ATTORNEY ON CALL · 24/7
212 300 5196
FROM THE DEFENSE DESK / SEC ENFORCEMENT
2 AUG 2026 · UPDATED 20 AUG 2026 · 14 MIN READ · BY TODD A. SPODEK
THE BRIEF · FILED UNDER: SEC ENFORCEMENT
DOCKET NO. 867 · THE DEFENSE DESK

Protecting Executives During Internal Investigations.

★★★★★1,100+ FIVE-STAR GOOGLE REVIEWS
SUPER LAWYERS · 2020-25AVVO · “SUPERB”SECOND GENERATION · SINCE 1976
AS SEEN ON NETFLIX · CNN · FOX NEWS · NY POST

Executives facing internal investigations can help protect themselves by taking key steps such as engaging early independent counsel and conducting a thorough and immediate preservation process. While these and other protective steps are important, executives must also stay mindful that the company’s and executives’ interests can diverge in an internal investigation, particularly with respect to disclosure, blaming specific individuals, and cooperation with the government.

Internal investigations may address a broad range of allegations, from accounting fraud and insider trading to bribery, illegal political contributions, corruption, and cybersecurity allegations. The scope and nature of the investigation will depend on the specific allegations under review.

We engage other law firms when necessary. In the case of internal investigations, Spodek Law Group works closely with Arnold & Porter. BTI has identified Arnold & Porter as an intimidating litigation opponent for 2023, 2024, 2025, and 2026.

We are proud of our lawyers’ and firm’s numerous law-firm rankings and industry awards, and we are committed to continuing to receive similar accolades in the future. However, we strongly encourage potential clients to look past any rankings, awards, and endorsements and instead focus on the specific qualifications and credentials that are most relevant to their unique circumstances. We believe this is more important than relying on any given publisher’s independent ranking. The methodologies used to rank law firms and individual attorneys vary widely, and the ranking of a firm or lawyer in one area does not guarantee a positive outcome in any individual case.

How Can Executives and Other Company Leaders Protect Themselves and Others in Internal Investigations?

Executives and other company leaders can protect themselves and others in internal investigations by doing the following:

  • Engagements for early separate counsel
  • Swift and thorough document preservation
  • Deliberate privilege and cooperation strategies

When Should an Executive Hire Counsel Separate from the Company?

Executives who are being interviewed in internal investigations may need to hire counsel separate from corporate counsel. Here are the main reasons why this is necessary:

Corporate Counsel Represents the Company, Not the Interviewees

Corporate counsel represents the company, not the executives and employees who are interviewed in internal investigations. This means that any statements you make to corporate counsel are not confidential, and you are entitled to no protections like attorney-client privilege. Instead, corporate counsel may provide statements made by executives to the board of directors, shareholders, the government, or anyone else it deems necessary.

Executives’ Personal Exposure May Persist after Company Settles

Internal investigations often target allegations such as accounting fraud, insider trading, corruption, political fraud, and cybersecurity allegations. If the company is ultimately at risk of being targeted by the U.S. government, the exposure of individual executives is not necessarily resolved when the company’s investigation ends. The company may not settle its investigation until the government decides whether to target specific individuals as well. Executives should have independent legal counsel to ensure they are prepared to defend themselves to the fullest extent available.

ABA Model Rules Regarding Conflicts and Dual Representation

The American Bar Association (ABA) adopts Model Rules for attorney ethics. Two of the ABA’s Model Rules clarify the limitations and potential issues with dual corporate and individual legal representation:

  • ABA Model Rule 1.7 (“Conflict of Interest: Current Clients”) says a lawyer cannot represent a client when there is a significant risk that the lawyer’s representation of that client will be “materially limited by the lawyer’s responsibilities to another client, a former client or a third person (or clients, former clients or other persons, as appropriate).”
  • ABA Model Rule 1.13(g) (“Organization as Client”) applies Rule 1.7 to any joint corporate and individual legal representation.

These rules make it clear that while dual representation is permitted in certain situations (so long as informed consent is obtained), it is fraught with potential conflicts of interest, one of which is the conflict where the company wants to cooperate in order to avoid prosecution, while executives will want to avoid criminal or civil liability.

Funding Counsel for Internal Investigations

Executives can fund counsel for internal investigations using corporate funds or D&O insurance, if these sources are available. Delaware General Corporation Law (DGCL) provides for expense advancement and corporate indemnification of executives in certain situations:

  • DGCL § 145(e) allows companies to advance legal fees to executives if the executive undertakes to repay the expenses if indemnification is not available.
  • DGCL § 145(c) mandates corporate indemnification of legal expenses for covered directors or officers if they have successfully defended themselves against allegations of liability.
  • DGCL § 145(g) authorizes companies to purchase Directors and Officers (D&O) insurance for certain liability exposure, including situations in which corporate indemnification is unavailable.

How should executives preserve texts, devices, and personal accounts?

1. Documents and Electronic Communications (ESI)

As noted above, internal investigations focus on reviewing documents and electronic communications (electronic stored information, or ESI), conducting interviews, and determining what is needed for future litigation and/or government enforcement action.

Under Federal Rule 37(e), a court may order adverse inferences (and other remedies) in “lost data” scenarios, i.e., when relevant ESI is lost and the party fails to cure the loss. An ESI preservation duty arises in federal court when a party “reasonably anticipates” litigation.

If relevant business communications are stored on personal devices or in personal accounts, the corporation controls them and they are thus discoverable. While employees are entitled to some privacy, the corporation controls documents in its files, including documents on employees’ personal devices that reflect their work assignments.

2. Preservation Holds

Once a company identifies its preservation obligations, a preservation hold is used to “freeze” the relevant data. A preservation hold ensures relevant communications are not deleted and other employees do not rely on auto-deletion and disappearing-message settings in their email and messaging applications.

3. Targeted Forensic Collections

With employees’ personal devices and accounts, targeted forensic collections ensure that the relevant content, metadata, and any evidence of deletions are preserved. A forensic specialist is often employed for this purpose. A forensic specialist can also analyze bank records and other transactions, digital assets, or other digital evidence that is at issue.

4. International Investigations and Cross-Border Data Transfers

Cross-border data transfers are subject to privacy and data protection requirements in many jurisdictions, including the European Union (EU), where the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) applies. Two key provisions of the GDPR are Article 44 and Article 46:

  • Article 44. “Any transfer of personal data which are subject to the scope of this Regulation to a third country or to an international organisation shall take place only if the conditions laid down in this Regulation are complied with…”
  • Article 46. “In the absence of an adequacy decision, a controller or processor may transfer personal data to a third country or to an international organisation only if the controller or processor has provided appropriate safeguards, and on condition that enforceable and effective legal remedies for data subjects are available.” Article 46(2) explains what constitutes “appropriate safeguards,” including standard contractual clauses.

Should I Agree to an Internal Investigation Interview?

Whether you should agree to an internal investigation interview will depend on your specific circumstances. Along with your counsel, you need to consider various factors in making an informed decision.

But, as a preliminary matter, you should know what you will be facing if you agree to an interview.

1. Upjohn Warning

During an internal investigation, counsel should provide an “Upjohn Warning” to all employees it interviews. An Upjohn Warning makes clear that (i) the corporation owns the attorney-client privilege for the interview, (ii) the corporation can disclose any information from the interview to prosecutors, regulators, or anyone else it deems necessary, and (iii) the interviewee is not entitled to the lawyer’s representation. While Upjohn Warnings are very important, interviewees will also need to weigh various other factors when making the decision.

2. Disclosure of Statements to Prosecutors and Regulators

The key risks associated with an internal investigation interview are that (i) your statements may later be disclosed to prosecutors, regulators, or other parties by the company (which will not be bound by a promise of confidentiality, or, even if bound, may seek to overcome its promise by claiming a conflict), and (ii) your statements may be used against you. For example, if you provide answers during an internal investigation interview that are not consistent with testimony you provide later in a federal grand jury, trial, or administrative proceeding, the government could use those statements against you in court.

3. Right to Counsel

Do you have a right to counsel during an internal investigation interview? Generally, no. While the U.S. Constitution guarantees citizens the right to counsel and protections against self-incrimination (Fifth Amendment) when questioned by government agents, similar protections generally do not apply when interviewed by private-sector companies or nongovernmental authorities.

4. Fifth Amendment Privileges

While public employees may assert certain protections when questioned by nongovernmental authorities, and even then the U.S. Constitution generally does not bar nongovernmental interrogation of private employees, Garrity prevents the use of statements made by public employees who were compelled to speak by government employer threats of job loss. However, the Supreme Court held in one case, 425 U.S. 308 (1976), that the Fifth Amendment does not forbid adverse inferences against parties to civil proceedings when they refuse to testify in response to probative evidence offered against them.

5. Discipline for Interview Refusal

If you refuse to participate in an internal investigation interview, can you be disciplined for doing so? Generally, yes. A private company can terminate your employment or take other disciplinary action, so long as the company does not violate contract provisions or applicable employment law.

6. Grant of Immunity

A company cannot protect you by granting you immunity. Immunity provided by the government in a federal criminal investigation is provided under a specific statutory process, and, as explained in 18 U.S.C. § 6002, immunity granted to a witness by the United States is “not a waiver of immunity or criminal prosecution for any offense by the United States government.”

If you are facing this situation, Spodek Law Group handles federal criminal defense matters nationwide, from offices in New York and Los Angeles.

Does Company Counsel Make the Internal Investigation Privileged?

While engaging company counsel to lead an internal investigation can establish the attorney-client privilege, it will not make the entire internal investigation privileged. The attorney-client privilege is an exceptionally broad protection, but there are several scenarios that will fall outside the scope of the privilege.

1. Document and Communications Review

The attorney-client privilege protects “confidential communications made for the purpose of providing legal advice.” In other words, the privilege protects confidential communications between a client and its lawyer that are made for the purpose of seeking legal advice. If corporate counsel, regardless of whether it is in-house or outside counsel, reviews documents and electronic communications (ESI) generated during business activities, those documents will not become privileged. Instead, corporate counsel’s review alone does not give them the appearance of confidentiality or the purpose of seeking legal advice.

2. Compliance and Audit Work

Compliance and audit work is also not inherently privileged. Similarly, records generated by compliance audits will not typically be privileged. While it is possible that certain audits will be privileged, i.e., if the audit is undertaken for the purpose of providing legal advice or to seek advice related to legal liability, this will not be the case in most routine compliance matters.

3. Interviews

Interviews are a gray area. Employees interviewed by lawyers in internal investigations may have a right to assert the attorney-client privilege depending on (i) their role, and (ii) the context in which their interview was conducted. Generally, interviews will be protected under the attorney-client privilege if they were conducted for the purpose of providing legal advice, i.e., for the purpose of evaluating potential or actual legal liability. If interviews are conducted to ascertain facts that are not related to legal advice or to gather information for a compliance review, the interview will not be covered under the attorney-client privilege.

4. Report for Internal Investigation

Reporting by internal investigation counsel is also highly subject to challenge. While investigations may provide legal advice or evaluate potential or actual legal liability, these reports can also provide substantive, non-legal information. While there is no single authoritative authority on the scope of the attorney-client privilege over report contents, one common argument is to limit reports to the corporation’s decision-makers and to include legal content in a confidential addendum.

To help preserve any potential claim to the attorney-client privilege, companies should establish the purposes of internal investigations early on. The legal advice purpose of an investigation should be clearly documented in engagement letters and documents at the time of the investigation’s inception.

The issue of waiving the attorney-client privilege is a distinct issue. The decision whether to waive the privilege is ordinarily made by authorized corporate management, and executives cannot waive the company’s privilege unless expressly authorized to do so. However, executives need to take precautions not to inadvertently or accidentally waive the corporation’s attorney-client privilege, including privileges belonging to executives and employees themselves.

Can the Company and Executive Share Information without Waiving Privilege?

The common-interest doctrine prevents waiver. The common-interest doctrine protects confidential communications between parties and their lawyers that are made for the purpose of furthering their shared legal interests. While the common-interest doctrine provides a means of preventing a waiver of the attorney-client privilege, it does not create a privilege independent of the attorney-client privilege.

The common-interest doctrine applies whether or not there is a written common-interest agreement. However, for the common-interest doctrine to prevent a waiver of the attorney-client privilege, the party must:

  • Further a common legal interest by sharing communications;
  • Keep the communication confidential; and,
  • Share the communication in order to jointly pursue a common legal interest.

Under Federal Rule of Evidence 502(a), an intentional disclosure made in one circumstance may extend waiver to all other similar communications. FRE 502(a) provides:

“A party can’t use the disclosure to justify waiving attorney-client privilege or work product protection with respect to more of the same material, unless:

(1) the disclosure is one made in a court proceeding, or another party or the court ordered the disclosure; or,

(2) the disclosure was made in a context that makes fairness suggest that the disclosures should be treated as having waived the privilege or protection; or,

(3) the disclosure was made without intent to waive the privilege or protection, and the party has taken reasonable steps to restore the privilege or protection.”

Finally, under Federal Rule of Evidence 502(d), a court can enter an order stating that disclosure of a specific privilege-protected document does not waive the privilege in any circumstance. This type of order is available when a privilege is waived in order to meet an employer’s obligations in government enforcement litigation or administrative proceedings. An individual or corporate party can seek the court’s approval for such an order upon making any reasonable efforts to ensure the confidentiality of the communication.

What Happens if the Company Discloses Findings to the Government?

Disclosure of findings to the government can have serious implications for executives. Executives facing internal investigations will need to consider the following issues in conjunction with their legal counsel.

Voluntary Regulator Disclosure

The risk of voluntary disclosure to a regulator is that it can waive the attorney-client privilege. This is true even if the disclosure was made to the regulator in order to obtain a confidentiality agreement, as this is still a form of voluntary disclosure. While a confidentiality agreement can prevent further disclosure to third parties, a voluntary disclosure to the government can waive the company’s attorney-client privilege with respect to the information disclosed and potentially any other information on the same subject.

Federal Entities

The SEC’s Division of Enforcement investigates potential violations of federal securities laws. The DOJ investigates and prosecutes potential criminal violations of federal securities laws as well. While the SEC investigates potential insider trading and other potential violations of federal securities laws, criminal offenses that carry the potential for prison time are under the DOJ’s jurisdiction. If the Department of Justice is involved, it complicates things. In a federal criminal investigation, corporate counsel will have to make several key decisions regarding (i) the corporation’s cooperation with the DOJ (including whether the DOJ should be permitted to access materials collected and reviewed during the internal investigation), (ii) the DOJ’s ability to charge individuals, and, (iii) the DOJ’s right to pursue charges against the corporation.

While voluntary disclosure can assist companies and executives in avoiding charges, it does not guarantee declination, immunity, or reduced penalties. Additionally, disclosure of materials to the government can expose both the company and executives to private litigation. While documents and communications given to the government are protected from disclosure to private parties, plaintiffs can obtain these disclosures by issuing subpoenas for them.

Oral vs. Written Disclosure

Disclosure to the government can be conducted orally, and even oral disclosure can be a waiver. Oral disclosure can waive the privilege without the need to transfer the documents themselves.

Cooperation Credit under Justice Manual § 9-28.710

The DOJ’s Justice Manual explains several aspects of corporate cooperation, including the DOJ’s cooperation credit policies. Under Justice Manual § 9-28.710, corporate cooperation credit is not conditioned upon the corporation’s waiver of the attorney-client privilege.

Waiver of Work-Product Protection

In addition to the attorney-client privilege, corporate counsel can also lose work-product protection when disclosing a privilege-protected document to an adversary. An adversary is any party with a conflict of interest with the corporation. Disclosing work product to an adversary, even if not voluntary, may lead to waiver of the work-product protection.

Contact a Federal Criminal Defense Attorney

Nothing here is legal advice, and the details of your case matter. Todd Spodek and Spodek Law Group take federal criminal and white collar cases nationwide, from offices in New York, Brooklyn, Queens and Los Angeles. You can reach the firm at 212-300-5196.

LEGAL INFORMATION, NOT LEGAL ADVICE · STATUTES CHANGE - VERIFY CURRENT LAW · ATTORNEY ADVERTISING
THE AUTHOR'S RECORD · PRIOR RESULTS DO NOT GUARANTEE A SIMILAR OUTCOME
Acquitted.
$26M MONEY LAUNDERING
Dismissed.
RICO · 10-YEAR MINIMUM FACED
Six months.
$12M PONZI · YEARS ASKED
ALL RESULTS →
★★★★★VERIFIED CLIENT · FEDERAL CASE · 2022 · VIA GOOGLE REVIEWS
"By the time our free consultation was over, we left at ease."
1,100+ FIVE-STAR GOOGLE REVIEWS →
RISK FREE · CONFIDENTIAL · 24/7

Reading is good. Calling is better.

Answered within 24 hours, guaranteed. Some stories are better told out loud -

212 300 5196
AFTER YOU REACH OUT
01A person answers - not a service. Day or night. 02Free, confidential consultation - ask us anything, regardless of how long it takes. 03Strategy starts the same day - and you hold the senior partner's cell number.
★★★★★1,100+ FIVE-STAR GOOGLE REVIEWS
READ THEM →
INTAKE · PRIVILEGED & CONFIDENTIAL
24/7
01
02
03
04
05
ANSWERED WITHIN 24 HOURS, GUARANTEED OR CALL 212 300 5196
EVERYTHING YOU SHARE IS PROTECTED BY ATTORNEY-CLIENT PRIVILEGE FROM THE FIRST WORD.