Criminal Defense Lawyers

Fighting Federal Subpoenas on Fifth Amendment Grounds: When You Can Stay Silent

Fighting Federal Subpoenas on Fifth Amendment Grounds: When You Can Stay Silent

Dealing with a federal subpoena can be intimidating. You may feel compelled to provide information or testify even if doing so could implicate your rights. However, the Fifth Amendment gives you the right not to incriminate yourself. Here’s what you need to know about fighting federal subpoenas on Fifth Amendment grounds and staying silent when appropriate.

Overview of the Fifth Amendment Right Against Self-Incrimination

The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution states that no one “shall be compelled in any criminal case to be a witness against himself.” This means you cannot be forced to provide information that could implicate you in a crime. The right against self-incrimination applies to federal, state, and local proceedings.Some key things to know:

• The Fifth Amendment only protects you from being compelled to testify against yourself. It does not give you an absolute right to refuse to comply with a subpoena.
• The right covers both oral testimony and personal documents/records. It protects against the production of anything that might be self-incriminating.
• The right can be claimed in any proceeding, civil or criminal, administrative or judicial. It applies whenever information sought could implicate you in a crime.

So if a federal subpoena asks you to provide oral or written testimony or turn over documents that could self-incriminate you, the Fifth Amendment gives you grounds to refuse.

When You Can Fight a Federal Subpoena Based on the Fifth Amendment

There are several scenarios where you may be able to stay silent when served with a federal subpoena by pleading the Fifth:You are the target of a federal investigationIf you are the subject or target of a federal grand jury investigation, you can generally refuse to testify or provide subpoenaed documents that may incriminate you. The right against self-incrimination is strongest when invoked by a target.You are a witness in a federal criminal investigation or proceedingWitnesses also have Fifth Amendment rights in federal proceedings. You may refuse to answer specific questions or provide testimony that could implicate you. However, you typically must appear and assert the privilege on a question-by-question basis.You face parallel civil and criminal casesIf you face overlapping civil and criminal cases, you may be able to avoid answering subpoena questions or providing testimony in the civil case by pleading the Fifth. Otherwise statements made could be used against you in the criminal matter.Compliance with the subpoena would require self-incriminationIn any federal proceeding, if compliance with a subpoena would require you to disclose self-incriminating information or records, you can file a motion to quash (block) the subpoena on Fifth Amendment grounds.

How to Plead the Fifth Against a Federal Subpoena

If served with a federal subpoena requesting potentially incriminating information, here are key steps to staying silent:Get legal helpConsult with a criminal defense lawyer as soon as possible after being served with a subpoena. An attorney can advise you on the applicability of the Fifth Amendment privilege and next steps.File a motion to quashYour attorney can file a motion to quash or modify the subpoena based on Fifth Amendment objections. This asks the court to block or limit the subpoena to protect your rights.Assert the privilege clearlyIf your motion fails and you have to comply with the subpoena, you must explicitly state when asked to provide particular information that you are refusing to answer based on Fifth Amendment privilege. Simply staying silent without explanation often won’t suffice.Get an immunity orderIf the court rejects your Fifth Amendment claim, request an order of immunity from prosecution. This protects your compelled statements or evidence from later being used against you.Risk being held in contempt of courtIf you refuse to comply with a subpoena after a court rejects your Fifth Amendment argument, you could potentially face civil or criminal contempt charges. So relying on the right involves legal risk.

When the Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination Does NOT Apply

There are also certain situations where you cannot plead the Fifth in response to a federal subpoena:

• If you have been granted immunity: Immunity removes the threat of prosecution based on your compelled statements. So the Fifth Amendment no longer applies.
• Business/corporate records: The Fifth Amendment only covers personal papers. Business entities cannot claim a right against self-incrimination.
• Required records: The Fifth Amendment does not allow refusing to provide required tax statements, regulated records, or mandatory reports.

So think carefully when fighting a federal subpoena on Fifth Amendment grounds. While you have a right against self-incrimination, it is limited. Understanding the scope of the privilege is key to staying silent appropriately. Consult an attorney to ensure you assert your rights properly.

Resources

Articles and Guides

• Pleading the Fifth: Your Right to Remain Silent
• Self-Incrimination and the Right to Remain Silent
• Can You Plead the Fifth to Avoid Turning Over Documents?

Videos

{{< youtube R7oyZGW99os >}}{{< youtube B9T0j5xJikw >}}