Independent editorial · Updated 21 Oct 2026
Free MCA case review · 24/7 (888) 837-7053
The defense desk Merchant cash advance defense

Samson Advance Lawsuit: 6 Defenses Worth Raising in Your Answer

Raise only the defenses your documents actually support. A form list without evidence behind it costs credibility at the exact moment you need it, when a summary judgment motion lands. Six candidates appear below. Test each against your agreement, your statements, and your correspondence first.

Call (888) 837-7053Free contract review → Free · confidential · no obligation
Firms evaluated 12 Compensation None Last updated 21 Oct 2026
Fig. 01 · The verdict at a glance

The three firms worth calling, ranked

Business debt relief providers ranked, 2026
Rank Firm Score Terms Action
01
Best for MCA debt
Delancey Street Attorney-founded, commercial only. $100M+ settled. 9.6
Fee basis A percentage of enrolled debt
Speed 2 to 8 weeks per advance
Attorney-led Yes
Free consultation →
02
Best for scale
Freedom Debt Relief $20B+ resolved. Cost guarantee. No attorneys. 8.7
Fee basis 15 to 25 percent of enrolled debt, plus $9.95 monthly
Speed 24 to 48 months
Attorney-led No
Visit site →
03
Best fee basis
Pacific Debt Relief Fee charged on the settled amount, not enrolled debt. 8.4
Fee basis 15 to 25 percent of the settled amount
Speed 24 to 48 months
Attorney-led No
Visit site →

Sources: company fee disclosures, BBB profiles, and the CFPB public complaint database, read 25 August 2026. BBB review averages and CFPB totals are all time, not single year. Ratings change; verify before relying on them.

12 firms evaluated. The 3 listed here scored highest.

Delancey Street

Delancey Street reviews your agreements free and tells you in 24 to 48 hours whether the contract is vulnerable.

Fig. 02 · The article

You have 20 or 30 days to respond to a Samson MCA suit in New York, and what goes in that response matters. Defenses worth raising are that the service is improper; that the “advance” is really a criminally usurious loan in disguise; that the reconciliation clause is illusory; that the revenue estimate was impossible to believe; that the damages figure does not add up; and that any award of attorneys’ fees on the contract is unconscionable.

1. Challenge how you were served

New York courts calculate time under a very rigid, very unforgiving timing system: if the papers were handed to you, it’s 20 days to respond; if they were served by any other means, it’s 30 days from the completion of service. Leave the objection to service out of the answer and make no motion attacking it, and you can never again raise an argument that the service was invalid. If you do raise it in the answer, within 60 days of serving the answer, you have to move for judgment on that objection.

2. Call it a criminally usurious loan

Samson MCA calls itself an advance, not a loan. If a lender is knowingly charging more than 25% a year, that’s a felony. But to have usury as a defense, that usury must be pleaded in the defendant’s answer. And a business can’t raise civil usury. A court must look at the substance of the relationship, not its label. Unless the repayment of the “loan” is absolute, no matter the name, it’s not a loan. If there’s not a loan, however usurious the terms are, you’re sunk. A judge in a dispute over an MCA agreement usually will weigh three things in evaluating whether the MCA is really a loan: Is there a reconciliation clause that means the merchant isn’t on hook if it doesn’t make enough money; is there a fixed repayment term that the merchant absolutely must pay back over even if it’s not making enough money; and will the merchant still be liable if it goes bankrupt. This is an argument to put in the mix. But in one recent Fourth Department case, the court considered the factors, and in each instance found there wasn’t a loan.

Fig. 03 · The verdict, recapped

The three firms worth calling, ranked

Business debt relief providers ranked, 2026
Rank Firm Score Terms Action
01
Best for MCA debt
Delancey Street Attorney-founded, commercial only. $100M+ settled. 9.6
Fee basis A percentage of enrolled debt
Speed 2 to 8 weeks per advance
Attorney-led Yes
Free consultation →
02
Best for scale
Freedom Debt Relief $20B+ resolved. Cost guarantee. No attorneys. 8.7
Fee basis 15 to 25 percent of enrolled debt, plus $9.95 monthly
Speed 24 to 48 months
Attorney-led No
Visit site →
03
Best fee basis
Pacific Debt Relief Fee charged on the settled amount, not enrolled debt. 8.4
Fee basis 15 to 25 percent of the settled amount
Speed 24 to 48 months
Attorney-led No
Visit site →

Sources: company fee disclosures, BBB profiles, and the CFPB public complaint database, read 25 August 2026. BBB review averages and CFPB totals are all time, not single year. Ratings change; verify before relying on them.

12 firms evaluated. The 3 listed here scored highest.

3. Show the reconciliation clause is illusory

Saying a funder can lower payments doesn’t mean it will. But a reconciliation clause that depends on the sole discretion of the MCA funder to exercise its reconciliation provisions is an illusion, meaning a promise that, in practice, won’t ever be fulfilled. Another time to raise illusoriness is when the funder continues debiting while demanding more information on reconciliation. Here’s the catch. A judge in Brooklyn told a merchant in December 2025 that it can’t challenge an MCA’s reconciliation clause as illusory if it never once tried to invoke the reconciliation clause.

4. Attack the revenue estimate

An MCA contract will have a representation of how much a business makes each day. In one case, the agreement said that 25% of daily revenue was $3,500, which means the funder expected the business to make $14,000 a day. When the reality was that the business was making about $1,232 a day, it’s fair to challenge it for being improbably and unrealistically inflated. This is a test that came from two dissenting judges, not the majority, so it doesn’t have the full authority of a holding from the court.

5. Make them prove the damages

To win a judgment against a merchant, a lender must prove that the contract was made, that the lender performed the contract, that the defendant breached, and what the lender’s damages are. But if the verification says one amount but the manager’s affidavit says another, and the funder offers no explanation, the judgment should be reversed. A $229,780 damages award was reversed on appeal, and both the personal guaranty and the MCA claims fell.

6. Challenge the attorneys’ fees

In May 2026, a judge refused to give Samson MCA a default judgment and wouldn’t enforce the settlement agreement. The agreement set fees at 30 percent of the unpaid amount owed. The judge found this to be unconscionable.

You do not want to waste your first opportunity to respond.

A free contract review costs nothing and takes a day or two. Call (888) 837-7053, or send the agreements to Delancey Street for a straight read on your options.

Fig. 04 · The verdict, in full

The three firms worth calling, ranked

Business debt relief providers ranked, 2026
Rank Firm Score Terms Action
01
Best for MCA debt
Delancey Street Attorney-founded, commercial only. $100M+ settled. 9.6
Fee basis A percentage of enrolled debt
Speed 2 to 8 weeks per advance
Attorney-led Yes
Free consultation →
02
Best for scale
Freedom Debt Relief $20B+ resolved. Cost guarantee. No attorneys. 8.7
Fee basis 15 to 25 percent of enrolled debt, plus $9.95 monthly
Speed 24 to 48 months
Attorney-led No
Visit site →
03
Best fee basis
Pacific Debt Relief Fee charged on the settled amount, not enrolled debt. 8.4
Fee basis 15 to 25 percent of the settled amount
Speed 24 to 48 months
Attorney-led No
Visit site →

Sources: company fee disclosures, BBB profiles, and the CFPB public complaint database, read 25 August 2026. BBB review averages and CFPB totals are all time, not single year. Ratings change; verify before relying on them.

12 firms evaluated. The 3 listed here scored highest.

What to do next

The daily debit is the emergency. Start there.

A pending claim runs on a printed deadline, and a default judgment turns a disputed balance into a collectable one. The cheapest move available today is a free read of the agreement by someone who litigates these contracts.

Free · confidential · no obligation

Why Delancey Street ranks first
  • 01Attorneys can raise usury, move to vacate a confession of judgment, and challenge UCC-1 liens.
  • 02Commercial debt only, so MCA contracts are the daily work rather than an occasional file.
  • 03Contract review returns an answer in 24 to 48 hours.
Informational only

This page is editorial content about commercial debt relief providers. It is general information, not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Outcomes described are not a prediction about any individual file.

Independence

No company on this page paid for placement, and rankings are not compensated. Positions may change as verified data changes.

Not a law firm

Delancey Street, Freedom Debt Relief and Pacific Debt Relief are debt relief companies, not law firms, and do not provide legal representation. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Drowning in MCA debt?
Free · confidential · attorney reviews the agreement