Immigration Consequences of a Child Exploitation Charge.
How Does a Pending Child Exploitation Charge Affect My Immigration Case?
Do I Need to Be Deported from the United States Because I Was Arrested for Child Exploitation?
Can a Pending Charge Get Me Deported from the United States?
What Are the Consequences of a Plea Agreement for Child Exploitation for My Immigration Status?
Is an Immigration Deportation Defense Available for U.S. Citizens?
Can an Immigration Deportation Defense be Based on an Arrest Alone?
Can a pending charge hurt me before conviction?
How Does Federal Law Distinguish Between Being Inadmissible and Deportable?
What Immigration Benefits Could I Be Denied as a Result of an Inadmissibility Determination?
What Is the Difference Between Being Ineligible for Admission and Being Subject to Deportation?
What Does it Mean to Be “Deportable” or Subject to Removal from the United States?
Can Allegations and Information Prior to a Conviction Affect My Case?
What Does the Law Say About Detention for Alien Deportees?
What Are the Consequences of Removal Proceedings for Noncitizens?
What Counts as Child Exploitation for Immigration Purposes?
Child exploitation is a broad category that covers a wide range of offenses under the United States Code (U.S.C.). The federal government can pursue charges for everything from child pornography production, distribution, and possession to trafficking, grooming, solicitation, and sextortion. For example:
- Federal Child Pornography Production, Many federal cases under 18 U.S.C. § 2251 involve the production of child pornography. The law applies the same criminal penalties for offenses involving the creation or attempts to create sexually explicit content involving minors, and prosecutors can pursue charges regardless of the extent of the illegal content’s circulation.
- Specified Unlawful Sexual Exploitation of Children, Many other federal cases fall under 18 U.S.C. § 2252A which makes criminal the solicitation, distribution, and possession of child pornography, and any material depicting specified unlawful sexual exploitation of children.
- Communications With Minors for the Purpose of Enticing Them Into Illegal Sexual Acts, The federal government has designated minors as a protected class under federal child exploitation statutes, and attempt liability under 18 U.S.C. § 2422(b) involves communications enticements to commit illegal sexual acts. The law targets both the use of communications to send messages and attempts to entice individuals through electronic communications or other means of communication to commit illegal sexual acts. The key is the age of the minor, and even if the individual is actually an undercover officer posing as a minor, federal law still makes this an offense that can lead to criminal prosecution.
- Recruiting, Enticing, Inducing, Obtaining, Transporting, Conveying, Transferring, Harboring, Persuading, and Sex Trafficking Involving a Minor, The federal government broadly enforces statutes designed to combat the recruitment, transportation, and enticement of children into commercial sexual exploitation, and 18 U.S.C. § 1591 criminalizes the crime of sex trafficking a minor. The statute imposes criminal liability for providing or attempting to obtain any commercial sex act from a minor through force, fraud, coercion, or simply because of the victim’s age.
Which immigration categories do child exploitation pleas trigger?
Which “Crime-Related” Deportability Ground Would Child Exploitation Trigger?
If you have been charged or convicted of a child exploitation crime and you are a noncitizen, your plea must take into account the removal, inadmissibility, detention, and relief rules that will affect you in order to make an informed decision. There are various grounds for deportation based on a person’s criminal record, and many cases can fall into multiple categories. For example:
- Child Abuse, Neglect, or Abandonment of a Child or Disabled Adult, There are specific provisions that can apply to convictions for child abuse, neglect, or abandonment (INA § 237(a)(2)(E)(i)). The issue here can have a broad impact since “abuse” in the immigration law context can include cases where the child did not suffer any injury. For noncitizens, the issue of whether child abuse or child pornography resulted in any actual harm can be one of the most important questions in an immigration deportation case.
- Aggravated Felonies, Many child exploitation convictions are classified as aggravated felonies. Aggravated felonies trigger removal without the possibility of discretionary relief. In addition to these, aggravated felonies also include convictions for murder, rape, child pornography, and sexual abuse of minors.
- Registration as a Sex Offender, Depending on your offense, a conviction for a federal sex offense may require registration as a sex offender. Failure to do so is, in itself, a ground for deportation (8 U.S.C. § 1227(a)(2)(I)).
- Crimes Involving Moral Turpitude, Crimes involving moral turpitude are a separate class of crimes and, in general, crimes involving moral turpitude include theft, fraud, and intentional crimes resulting in serious injury. Because the definition of crimes involving moral turpitude is so broad, many noncitizens who have been convicted of federal crimes are thus subject to removal.
Does Every Child-Exploitation Conviction Trigger Removal?
Not every conviction for child exploitation constitutes a deportability ground under federal immigration law. It can be complex for a noncitizen to avoid deportation, but it is possible. Your defense attorney should be able to advise you about whether your specific offense is subject to removal, or whether you can seek other remedies and protections.
Todd Spodek is the managing partner of Spodek Law Group, a second generation criminal defense firm that has been practicing since 1976.
Why Do Elements Rather Than Police Narratives Decide Removability?
In many immigration cases, the key is to examine the elements of the offense, not to look at the police narrative, testimony, or any other circumstantial evidence in the record. For example, a broader state child-endangerment statute or a child-exploitation statute can create a valid defense to deportation. If the offense is broader than the relevant federal immigration category, then the offense may not categorically match and a plea bargain that takes this into account can lead to a non-removable judgment.
What Is the Categorical Approach for Immigration Deportation Defenses?
The categorical approach to determining whether a conviction matches a grounds for deportability under the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) involves comparing the statutory elements of the offense to the elements of a federal immigration category. If all of the statutory elements of the offense are a subset of the elements of the immigration category, then the offense categorically matches. If the statutory elements are broader than the immigration category, then a plea to the offense cannot trigger deportability, unless the modified categorical approach applies.
What Is the Modified Categorical Approach for Immigration Deportation Defenses?
The modified categorical approach applies in cases where the statute lists alternative elements, such of as age or intent. If one of the alternative elements triggers removal and another does not, then the statutory elements of the offense alone cannot determine whether the person is removable. In order to determine which element controls, then the record of conviction needs to be examined.
What is the Record of Conviction in Immigration Cases?
The record of conviction may include:
- Charging documents;
- Plea agreements, plea allocutions;
- Plea colloquies with the judge;
- Judgments.
The record of conviction generally does not include police reports, trial transcripts, or a person’s testimony.
Do Police Reports Matter for Immigration Court Cases?
Although police reports can matter in a criminal case, police reports do not matter for immigration court proceedings that are resolved under modified categorical analysis. Police reports simply don’t fall within the record of conviction.
When Do Police Reports Matter for Immigration Court Cases?
Police reports can only matter for immigration court cases when themodified categorical approach is not applicable. When a court does not apply a modified categorical approach, it will use a factual approach that is a form of circumstantial evidence analysis. The factual approach is used in some court cases involving noncitizens with criminal convictions, and these cases are very common.
What is a Plea’s Factual Basis and Why Does it Matter?
A plea’s factual basis can be crucial for determining which alternative elements govern the modified categorical analysis. The factual basis will clarify the nature and circumstances of an offense and the immigration court can use this to understand the nature of the crime committed.
Do diversion, juvenile adjudication, or expungement still count?
Do Diversions Count for the Purposes of Deportation for Noncitizens?
Under the INA, a conviction for immigration purposes is defined as:
- A formal judgment of guilt for a criminal offense;
- An admission of guilt for any criminal offense regardless of jurisdiction; and,
- If the judgment or admission does not include punishment or restraint on liberty, a judgment, order, or finding of guilt by a court and a court-ordered punishment or restraint on liberty that results from judicial proceedings.
A criminal offense is the violation of any criminal or penal statute, ordinance, regulation, or any other applicable law. Thus, INA includes any state, local, or foreign conviction.
Do State-Deferred or Withheld Adjudications Count as Convictions in Immigration Proceedings?
Although deferred or withheld adjudications can preclude a criminal conviction under state law, many people are still deported under the INA despite these procedures. The reason is that most of the time, deferred adjudications and withheld sentencing procedures include an admission of guilt. If you have been charged with a federal child exploitation crime, your defense attorney should advise you about whether a deferred adjudication or a withheld sentence is appropriate, or whether avoiding an admission of guilt is possible.
Can a Pretrial Diversion Prevent a Child Exploitation Conviction from Triggering Deportation?
A pretrial diversion program can prevent a noncitizen from being deported because these programs typically end with dismissal of the charges. In order to avoid a conviction under INA, you must make sure to avoid admitting guilt. When you choose a diversion program, your defense attorney should make sure the diversion paperwork avoids unnecessary admissions and statements.
Do Juvenile Adjudications Count as Criminal Convictions in Immigration Proceedings?
The BIA’s decision in Matter of Devison clarified that a genuine juvenile-delinquency adjudication does not count as a “conviction” under the INA. However, if a minor is prosecuted as an adult and convicted of a child exploitation crime, this constitutes an immigration conviction that can lead to removal from the United States.
Do Rehabilitative Expungements of Criminal Records Count as Convictions in Immigration Proceedings?
The INA, as interpreted by courts, does not consider rehabilitative expungement of a criminal record an invalidation of the underlying conviction. Expungement and exoneration are different. Exoneration may remove an immigration conviction from a noncitizen’s criminal history. Rehabilitative expungement, however, can only stop a law enforcement agent from using an expunged conviction against you during an interrogation, not prevent the court from finding a conviction for purposes of removal proceedings.
Can Relief Survive an Aggravated Felony Conviction?
What is LPR Cancellation of Removal?
LPR cancellation of removal is a relief procedure for permanent residents. LPR cancellation of removal generally requires the person to establish at least seven years of continuous residence after lawful admission to the United States. The applicant must establish at least five years of residence as a permanent resident and any other statutory requirements. An aggravated felony conviction bars LPR cancellation of removal.
Can an Aggravated Felony Trigger Detention?
An aggravated felony conviction can trigger mandatory detention under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(c) which makes a conviction for an aggravated felony or certain other crimes “covered” for purposes of INA § 236(c). An aggravated felony conviction can also make the respondent ineligible for bond before an immigration judge in proceedings to contest removability.
Can an Aggravated Felony Conviction Bar Asylum or Deferral of Removal?
An aggravated felony conviction can bar asylum under INA § 208 because it is considered a “particularly serious crime” as a matter of law. It can also potentially bar deferral of removal. Convention Against Torture (CAT) deferral is different. A criminal conviction, regardless of the offense’s severity, will not bar CAT deferral as long as the applicant establishes a qualifying fear of being subjected to torture.
What Are the Consequences of Reentering the United States After Being Removed for an Aggravated Felony Conviction?
Noncitizens who are removed due to an aggravated felony conviction will generally lose their eligibility to return to the United States. Furthermore, re-entering the U.S. without authorization can lead to criminal prosecution under 8 U.S.C. § 1326(a) for illegal reentry, while re-entering with authorization would trigger removal proceedings. Under INA § 1326(b)(2) and 8 U.S.C. § 1326(b)(2), illegal reentry after a conviction for an aggravated felony conviction carries up to 20 years of federal imprisonment.
Is It Possible to Avoid Deportation for Noncitizens with a Pending Child Exploitation Charge?
Depending on the circumstances, it is sometimes possible to avoid deportation for noncitizens who are facing pending charges for federal child exploitation offenses. Although the likelihood of avoid deportation is small, it is worth pursuing in each case. If you have questions about a child exploitation case, call Spodek Law Group and our federal immigration attorneys can discuss your situation in a free, confidential consultation.
How Can a Plea Reduce Potential Immigration Damage?
As a result of a Supreme Court ruling, defense counsel has an affirmative obligation to advise clients of their risk of deportation before soliciting a guilty plea. In exploitation cases involving noncitizens, defense counsel needs to coordinate closely with immigration counsel to discuss the immigration ramifications of the proposed plea. The primary focus for plea negotiations will be either:
- Identifying non-child-abuse alternatives to the charges in play, and targeting a plea to disorderly conduct, or similar charges, if they are available, in order to reduce the immigration exposure.
- Reducing criminal penalties, By reducing a 365-day sentence to 364 days, it is possible to avoid certain aggravated felony classifications.
- Narrowing a plea, A plea to a charge that does not explicitly include the existence of a minor victim can potentially help to avoid a categorical match with one of the child-abuse grounds of removability.
Can Bad Plea Advice Constitute Grounds for Vacating a Criminal Plea?
Yes, bad plea advice from a defense attorney or prosecutor is potentially a ground for vacating a criminal plea. This can lead to the removal of the conviction from the person’s record, which in turn can reduce their exposure to deportation. However, while prosecutors’ and judges’ improper sentencing or plea advice can support a motion to vacate, a conviction cannot be set aside simply because the defendant subsequently regrets the consequences of the plea or the outcome of removal proceedings initiated by the immigration court.
How Can a Plea in Child Exploitation Case Provide Immigration Protection?
A plea in a child exploitation case may be used to provide immigration protection only if it is negotiated in accordance with the relevant criminal and immigration laws and statutes. If the plea allows the defendant to satisfy the burden of proof without triggering an immigration consequence, then a plea is appropriate. If the plea does not trigger any immigration consequences, then you can have a “no-immigration-consequences” plea. If the plea triggers an immigration consequence, you need to make sure to include a provision that expressly forbids or protects against the execution of the corresponding immigration consequence or punishment.
Does a Plea for Child Exploitation Affect Deportability, Even If Convictions for Child Exploitation Don’t Generally Trigger Deportability?
A defendant’s admission to immigration authorities that they committed a federal child exploitation offense can potentially have immigration consequences, even if the plea is for a different offense, or does not result in a conviction. Under federal immigration laws, an admission of guilt to a federal immigration officer or other authorized individual can make an applicant ineligible for adjustment of status, visa admission, and other types of immigration protection. If you’re facing a child exploitation charge, this means that the plea negotiations must focus not only on what you tell the judge, but also what you tell (and even what you admit in) your record of conviction.
Talk to Spodek Law Group
Every case turns on its own facts, and general information is no substitute for advice about yours. Todd Spodek, managing partner of Spodek Law Group, and the firm's attorneys defend federal criminal and white collar matters nationwide. Reach the firm at 212-300-5196.
Reading is good. Calling is better.
Answered within 24 hours, guaranteed. Some stories are better told out loud -
212 300 5196