How Federal Criminal Defense Lawyers Use Jury Consultants
Contents
How Federal Criminal Defense Lawyers Use Jury Consultants
Federal criminal cases can have severe consequences, with lengthy prison sentences on the line. That’s why building an effective defense is so critical. And one key tool defense attorneys use? Jury consultants.
What Is a Jury Consultant
A jury consultant is an expert who helps attorneys prepare for trial by providing insight into how jurors think and make decisions. They use social science research and their own experience to advise lawyers on jury selection, case themes, witness preparation, and other trial strategy issues.
Jury consultants got their start in high-profile civil cases, but today they are commonly used in complex federal white collar criminal prosecutions as well. Top federal criminal defense attorneys rely on consultants to help them read the jury and maximize the chances of an acquittal.
Why Use a Jury Consultant
Federal juries can be unpredictable. So federal criminal defense lawyers use consultants to gain an edge. Reasons attorneys bring consultants on board include:
Mitigating Bias
Everyone has implicit biases. And lawyers worry those biases may negatively impact their client. A jury consultant helps detect and minimize the effects of bias. They identify biases upfront through juror questionnaires. And they advise lawyers on using voir dire (jury selection) to remove potentially biased jurors.
Understanding Juror Psychology
Federal juries are made up of regular people with their own backgrounds, personalities, and decision-making quirks. An experienced consultant understands that psychology. They can predict whether a particular juror is likely to respond well to complex financial evidence, for example. This allows lawyers to tailor arguments and present evidence more effectively.
Case Theming
Consultants help lawyers distill their case down to an easily understandable story or theme. Studies show juries latch onto case themes to organize trial evidence in their minds. A consultant works with attorneys to develop themes that will click with the specific jury selected.
Witness Prep
Even strong witnesses can sometimes flop on the stand. Jury consultants prepare witnesses to connect better with jurors. They use mock trials to identify weaknesses and improve delivery. The goal is credible, confident witnesses that avoid juror alienation.
Reading Jurors
A jury consultant observes juror body language during trial to advise lawyers on what’s landing or falling flat. For example, they may notice particular jurors disengaging during complex testimony. That allows attorneys to simplify and clarify their case presentation.
Jury Consultant Methodology
Experienced federal jury consultants draw on established social science methodology. Common techniques include:
Community Surveys
Many consultants conduct local surveys before trial. The goal is to gauge broader community attitudes and identify themes that resonate in the jury pool area. Defense lawyers use the results to fine tune case themes.
Mock Trials
Consultants often organize mock trials before the real one. Volunteer jurors hear abbreviated case presentations and deliver a verdict. The “verdict” provides a reality check for lawyers to adjust trial strategy. And the mock jury feedback offers insight into juror perceptions.
Juror Questionnaires
Lengthy written juror questionnaires help identify biases early on. Consultants assist attorneys in drafting customized questionnaires with questions targeted to case issues. They later analyze responses to detect any extreme or concealed biases.
Voir Dire Recommendations
Armed with questionnaire insights, consultants suggest voir dire questions and topics to uncover hidden biases. They also track real-time juror reactions during jury selection to provide strike recommendations.
In-Trial Juror Observation
A trained consultant sits in court studying juror body language for clues as to how the case is landing. For example, they may notice when technical evidence causes confusion or boredom. Lawyers use these real-time observations to adjust questions and clarify key points for the jury.
Real World Impact
Skilled federal jury consultants make a real difference in trial outcomes. Take the case of two attorneys charged with obstructing a federal investigation into a cult-like group. The case was complex with weeks of salacious and contradictory testimony.
A jury consultant helped keep the jury engaged through long trial days. They assisted in simplifying technical elements of the law. And they provided feedback allowing lawyers to clarify confusing aspects of the prosecution’s timeline.
In the end, both defendants were acquitted on all charges. The jury feedback showed the consultant’s work kept them attentive and avoided confusion. The attorneys credited the not guilty verdicts to the consultant’s critical insights.
Finding the Right Consultant
Not all jury consultants are created equal. It’s important to find someone with federal criminal trial experience and social science expertise. Reputation matters too. The top consultants stay up to date on the latest academic studies. And they have a sixth sense for reading the jury room.
Experience working with diverse juries is also key. Federal juries draw from a wide population pool. A seasoned consultant understands how cultural differences impact juror perceptions. And they can advise lawyers on avoiding alienating certain demographics.
The right jury consultant acts as an invaluable resource. Their perspective arms federal defense attorneys with the tools and strategies to overcome tough odds. In complex white-collar prosecutions, that insider view into the jury box can make all the difference.