public. As however, there are some restrictions.
Although many executive accounts are technically “public,” this public visibility is not enough to establish an executive account as a recognized channel of public dissemination. Prior notice given to investors that a company’s senior official will use an account on a social media platform as a channel of public dissemination can help establish the account as a recognized channel of public dissemination. However, even in this scenario, companies must use a “recognizably public medium” that is accepted by reasonable investors.
If any of this describes your situation, it is worth talking it through with counsel. Spodek Law Group can be reached at 212-300-5196.
Why didn’t deleting DraftKings’ social posts fix the violation?
On September 26, 2024, the SEC charged DraftKings under Section 13(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and Regulation FD. The SEC noted that on July 27, 2023, DraftKings’ CEO allegedly used an account on X to tweet and a page on LinkedIn to post undisclosed information about DraftKings’ growth. As a result of the SEC’s allegations, an independent PR firm that routinely communicated with DraftKings’ senior officials allegedly shared a post on DraftKings’ CEO’s LinkedIn account as a result of the same selective disclosure.
Although DraftKings quickly removed both the X and LinkedIn posts from the public record (within 30 minutes, according to the SEC), this did not protect DraftKings against a Regulation FD violation. According to the SEC, the removal of the posts alone was not sufficient public remediation. The SEC also noted that DraftKings did not disseminate the undisclosed information to the investing public via a corrective Form 8-K filing or a press release. Instead, DraftKings allegedly waited seven days after the posts, and the posts appeared to precede DraftKings’ second-quarter financial-results release.
The SEC’s September 26, 2024, charge against DraftKings demonstrates the fact that, although public exposure, as a result of a selective disclosure, can be remediated in some cases by a prompt public dissemination, it still takes more than just deleting a social-media post to do so. Deletion alone will generally be insufficient public remediation. Instead, in order to avoid a Regulation FD violation, companies must publicly disseminate the information either (i) simultaneously, or (ii) “promptly” in the case of inadvertent selective disclosure. In either case, the company must do more than simply delete the offending posts.
What Is the SEC’s Take on Public Dissemination via Social Media?
The SEC has took a fairly balanced view of using social media as a means of public dissemination. According to the SEC, companies can use social media platforms, including X, LinkedIn, Facebook, and Instagram, as long as investors and the market are provided “prior notice” that “these are the platforms on which you can find the company’s information.” The SEC has noted that “this is important, in order to avoid, for example, the issue presented in DraftKings’ case.”
What penalties and personal liability can Regulation FD trigger?
Private Causes of Action
One key aspect of Regulation FD is that the rule created no private cause of action for selective disclosure alone. As the SEC noted in its August 15, 2000, adopting release, “Rule 100(a)(1) does not independently impose a duty of public disclosure; rather, it imposes a duty of public dissemination of certain information, and makes unlawful the disclosure of certain information to certain recipients in the absence of prompt dissemination to the public.” As a result, a selective disclosure alone does not present a private cause of action under federal securities law, and Rule 102 provides that a failure to make a public disclosure required solely by Regulation FD is not deemed a violation of Rule 10b-5.
SEC Enforcement Power, Cease-And-Desist Orders, and Personnel Liability
While a selective disclosure does not provide a private cause of action, companies must be wary of the SEC’s enforcement authority. The SEC has two primary means of pursuing enforcement action under Regulation FD: (i) administrative enforcement, and, (ii) enforcement in federal court. The SEC’s decision on which of these methods to pursue will depend on numerous factors, and the agency will generally try to pursue administrative enforcement when possible. With that said, even when the SEC initiates enforcement under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (or the Investment Advisers Act of 1940), it can still seek relief in the form of a cease-and-desist order under Section 21C.
Importantly, while Regulation FD imposes the primary duty of correcting a selective disclosure on the “issuer,” corporate personnel (including executives and directors) can face liability as well. In addition to facing liability as an “issuer,” executives and directors can face liability for “aiding and abetting” violations of Regulation FD.
How Often Does the SEC Pursue Regulation FD Enforcement?
While the SEC has the statutory and regulatory authority to pursue enforcement of Regulation FD, it has been reluctant to pursue enforcement to date. Most of the SEC’s enforcement actions are pursued under the broader securities-enforcement provisions of the Securities Act of 1933 or the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. As such, companies that are facing SEC investigation and enforcement for a Regulation FD violation will need to present the SEC with the specific defenses that are available under Regulation FD.
Penalties for Regulation FD Violations
Under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 and the Investment Advisers Act of 1940, the SEC can seek penalties in either administrative or civil enforcement proceedings. The penalty ceilings under these Acts are subject to inflation adjustments and vary based on the respondent’s type and the violation’s tier. Under the Exchange Act and the Investment Advisers Act, the relevant penalty ceilings are:
- For First-Tier Violations: For natural persons, the penalty ceiling for first-tier violations is the inflation-adjusted amount of $11,823 per violation. For any other person, including issuers, the inflation-adjusted amount is $118,225 per violation.
- For Second-Tier Violations: Second-tier violations involve fraud, deceit, manipulation, or a deliberate or reckless disregard of a regulatory requirement. For issuers, the penalty ceiling is the inflation-adjusted amount of $115,211 per violation. For others, the inflation-adjusted amount is $230,422 per violation.
- For Third-Tier Violations: Third-tier violations involve fraud, deceit, manipulation, or a deliberate or reckless disregard of a regulatory requirement that results in substantial financial loss to others. For issuers, the penalty ceiling is the inflation-adjusted amount of $1,152,115 per violation. For others, the inflation-adjusted amount is $1,152,115 per violation.
The SEC’s Seaboard Report Framework
The SEC’s Seaboard Report framework governs the circumstances in which the SEC will extend leniency to issuers accused of violating federal securities laws. In the case of a Regulation FD violation, the SEC will consider factors including:
- Self-policing
- Self-reporting
- Remediation
- Cooperation
Contact a Federal Criminal Defense Attorney
Nothing here is legal advice, and the details of your case matter. Todd Spodek and Spodek Law Group take federal criminal and white collar cases nationwide, from offices in New York, Brooklyn, Queens and Los Angeles. You can reach the firm at 212-300-5196.
Reading is good. Calling is better.
Answered within 24 hours, guaranteed. Some stories are better told out loud -
212 300 5196