How Much Do SEC Whistleblowers Get Paid??
The Dodd-Frank Act of 2010 lets the Securities and Exchange Commission pay rewards to whistleblowers who tip them off to a company or person violating federal securities laws. The lead has to be voluntary and original, timely, credible, and has to lead to a successful enforcement that brings in sanctions of more than $1 million. The whistleblowers get a reward equal to 10% to 30% of the money collected in SEC and related actions.
The program has paid out large sums since it began. An important point to note, is that the money to pay whistleblowers doesn’t come from the SEC budget, paid for by taxpayers. It comes from a fund Congress created to receive civil money penalties paid to the SEC by securities law violators.
The SEC has adopted rules to implement Dodd-Frank’s whistleblower rules, and in Sept 2020 amended the rules again. The amendment to the rules created subsection (c) of Rule 21F-6, providing a presumption that the award will be near the 30% maximum when the maximum is $5 million or less. What that means is that when the top of the range is $5 million or less, the agency starts at the top and then makes adjustments down if other factors merit it. Still other criteria described below will be used to determine reward amounts.
Positive Factors That May Increase the Award Percentage Amount
SEC rules provide that the amount of an award will be determined at the discretion of the Commission based on the facts and circumstances of the case. Set forth below are the positive factors that may increase the award percentage amount:
Significance of the information is about how much it helps the SEC. Tips of reliably complete and specific info lead to valuable enforcement actions that help protect the markets against violations of securities laws. Usually that justifies a more generous award. Good evidence also reduces the need for SEC investigative resources.
An informative and timely tip is good. Even better is continued cooperation with the SEC throughout the SEC investigation and any related actions. You can also add to your award by assisting the investigation. When the evidence is complex, explaining the transactions or helping analyze information can help get a bigger award. So can recommending lines of inquiry, introducing other helpful people, and helping recover proceeds. When you do this early on, the SEC can save on the resources that an investigation would take. Any hardships caused by blowing the whistle can also be factored in to your reward.
Sometimes the SEC may raise your award for reasons of law enforcement and investor protection. The SEC can pay more to support enforcement, protect investors and encourage good tips. SEC priority areas matter. Tips on regulated entities or individuals with fiduciary duties are also a big deal, as are tips that expose industry-wide misconduct, serious fraud, danger to investors. The SEC also looks for tips about especially severe wrongdoings, or ones that the company has kept covered up for a long time.
You don’t have to report a violation to your company’s compliance program before or along with SEC reporting, but it may factor into your reward size. However, you’re encouraged to report to company compliance before the SEC. Whistleblowers are encouraged to use the programs by the prospect of a higher reward.
Two advantages of internal reporting first. First, if an internal report is followed by an SEC report within 120 days, the SEC will use the earlier internal report date as the date the whistleblower reported the information to the SEC. Second, if the company investigates and reports the results to the SEC, then the whistleblower may get credit for anything the company finds out during the investigation.
What about internal auditors and compliance officers? Can they report and qualify for awards? Generally no, but these exceptions apply.
- (1) If the whistleblower reasonably believes the disclosure is needed to prevent serious financial harm to the company or its investors;
- (2) if the whistleblower reasonably believes the company is obstructing an investigation;
- (3) if 120 days passed after telling the company’s supervisor, audit committee, chief compliance officer, or legal officer about the violation or misconduct.
Things That Can Lower the Award Amount
And now to the other side: some things that can lower the award amount for an eligible whistleblower.
Culpability can be a big factor. Whistleblowers can share in the responsibility of frauds they report. This can lower the award but still qualify for one. If the person bringing the tip was involved in the wrongdoing, the SEC looks at (1) the character of the whistleblower’s role; (2) background and training; (3) whether the whistleblower acted deliberately to benefit from the misconduct; (4) how much profit it brought in; (5) any relevant past violations; and (6) the egregiousness of wrongdoing. Another big negative factor is interfering with the SEC investigation.
If the whistleblower knew about the violation and was in a position to report or stop it, but had an unreasonable delay in doing so, the award may be reduced. A legitimate reason for waiting to make the tip will be taken into account.
Also, someone making the tip must not interfere with the company’s internal compliance or reporting system. Interference happens if you lie to company compliance staff so they can’t do their investigation, for example, but that isn’t the only thing. A whistleblower who interferes will be subject to a negative award factor.
Rule 21F-6
Unfortunately, the SEC caps the presumption at $5 million, which effectively exempts the largest awards.
An award will not be subject to this presumption, however, if any of the negative award factors listed in Rule 21F-6(b) apply. The negative factors listed in Rule 21F-6(b) relate to the whistleblower’s culpability in or unreasonable delay in reporting the violations, or to the whistleblower’s interference with the company’s internal compliance and reporting systems. The same goes for any whistleblower with conduct considered “culpable” under Rule 21F-16.
In addition, even without any of these negative factors, the SEC may not apply the presumption, and indeed may award less than 30%, if one or more factors justify doing so. For example, if you didn’t help the investigation very much, or if you violated securities laws unrelated to the tip. The SEC looks at conflicts between awarding the highest amount and the public interest, investor protection, and the goals of the program.
When there are several whistleblowers, if one alone would qualify for the presumption, the group’s combined award will amount to the statutory maximum. The 30% maximum is divided among them, not paid in full to each one individually. If there are a lot of whistleblowers with joint awards, which they have to split, they could each wind up with less than 30%.
Under the previous Rule, the SEC would use the positive and negative factors to calculate an award amount between 10% and 30%. The previous Rule had no presumption about award amounts. Under the new rule, the presumption of 30% is now linked to dollar amounts. The new presumption of maximum 30% awards provides some certainty for whistleblowers.
The March 29, 2021 SEC order shows what it takes to drive a split between joint whistleblowers. There, the SEC ordered two whistleblowers to be given the statutory maximum percentage in one enforcement action. The two whistleblowers weren’t awarded the same amount of money for what was awarded, however, because one’s tip was more significant. The SEC uses its discretion over award amounts to reward whistleblowers who help most. It still matters to help the investigation and provide useful information if you want the maximum award.
You should seek an experienced whistleblower attorney’s advice to see whether you might qualify for an award, and what you could do to maximize your award and protect against retaliation. A lawyer can also help explain the protections against retaliation and how to file a proper tip to the SEC.
Reading is good. Calling is better.
Answered within 24 hours, guaranteed. Some stories are better told out loud -
212 300 5196